Aaand here's another ask box prompt meme fic for @medusarealms! This prompt was "Not a ship, but more like family relationships -> The Cackle sisters: Ada Cackle and Agatha Cackle -- 'I do not believe my heart shall ever recover.'â I originally was trying to conceptualize something very earnest and serious for this prompt and then everything took a bonkers left turn and I ended up with a Hackle fic stuffed with a wacky mess of Agatha & Ada shenanigans. (I mean the shenanigans are on Agatha's part, but the themes pertain to their sibling relationship.) Note that there's a lot of consent issues that come up in this fic, but no actual sexual content. Hope you enjoy!
_________________________
Ada and Hecate have been missing each other's signals for six months before Agatha decides to get involved.Â
To be fair, they'd have continued to miss each other's signals for the next ten years if Agatha hadn't taken matters into her own hands. Agatha doesn't even know how much longer than that it might have taken them to acknowledge their feelings, if indeed they ever would have; the draught of future water she took only showed her the next decade. In any case, Agatha is not interested in watching her sister pine away endlessly for a woman who is clearly pining for her in turn. She also finds the prospect of a little spice and drama to be delicious.
So Hecate is surprised one afternoon, upon returning to her potions lab after dinner, to find Ada there waiting for her. Normally if Ada wished to speak to her she'd have summoned Hecate to her office, but here she is, sitting demurely at Hecateâs desk, an empty cauldron in front of her and a variety of ingredients laid out neatly around it. Hecateâs pulse begins to pick up as she takes note of the particular ingredients Ada has chosen. Barrenwort, maidenhair, pomegranate seeds. Bloodred rose petals, oyster hearts. What sort of potion can Ada possibly be making with those? And why is she looking at Hecate that way â a look that's challenging, almost arch? The brooch that normally secures the top of her jumper is missing today, and the top two buttons of her pink dress are undone. All these things flash through Hecate's mind in an instant as she steps into the room. Her mouth has gone dry.
âHecate,â Ada says, not rising from the chair. âThere you are.â
âIs there⌠something you needed, Headmistress?â Hecate says, a little awkwardly.Â
âWell, you could begin by calling me Ada,â Ada says pleasantly. âThat would get us a little further along.â
âOh, Hecate,â Ada says, and laughs lightly. âIâd almost believe you really were entirely oblivious.âÂ
âObliviousâŚâ Hecate feels like sheâs stepped into quicksand, is feeling the ground shift as it begins to swallow her. âOblivious to⌠what?â
âOblivious to me,â Ada says, a bit sharply. âOblivious to my feelings for you.âÂ
Hecateâs jaw drops. She is entirely flummoxed.Â
âSurely you canât really have missed it,â Ada says. âAll this time.âÂ
âIâŚâ Hecate literally canât find a single word more. She makes a little interrogative noise.Â
âIâm mad about you, Hecate,â Ada says directly, one hand playing idly with the dish of rose petals. Then she rises to her feet and begins to move toward Hecate. âI always have been. The same way youâre mad about me.â
âAda!â The word bursts out of Hecate without her consent. She has never been so stunned in her life.Â
âOh, donât pretend it isnât true,â Ada says, her voice lowering conspiratorially now. Conspiratorially and caressingly. âHecate, Iâve spent months upon months longing for you, hoping youâd take the hint, but that doesnât seem to be your strong suit. So Iâm having to take a more direct approach now, Iâm afraid.â
âBut â I ââ Ada is moving closer now. Hecate catches a whiff of floral perfume, and a few odd notes of scent from the ingredients scattered around the cauldron, heady and exciting.Â
âShh,â Ada whispers, now inches away from Hecateâs face. âLet me have this.â
âHaveâŚâ But Hecate can no longer pretend she doesnât know whatâs going on, not as Adaâs face moves in close to hers. Her body begins to press against Hecateâs own, and fire whips through Hecateâs nerve endings. Helplessly, she begins to lower her face to meet Adaâs â
âHecate?â Hecate startles so hard that she nearly falls over as Adaâs voice tears through the moment. Adaâs voice? Adaâs mouth is still closed, her lips just barely parted. What â?
