so im working on a thought about how often, lately, i’ve seen science fiction dreams of space exploration dismissed as ‘colonial fantasies’ and what i’m thinking on is how readily we fall into the easy assumption that white people are uniquely and intrinsically exploitative (that white people are uniquely and intrinsically anything) and that this urge to colonize (to be exploitative, to consume, to sin) is an inherent property we can’t help but reproduce.
and the thing is it’s really important to think about what colonization entails and how much of the white american dream is built on an incredibly destructive way of life, how much white american ideals revere exploitation, consumption, destruction. it’s important to point out that elon musk’s vision for mars combines all the worst parts of manifest destiny, disney world, and company towns: he wants to build a fucking resort there with indentured servants and he absolutely doesn’t give a shit how many people die along the way so long as he gets his money. that’s a colonialist fantasy. absolutely. fuck that.
but… i can’t believe that the human desire to travel is nothing more than the desire to colonize. that’s like saying the human desire to love is nothing more than the desire to rape. humans love to travel. countless cultures have been nomadic or migratory, and even the most stable civilizations have traders, pilgrims, tourists. we have been travelers our entire history. we love to go new places. we love to see new things. we have looked up at the stars for more than a hundred thousand years; we’ve sailed our ships by their lights for more than ten thousand years; we’ve told each other stories of going out among them for more than a century. we are so close to the edge of the universe, and we are a species of ardent travelers. of course we want to go.
some science fiction is colonial. the desire to space just to plunder everything we can get our greedy little spacesuit gloves on, by all means, let’s interrogate our motives for trying to do that kind of thing. let’s point out that this is a pretty shitty thing to do.
but holy shit, we’re on the edge of the universe. we have always wanted to go. you can’t tell me it’s wrong to want to go and see what’s over the next horizon.