Hi tumblr, I bring you my thoughts on the Tadc finale and Jax's character specifically <3
This whole thing comes from messages I texted my friend when we were discussing it so excuse me if the beginning feels a bit disconnected
Talking about Jax, I've seen various trans people I follow, mostly people who are in their 30s or still closer to adulthood than they are to teenagers talk about how they recognize that much of the criticism for Jax's characters and their transness (at least the one that's simply not transmisogyny disguised as criticism) comes from very young queer people that have a very idealized and linear view of transness and "how it's supposed to look like"
When in the real world, that kind of expectations and ideals aren't realistic, and obviously stories don't have to be realistic to be meaningful, but in this case, it feeling so tangible (to me at least) it's what makes it even more meaningful
Many young queer people expect that once you start to realize you're queer and/or trans, the next immediate step to take is to embrace that and fully embody that identity
But, for once, identities aren't static and even more so queer ones, so the first bias to tackle is that need to still fit someone in a box and have them look like, in Jax's case, how one would "expect a transfem person to look like"
When that's still pushing people in labels and boxes and have them conform to your (general you) ideas of what trans people look like, just because it's not heteronormativity doesn't mean that they aren't trying to push a normativity on them, and we're still talking about a character here, but this behavior is well and live in the community itself
And this kind of expectations also push to put a deadline in which a trans person has to fit in to be accepted by the world, with the community itself being part of that oppression and pressure to "not waste time in the wrong body once you realize"
And that's such a harmful rethoric, besides it being actual bullshit
People can transition at any fucking age they'd like, hell they could spend their whole life experimenting, or never settling on a label or feeling the need to explicitly state it
And we rarely see trans people in media as a whole, let alone just like in this case, trans people who are still figuring out who they are and what that means to them
We see Jax as being a personalization of Lee's worst traits and lowest mental state that they've been in, and then, we get to see how the person behind that trauma actually had the chance to grow and is trying to build a life for themselves. At the time of the scan they were 22. Barely in their 20s, and yet just a few years later we're able to see them have a job and a space that they frequent with people that make them feel safe
Us getting to see where each character was in their life in the years after their conception is such a light of hope in this story, the proof that it does get better, even if one may feel hopeless and at rock bottom, it gets better
We saw pictures and posts with Lee smiling and having fun, they have their whole life ahead to figure out their identity, and we as an audience don't need to see that, because at the end of the day, it doesn't concern us what that identity will look like for them, all we had to know is that they're happier now than they ever were in the Circus, and for now that's enough
And obviously this whole deal goes for everyone in there, Grant having a happy family, Abigail opening up and gaining friends, Suzie being in a fulfilling career from her own efforts, Zoey surviving a suicide attempt and pursuing her passion while recovering, Riley holding a safe space for people in their community who might need it
And the characters being able to move on and build a life for themselves inside the Circus after seeing what they managed to overcome in the real life is such a genuine and hopeful ending
They were able to move on and be happy in the world, so they are allowed to grow and be happy and feel fulfilled in the circus too
And sure, it's obviously not a perfect story, but does it have to be this grand overachieving narrative for it to be impactful? I don't really think so, if anything, we really need more hopeful and grounded stories in today's world, we could do with some more hope