I'm thinking a lot about how actually cool the marauders could be as characters, like there's so much you could do about them and with them and water's wet, I'm saying this as a die hard pro-Snape fan.
Like, them being bad people and bullies is not a problem for me, I'm used to liking the villains, heck Tom Riddle is my comfort character. It's the lack of accountability. Most people are going to admit that Snape is a flawed and morally gray character who did lots of awful things and it's generally not a nice person to around. I don't I need to explain how we also acknowledge that Tom Marvolo Riddle is, how do you say it, oh yeah, EVIL.
But the marauders fandom generally doesn't do that, there's this trend of brushing off their misdeeds and not acknowledge the severity (pun intended) of what they have done. The marauders are bullies, all of them. What James did to Severus could be classified as sexual assault in current UK law. The marauders are sadists, they laugh at causing other people pain and misery. Sirius says he wishes it was full moon. James tries pressuring Lily into dating him. They're not nice people.
Now, I'm definitely not saying my favorite characters are better, they never sexually assaulted anyone, but besides that they really aren't.
But I'm okay with that. I'm going to read through Tom murdering and torturing people, I'm going to read through Severus intimidating children, and I'm going to read through Slytherin as a whole being bluntly racist like yeah, that's part of the character deal, we ball.
If you come to me with "group of 1970s teenage wizard boys causing havock with a superiority complex and intimidating anyone who comes their way, while using their privilege backgrounds to go unpunished by the system. Oh, and they're also shapeshifters and at least one of them is a biker." SIGN ME UP. I can totally see it having a The Lost Boys (1987) kinda vibe, I want to see them being the popular jocks and absolutely jerks to everyone around them. And then we have Sirius and James navigating the geopolitical world of Pure Blood families before blowing it all off in the 6th year in the scandal. And then there's the Order Of The Phoenix, and oh it could have been so good.
I can get past the SA thing, really, I can. I keep bringing it up because people refuse to acknowledge it altogether. We always say "I love these characters because of their flaws, not despite of them", but that's not entirely true either. For example, animal cruelty is where I personally draw the line, I don't want to read about it or through it, I acknowledge that Tom killing that rabbit in the orphanage and Severus threatening to kill Neville's toad were truly heinous acts that deserve all the criticism, so yes, I love these characters despite that specific flaw, but I love them because of all the other flaws. It's perfectly fine if you love James and the marauders despite the SA, it's perfectly fine that you don't read or write about it, it's perfectly fine that you love them for all of their other flaws. But we gotta acknowledge that it unfortunately did happen in canon.
But so often I see the marauders as this one kind and happily domestic group of friends and nah, not having that. Also, notice how Peter is conveniently no longer a marauder, and Regulus never was a serious Death Eater in these posts.