I was watching Shrek 2 and my wife and I were reflecting on how much transmisogyny was in it as jokes (e.g. âgender confused wolfâ âugly step sisterâ âwomenâs underwearâ etc.) and itâs so extremely ridiculous to me the transphobesâ line that having positive representations of trans people (esp trans women) in childrenâs media would be âtoo confusingâ for kidsâbecause they are literally already making references to trans women in childrenâs media, theyâre just doing it in the most offensive ways possible. Taking away all the empty cis rationalization of it, really theyâre not arguing for kids to not see trans characters, theyâre arguing that kids should see trans characters as demonized, fetishized, objects of ridicule and disgust. Like thatâs literally the subtext in these âhow do I explain this to my kidsâ conversations. They really mean âlet me continue to explain this in ways that groom kids into hating trans people and themselves if they are transâ
ThisâŠis a great point
I donât know enough about Shrek to argue, but there is a lot of childrenâs media in which stuff like âputting a masculine person in feminine clothingâ is done for giggles and punishment, and itâs literally something I had to explain to my firstborn child as a small toddler, LIKE.
âWhy angryâ well kid, he didnât want to wear the tutu because⊠he doesnât like ballet.
âWhy laughing?â yeah, theyâre being mean actually. We donât point and laugh, that is wrong. Theyâre being naughty.
Itâs awful. Letâs explain bullying to a toddler who has never been scolded. Letâs explain malicious cruelty to someone who has never witnessed cruelty. And letâs make it repeatedly clear that femininity is humiliating. Itâs very important to the entertainment and stability of society that small children, who barely grasp the usage of gendered pronouns, be shown that wearing clothes for different roles is punishment.
Letâs be real, it is not actually difficult to have a five-word conversation about queerness with a toddler. âSome people have two daddies.â âOur friend is a they.â They really do not care about this. It is not hard. Theyâll listen to you.
But explaining a scene like the one above? Where youâre trying to explain that some parts of society are broken, and we donât copy those behaviours in our house, and we hold ourselves to a standard of decency higher than Peppa Pig? Thatâs hard work.

