âAgatha!â Now thereâs horror in Adaâs voice. The expression on the face of the woman before Hecate now is complicated â the sullenness of a child whoâs been caught misbehaving mixed with the mischief of a woman whoâs enjoying the chaos sheâs wrought. Mixed with a subtler note of triumph and more than a hint of provocation.Â
Hecate whirls around and sees the real Ada in the doorway. The expression on her face tells Hecate everything she needs to know.Â
âOh, Merlin.â For a moment Hecate thinks she is going to throw up. This is it, her life is over, thereâs no coming back from this â
âAgatha, how could you?â Ada demands, taking several steps into the room. âHow dare you â how you can ââ
âOh, calm down, Ada,â Agatha says, flippantly. âIâm just trying to help you out. You could thank me, instead of turning that unattractive shade of purple.âÂ
âThank you! For harassing my best friend?!â
âOh, come on, now, sister, if she were only your best friend Iâd never have tried to put the moves on her. Well, I wouldnât have done it pretending to be you,â Agatha amends. âIâm not making any further promises.â
Hecate bites the inside of her cheek until it bleeds, trying to wake herself up from this nightmare. She digs her nails into her palms. Nothing. The room stays solid around her, the two Adas still real.
âWhat did you even think you were doing!â Ada is pacing, rhythmically striking her forehead with her palm. She hasnât made eye contact with Hecate yet.Â
âIsnât it obvious? I was helping the both of you along. Since neither of you is capable of acknowledging that youâre mad for each other, I thought Iâd fix things up a bit. Donât worry, Iâd have magically given you the memory of all of this later. Youâd have thought you finally worked up the courage at last, thatâs all.âÂ
âYou would have â you would have ââ
âOh, really, Ada,â Agatha says dismissively. âI canât imagine why youâre acting like you donât know me.âÂ
âBecause youâre appalling! This is â oh, fuck ââ
âAda, swearing!â Agatha laughs delightedly.  âIâm not sure Iâve ever heard you use language like that in my life. It suits you wonderfully.âÂ
Ada stops her pacing and instantaneously spins to face Agatha, raising her hands in one imperative motion. Hecateâs force field blooms between the two sisters just in time; Adaâs spell crashes into it, blue-white and deadly, and dissipates in a shock of electricity. âHecate, let me at her,â Ada snarls now. âWhat she tried to do to you â Agatha, youâve crossed the line before, but this ââ
âOh, letâs not overdramatize,â Agatha says indifferently. âIf it had all worked out as Iâd planned Iâd have handed you the woman of your dreams. There would just have been an element of proxy involved, initially.â Â
âHecate.â Abruptly Ada turns her back on Agatha, rushing to Hecateâs side. âHecate, I canât â I donât even have words to tell you how â how sorry I am, how horrified I am â Hecate, please, donât ââ
Ada is beginning to cry. Hecate stares at her dumbly.Â
âWell, I think Iâve done my share of matchmaking for the day,â Agatha says, sounding bored. Emotional scenes have never been of any interest to her. âWork it out amongst yourselves, but take my advice and finish off what Iâve started. A vial of future water told me youâll be miserable for at least the next ten years if you donât.â With that, she flicks one hand up and disappears.Â
âShe stole a vial of future water?â Hecate says, randomly. Ada, still crying, begins to pace again.Â
âI canât believe she could â even Agatha â the idea that she would â and now sheâs ruined everything ââ
Suddenly Hecateâs mind snaps into gear, honing in on that last phrase. âWhat?â she says, voice unsteady. Ada has stopped pacing now, is looking at her with cowâs eyes. âWhat has she ruined?â
Ada closes her eyes. âAll right,â she says, and her voice is abruptly calm again. âIâm going to count to five and pinch my arm, and when I open my eyes Iâll wake up.âÂ
âDonât bother,â Hecate says. âIt doesnât work.â She takes a step closer to Ada. âWhat has she ruined?âÂ
Eyes still closed, Ada shudders.Â
âBecause â if ââ Hecate gropes for the next words, but theyâre eluding her.Â
