I don’t think “no no my idol only accidentally killed thirty to fifty million people! It was negligence not intentional!” Is the compelling defense of his ideology some people seem to think it is
Da context:
That's a lot of people to kill without really meaning to.
Allow me to present life expectancy during the Great Leap Forward (highlighted is that period):
Now, you may be thinking "Okay, that's not actually all that awful! I mean, it is, but like...that could be mostly accidental! It doesn't seem thaaat much bigger than COVID!"
Let me be extremely clear: That graph I showed you? Where life expectancy goes down by almost four years?
That is global life expectancy. That is the life expectancy of the entire freaking world, and the Great Leap Forward is still extremely visible.
This is the same time period, but for China only:
Fifteen years. Life expectancy was fifteen years lower.
Data source:
An interactive visualization from Our World in Data.
Also, separately from how bad Mao actually was, I think the attempted downplaying of the whole category of “things that are ~technically~ better than literal Hitler” here is fucking weird! Like. Ok. Let’s say Mao was better than Hitler, sure! There’s a case for that! There’s even a pretty strong case for that! Even setting aside the extermination camps, WWII was a total war on a level the world had never seen before, and the calculated cruelty of the German Hunger Plan is almost unimaginable! With you so far!
This person seems to be arguing from that that ~because~ Mao was better than, again, literal actual Hitler, the accusations the he was a monster who committed genocide must be overblown. I’m sorry but… what?? When did “well at least he wasn’t Hitler” become any sort of defense???
Seeking desperate refuge in Godwin’s law is not the slam dunk that you think it is, my dude. If anyone is making a serious case that your guy is even theoretically in the running for being “as bad as Hitler” then I think we’ve long since passed the “defendability of a historical figure” event horizon.
















