A panphobe claimed âmultiple historical bi activists are against pansexualityâ and used Lani Kaâahumanu as an example. They cited a quote from her book, said âshe pointed out the problem loud and clearâ but âpro-pans arenât ready for that conversationâ and ended with âlisten to bisexual eldersâ and âprotect bisexual historyâ.
As someone who actually read her book and knows a bit about her activism, this made me too angry to ignore it.
This is the cited quote from Lani Kaâahumanu and Loraine Hutchinsâ book Bi Any Other Name: Bisexual People Speak Out:
Bisexual attraction is narrowed to âmen and womenâ while pansexual âopens the possibilities for attraction to more than two genders.â These definitions arbitrarily define bisexual in a binary way and then present pansexual as a non-binary alternative. This opens the doorway to a judgment that pansexual identity is superior to bisexual identity because it âopens possibilitiesâ and is a âmore fluid and much broader form of sexual orientationâ. This judgmental conclusion is unacceptable and dangerous as it lends itself to perpetuating bisexual erasure. The actual lived non-binary history of the bisexual community and movement and the inclusive culture and community spirit of bisexuals are eradicated when a binary interpretation of our name for ourselves is arbitrarily assumed. (p. 16-17)
Left out is that pansexuality is not being criticized in that quote. How resource glossaries define pansexual and bisexual is being criticized. Specifically Exploring the Dimensions of Human Sexuality and Trans Bodies, Trans Selves.
Left out is that the following paragraph states:
The point is to respect one another and remain flexible in the ever changing self-identity landscape. We have to hold a safe space for people to define their personal experience without judgment. There is room for all of us. (p. 17)
Left out is that these quotes are in the same chapter:
Donât âidentity policeâ but DO spend time acknowledging the diversity that exists within the âB in LGBTâ (p. 12) People who are attracted to more than one sex and/or gender â now called variously bi, pan, fluid, queer. (p. 12) All sexual identities including queer, pan, fluid, etc. (p. 13) The term bisexual will be used as an inclusive term to mean romantic and/or sexual attraction to more than one gender, and includes pansexual, fluid, omnisexual, and queer self-identifications. (p. 14) Pansexual people have been actively involved in the bisexual community since the 1970s. (p. 15) We bisexuals, queer people, polysexuals, fluid people, pansexuals, by every name we call ourselves â continue to subvert gender assumptions and explore naming ourselves â by every other identity, to no-identity-needed-or-wanted at all. (p. 21) Whatâs most important is respecting each personâs self-identity and being recognized and understood for who we are. (p. 21)
Left out is that Lani Kaâahumanu said this in 2016:
Iâm so glad Iâm mentoring, and thereâs so many young bisexuals coming up, and transgender people, and pansexuals, and sexuals, and fluids, and whatever you want to call yourself. Yes, do it. Just push it all. Please. (1:47:55)
Left out is that Lani Kaâahumanu cofounded the Bay Area Bisexual Network, which published Anything That Moves, the pan inclusive magazine that the Bi Manifesto came from. The group has since been renamed to the Bay Area Bi+ & Pan Network.
Left out is that the bisexual community has a large, long history of supporting and including pan/mspec identities, one that far surpasses any pan/mspecphobic bisexual individuals.
Lani Kaâahumanu supports pansexuality (and other mspec identities) and self-identification, believes thereâs a place for all of our labels, and encourages people to grow as the terminology for sexuality grows.
But panphobes are taking the words of an almost 80 year old mixed race bisexual activist wildly out of context in order to use her as a tool in a hate campaign against a sexuality she supports.
So, tell me. Who really needs to listen to bisexual elders? Who does bisexual history really need to be protected from?






