âNothing,â Ada says suddenly, savagely. âSheâs ruined nothing at all, because there was never any chance I could have had what I wanted. That I could have had you. Iâm in love with you, Hecate, and I have been since the day we met, and for so long I dreamed â but it was nothing but foolishness, and now sheâs flushed it out into the open and I canât pretend it away, or even pretend to be normal around you anymore. And Iâm sure you can never forgive me, although whether my worst sin is loving you or having the most ghastly sister on the planet Iâm not sure ââ
âAda.â Hecate cuts into this torrent of words, holding Adaâs eyes with her own. âPlease.âÂ
âPleaseâŚ?â Adaâs voice is a whisper now.Â
Hecate clears her throat. âPlease donât.â
âPlease donât what?âÂ
âPlease donât think that,â Hecate says, and then as Adaâs brow crinkles Hecate takes three steps forward and kisses her.Â
The room spins around them, the scent of the various aphrodisiac herbs and ingredients Agatha so diligently collected rising up in the air, enveloping them. Hecateâs hand steals to the small of Adaâs back. Ada makes a muffled, shocked little noise against Hecateâs mouth, then deepens the kiss, pulling Hecate closer to her, standing on her tiptoes to reach. The kiss goes on for a very, very long time. Both women have the idea somewhere in their heads that as long as the kiss lasts, they donât have to talk about any of this.Â
Finally it breaks. Hecate stumbles a step, dizzy; Ada rather shakily leans up against the desk. âHecate,â she says.
âI⌠donât know,â Ada says, a little faintly.  âIâŚâ She tries to find the words. None are forthcoming. Then, abruptly, she smothers a giggle.Â
âAda?â Hecateâs brow is furrowed now.Â
âIâm sorry,â Ada says. âIâm so sorry. Itâs just ââ She chokes off a laugh again, a louder one this time.Â
âSomething is amusing you?â
âNo, no. Only â I just ââ Another giggle bursts out of Ada before she has a chance to stop it. âWalking in on you and⌠myself. I donât think my heart will ever recover from the shock.â Another convulsive laugh. âOh, Hecate,â she says, and now her eyes are wet again. âCan it really be possible that you care?â
âI care,â Hecate says, her voice barely audible.Â
âAnd you â you wish to try â? Iâm so much older than you, really not worthy of ââ
Hecate stops her mouth with another kiss.Â
Eventually this kiss breaks as well, both of them breathing hard. âWell,â Ada says, picking a point at random. âPart of me thinks itâs time to head to the restricted section of the library and look up the most horrifying curses I can find to put on Agatha, and the other part of me thinks I should send her a thank-you note.âÂ
âLetâs not think about her,â Hecate says. âAt least, not any longer than it takes me to find a warding spell to put on myself that will notify me if I have any sort of romantic contact with anyone other than the true Ada Cackle henceforth.âÂ
âAre we to have âromantic contactâ in the future, then?â Ada says, playfully, and Hecate blushes a beautiful deep cerise. âOh, my dear,â Ada says, moving closer and taking Hecateâs hand in hers. âYouâre lovely when youâre a little flustered.â
âI must have been lovely beyond words since the moment you walked into the room, then,â Hecate says dryly.Â
Ada gives her a peck on the lips. âYou have been indeed.â A smile steals across Hecateâs face, and she pulls Ada into a hug, the shorter womanâs head resting comfortably on the black-clad shoulder. They stay like that for a long time, just breathing, enjoying one another.Â
Eventually Ada says, without lifting her head from Hecateâs shoulder, âI wonder how much of what Agatha did today was done because she wanted to be an agent of chaos, and how much was because she actually wanted me to be happy.âÂ
âI can live a lifetime comfortably without ever worrying about Agathaâs motivation in doing what she did today.âÂ
âNot to mention how much was done simply because she wanted to make advances on you.â
âYou heard her. âIâm making no promises.â Weâve always had similar taste in women, I suppose, although sheâd rather corrupt them than ââ
âAda.â Hecate holds Ada at armâs length and looks directly into her eyes. âIf you say one more word on this subject Iâll turn myself into a bat and live the rest of my life roosting in the topmost tower of the castle.â
âWell, we canât have that.â Ada pulls Hecate into an embrace again. âI think there are some rather ingenious curses in some of the older portions of the libraryâŚâ
âThat, at least, seems appropriate ââ
âWe can send the thank-you note in the morning.â