Bear with me here, this’ll be a really rough draft so there may be some plot holes, idk I’m tired 💔
an AU where Polites survives the cyclops attack, but Odysseus leaves before he wakes up from the hit. He builds his own raft and sails back to Ithaca, but when he gets there, Odysseus isn’t back. (This is like 1-2 years after the war, so Telemachus is around 11-13?)
Penelope doesn’t have suitors yet, since everyone still isn’t sure Odysseus is alive. Except Polites, who reassures Telemachus and Penelope that he is (he has hope!!). + he also tells stories of Odysseus to Telemachus and Penelope to keep their hopes up (but mostly Telemachus)
he’s kinda like an uncle figure to Tele, it’s cute
And uh, the plot for Odysseus stays the same with canon until he gets back home. (except he doesn’t see Poli in the underworld gasp)
Then, after it’s been almost 20 years, everyone’s lost almost all hope that Odysseus is coming back. Obviously there are suitors now, despite Poli’s attempts to reassure everyone, so Penelope asks Polites if he would (platonically) marry her if Ody doesn’t come back and he agrees. ( But she’s still stalling. )
—also quick relationship dynamics
((This might not stay in the AU though I’d like it to, but Penelope, Odysseus and Polites were in like, a polyamorous relationship? But Polites and Penelope aren’t like…romantically into eachother? It’s complicated. They both love Odysseus, Ody loves them but uhh yeah— they love each-other but just not romantically ig. Or, not exactly romantic but not exactly platonic. QPR? Idk. However you want to describe it. (Srry I’m bad at words lmao))
Polites and Penny see the storm and are like “omfg Odysseus” because they know only he could piss off the gods that much 😭
So Odysseus gets back, hears the suitors plotting and starts killing them (Tele and Ody were both disguised as suitors)
(basically just the canon)
when he’s done killing the suitors, before the conversation with Tele ends, he tells him that Polites is alive and with his mom in their room and Ody tells him to let them know he’s back.
ofc they probably already knew cause of the suitors screams 😭 (Polites was keeping Penny company)
Then WYFILWMA happens and they both still love him ofc.
(Somewhat) happy ending!!