Can we pls have Johnny x Curtis sister? Can be headcanons or like how the brothers would react. I imagine Soda being #1 shipper, Pony being grossed out, and Darry getting strict af.
Soooooo sorry if I accidentally asked for this and forgot
johnny x curtis!reader headcanons
summary: everything that comes with the Curtis’ only sister dating Johnnycakes
content: mostly fluff! feat. the gangs reactions
a/n: this idea was too cute to pass up!
Johnny tried not to like you. He really did, but if the Curtises are known for anything, it’s for how damn attractive they are. It doesn’t help that you’re sweet, smart, and so so caring. To him, you’re golden
He never planned on acting on it either. He had decided to be content with stealing glances when he’d hang out at the Curtis house, and was just happy to have you in his life in any capacity he could
Your feelings caught you by surprise
You were sitting in your living room the chaos of the boys bustling around you. And as much as you loved the gang, it was getting a little overwhelming.
Johnny must’ve been able to tell ‘cause he leaned over slightly, a worried look in his eyes as he asked, “You okay?”
He shook his head when you nodded at him curtly, “Step outside with me?”
You silently followed him out the door to your front porch. The two of you didn’t say anything, just leaned against the railing and listened to the birds chirping in the distance and the hum of cars driving around.
You glanced at him, the light of the setting sun falling around him like a halo. He almost looked angelic. You’d know Johnny your whole life… how had you never noticed how beautiful he was?
Your realization was interrupted by Sodapop poking his head out the door, “Was wondering where you two ran off to. Everything okay?”
“Needed a break,” Johnny explained.
Soda nodded in understanding, “Well, cake’s ready. Come get some before Steve and Two eat it all, okay? You can bring it back out here, but I can’t promise they won’t follow y’all.”
“We’ll be in in a second.”
“I’ll fight ‘em off for ya,” he ruffled your hair, sliding back inside.
You watched your brother walk away, and in a moment of bravery, you reached out to squeeze Johnny’s hand, “Thank you… for this.”
He smiled at you, face hot from the contact, “Anytime.”
Soda is y’all’s #1 supporter. He’s decided to become both of you guys’ wingman and actually played a huge part in setting you up
He noticed y’all making goo-goo eyes at each other and immediately started scheming. Inviting you and Johnny out with him to grab food, and finding an excuse to leave early or step away
Eventually, after the fifth time, you confess your feelings to him.
“Ever notice that Soda always has somewhere to go, even though he was the one who asked us to hang out?” Johnny asked, laughing slightly to himself as he took a bite out of a fry.
“Yeah, it’s… Johnny, I gotta apologize.” You were staring at the table, your face flushed as you twisted your bracelet. “I think… I think he’s doing this cause he knows I kind of… well, I do have a crush on you.”
Johnny raised an eyebrow, jaw slackened as you continued. You- perfect, beautiful, you- had a crush on him?!
“I’m sorry this is so embarrassing.” You buried your face in your hands, “I promise I never asked him to or anything. He just did it? I totally understand if you don’t want to talk for a bit. I’m really sorry, I’ll talk to him.”
Johnny saying your name stopped you as you began to slide out of the old diner booth. Shyly, he reached out to take your hand in his. “You really like me?”
You nodded, still avoiding his gaze, “Yeah, I really do. I’m sorry.”
“Why are you apologizing? I… I really like you too.”
The first thing Dally says after he finds out is, “Forget everything I ever told you about girls. That shit ain’t gonna fly with a Curtis.”
Dally teases him a little bit, but is actually really happy Johnny found a nice girl
Steve finds out when Soda loops him into his plan to get you two together.
At first, he’s pretty skeptical. Soda sees love everywhere… surely, Steve would’ve noticed if something was up between you two.
That is, until he walks into the break room at the DX to see him laughing, genuinely laughing at something you say. And when hair falls in your face in your fit of giggles, he doesn’y hesitate to tuck the offending strand behind your ear, hand lingering slightly
Later, he simply pats Johnny on the back, “So ya have a death wish, huh?”
Steve (believe it or not) has a bit of a soft spot for Johnny and is pretty happy with the pairing
Despite his nerves, Johnny’s determined to talk to Darry about dating you before actually doing anything (Soda eavesdrops the entire time)
It actually goes surprisingly well? Minus the long string of threats on what will happen if Johnny hurts you, is anything other than a perfect gentleman, or gets you into any trouble
Darry has been fearing this day ever since his parents placed you in his arms at the hospital. Some part of him knew it was inevitable for you to date one of their friends. He’s just thanking his lucky stars that it’s Johnny and not Steve, or God forbid… Dallas
He’s still super overprotective. Not necessarily because he doesn’t trust Johnny, but more so cause you’re his baby sister
Anytime you guys hang out at the house, Darry is in the next room and will periodically check in
“Better see those hands above the blanket!” Called out as he leaned the kitchen chair back far enough to get a clear view of you and Johnny on the couch.
You ripped the blanket up with your free hand, showing your and Johnny’s intertwined fingers, “We’re literally just holding hands!”
“Well, do it above the blanket!”
Darry grows to respect how mature Johnny is with you. Always having you back in time for curfew, how good he is at comforting you when you’re upset, the way he always protects you, it all helps him trust Johnny even more.
Pony’s feeling conflicted about the whole thing. Cause yeah, he wants you both to be happy or whatever, but that’s his best friend! His best friend and his sister are… *proceeds to gag*
Unintentionally, third wheels constantly
He will also begin over-dramatically gagging anytime you guys do anything remotely couply in his presence (especially early on… later he’ll develop a tolerance, but if you kiss one time more than he can handle, the overdramatic gagging will resume)
Not to worry tho! Johnny and Pony are still very much best friends
Despite his teasing, he does grow to really support your relationship
Soda chaperones your dates out when Darry’s being too overprotective about the whole thing.
Dally has also designated himself as your chaperone - Darry does not approve of his chaperone tactics
Two-Bit also constantly crashes your dates
You two can practically never go to the drive-in without one or more members of the gang present
Before getting together, you were typically the one to clean Johnny up after fights with his parents. Now you insist on doing it every time, pressing gentle kisses over his bruises as you do so
The first time Darry catches you sneaking Johnny into your room, he crashes tf out
Makes it very clear from then on that Johnny is welcome on the couch, NOT his sister's bedroom
Soda (and Pony to a lesser extent) will still help him sneak in and distract Darry before he can catch you two
Soda is your number one gossip buddy. You always gush to him about the sweet things Johnny does for you and how much you like him. And Sodapop eats that shit up every damn time
You slip little love notes into his pockets all the time that make him melt
You guys always hold hands under tables
If you’re alone, Johnny will press gentle kisses to your knuckles
You’ll typically curl up against Johnny with your head on your shoulder, his arm lazily wrapped around your waist. Darry tries so hard not to notice. Two-Bit is practically vibrating from how hard he’s trying not to (lovingly) tease you
