I am sorry. We really going to pretend that Sansa's Northerner identity isn't weak? She was always South facing and has been in the South taking on Southern values and ways of doing things. Also, pretty sure people think she's not a pure, clean Stark because she was her mother's daughter and treated Jon like shit. That seems to be the ultimate test of Starkness. Even when she thinks of Jon she thinks of him as "ONLY her half-brother". Imagine one of the others adding ONLY -.-
Well, first, thanks for assuming Iâm pretty. Though assuming a personâs adherence or lack thereof to a certain standard of beauty correlates to their opinion of a character is kind of a prime example of superficiality, so good job.
Um, also, most of this âtreating Jon like shitâ stuff is headcanon that greatly exaggerates few instances. When Jon says she âonly ever called him half brotherâ, that doesnât mean she added âonlyâ.  The actual quote was ââŠEven Sansa, even though she only ever called him âHalf-brotherâ. She INTERNALLY thinks that heâs âonly a half brotherâ in A Feast For Crows, which is in the context of her thinking about how heâs the only brother she has left and it would be so sweet to see him so⊠Yeah, kind of a moot point there⊠but there is nothing that says she called him âonly half-brotherâ to his face. She referred to him as a half-brother. She also gave him tips on how to talk to girls.
Also! Congratulations, youâre (incorrectly) citing the books, not the show! That post was talking about the show!
Also! In the books, she asserts her Stark heritage numerous times? Like, a lot? A lot a lot? She continually reminds herself whose child she is, where sheâs from. She takes great comfort in the godswood and goes there for solace. Sure, sheâs inclined to Southern practices, but that hardly makes her less of a Stark, as she still maintains and indeeds becomes more and more drawn to the North and their customs as the books go on. She builds a fucking snow version of WInterfell in the Eyrieâs courtyard. Itâs called character development. Bran also wanted to go South and be a knight of the Kingsguard before his accident. Does that make him less of a Stark?Â
Oh, and all of the Starks refer to Jon (internally and out loud) to Jon as a bastard and a half brother at various points. There is absolutely no assertion that Sansa added âonlyâ to Jon in any of her interactions with him. Just that she referred to him as half-brother exclusively, because thatâs how grammar works.
Thereâs no citation of her ever taunting him about it or calling him a bastard. Just that she referred to her half brother as her half-brother. HoweverâŠ
ââIâm Lord of WInterfell!â he cried, as he had a hundred times before. Only this time, Robb had answered âYou canât be Lord of Winterfell, youâre bastard-born. My lady mother says you canât ever be the Lord of WInterfell.ââ â A Storm of Swords.
So yeah, I can imagine the other Starks saying something like that, because Martin wrote it.
Maybe double-check before sending superficial, venomous anonymous messages? It doesnât say much for your own confidence in your arguments if youâre not putting your own name on them.
(Oh, and PS, Arya Stark is every bit her motherâs daughter as Sansa, if not more so)
