re: that last post, ive said it before and ill say it again: no one deserves to die (deserving is fake and death is bad) but some people need to be stopped and choose to make death the only way to stop them
I disagree. Pedophiles 100% deserve death.
you are moralizing and weaponizing your disgust in order to construct and justify a category of person you're allowed to murder
what do you think you deserve for this?
Sorry, no person deserves to die, thankfully child molesters and pedophiles aren't human, so this doesnt apply to them.
denying the humanity of people who do horrible things accomplishes exactly three things:
give cover to people who haven't been caught yet by allowing them to use their humanity as "proof" of their innocence
silence any criticism of societal structures and institutions that facilitate those horrible things by putting the focus on individuals who are assumed to be so uniquely monstrous that the ways it was made easy for them are irrelevant
provide a shortcut to dehumanize anyone you feel like killing: simply accuse them of doing a horrible thing
3.a. if you've already established that only an inhuman monster could kill a child, then all you have to do to get people to burn down the jewish quarter is say that jews kidnap christian children to bathe in their blood
3.b. if you've already established that only an inhuman monster could commit rape, then all you have to do to get people to string up a black man you don't like is find a white woman who's willing to point at him while she cries and babbles
3.c. if you've already established that only an inhuman monster could molest a child, then all you have to do to get people to drag gay people behind their trucks is say that since gay people can't have babies, the only way they can make more gay people is by following a nefarious Agenda to "convert" children by molesting them
3.c.a. meanwhile if you try to address the rampant sexual assault of catholic altar boys, you're met with "don't be ridiculous, he's a priest!" (see #1) and with assertions that even if it does happen sometimes, those priests are just infiltrators who don't represent the church and there's no reason to make sure priests and altar boys are never alone together (see #2)
tl;dr: your disgust-based violent politics are not less reactionary than any run-of-the-mill homophobe or racist's disgust-based violent politics
I realized how bad of a take this was after I added my last bit, i apologize for the idiocy i portrayed in my half thought out statements. And I appreciate the way you rebutted this with reasonable statements rather than going hog wild because I said something you didnt agree with.
hey no worries. we've all been there, and anyone who says they havent is either 11 or afraid of their social circle
unlearning our kneejerk reactions is a process, and it's not a linear one. its good to practice thinking before we post, but sometimes thinking after we post just has to be good enough
Engaging in Disgust-Based Violent Politics is just carrying water for Transmisogynists and Fascists
Pedojacketing / Disgust Mongering is always a cudgel used to justify violence against the most marginalized
Black, Jewish, Queer, Trans.....
"Monstrosity" is always a political weapon.
Personally, I've always thought that the best thing would be to create communities where children were Not Allowed, for very, very obvious reasons, and people who realize they SHOULDN'T be anywhere near children can work and live there.
It shouldn't just be 'offshore oil rig' and 'Antarctic research station,' type communities where kids not being welcome is because it's dangerous. An artist colony with a whole bunch of glassblowers, potters and welders who work in the open air, a resort for K-12 teachers on their limited breaks who need time off from kids, an ecological preserve for some species or another that finds smaller-than-typical humans delicious? That's where you keep the non-offender pedophiles.
And the offender ones, well...if there are K-12 teachers, exciting arts n' crafts and dangerous wildlife, there are very, very good reasons for them to stay put, behave themselves and make no attempt to offend again. After all, it would be very unfortunate if someone made a terrible mistake and a horrible accident happened...but if no children were harmed, some interesting art resulted, certain rare animals were fed and some overworked, underpaid professionals got to experience some enrichment, that would be less bad than, say, judicial murder.
And if everyone understood that as a social contract, then the same former offenders could simply participate in mystery-solver night at the resort monthly, thus helping train the K-12 teachers to 'hunt' others like they used to be, enjoying some improv community roleplaying and having a nice, restorative-justice way to help reduce the amount of overall harm in the world.
Plus, people who tried to complain and demand to speak to the manager out of indignation that they couldn't vacation there with their kids could be told about the rare wild animals, the very dangerous arts n' crafts and THEN the pedophiles. Outranking the taipans n' tigers to a stray HOA board member might simply be better than their previous fixation.





















