A/N: This is such a fun idea I love it and I'm doing it <(￣︶￣)>
Clay x male!reader x Branch
Summary: Reader has attracted the attention of Clay AND Branch, neither brother knows that the other likes reader. Clay tells Viva that he likes reader, and Branch tells Poppy, both Brozone members are to nervous to tell reader on their own, so Viva and Poppy go to each other to ask for help planning a blind date, just to hear that the other was trying to do the same thing. This starts a problem, because both Viva and Poppy think that their respective Brozone member is the perfect person for reader and they will not budge, so they go back to Clay and Branch and tell them the news.
Warnings: Two people in love with Y/N, Clay n Branch are shy, Y/N has to make a decision on who he wants to date, slight ooc trolls ( ≧Д≦)
Extras: I will write two follow up fics on where you choose Clay, and where you choose Branch. If you guys want, I can also write a follow up fic on where you choose neither of the two brothers who are fighting for you!
Clay was staring. Not just at any random thing, he was staring at him. The man of his dreams, the one he's liked since not even Viva knew when. Y/N. He was reading, something that he did pretty often, it was some action or romance of mystery book that Clay couldn't care less about. But... It was Y/N, the man he did care about.
So he offered to read the book too so Y/N could have someone to talk to about it, and Y/N was less to say, over the moon about it. And that's what Clay wanted, so he watched as Y/N read the book. The two agreed to read up 3 chapters every week and talk about them every Saturday. Clay already blazed through them, but Y/N liked to take his time, noting every detail he found amusing, or sad, or anything of the like, in a notebook. He then rambled on and on about them every Saturday.
With Branch, on the other hand, they go on walks, or just do anything outdoors. They go on hikes together, sit by the water, sit in trees, sit BY trees, basically anything outdoors, Branch and Y/N enjoy them together.
That's not even necessarily saying that they talk every time they go out, or that the two even interact after the "hi" when they first meet up, and the little small talk they make before falling into a silence.
The tree leaves rustle from side to side, the ground crunching under their feet, the smell of fresh grass or the salty sea. The beautiful views the two see. It calms Y/N down tremendously to see the views, and he gets enjoyment from spending time with Branch. So it was no surprise that Branch had fallen for him not long after they started their little adventures together.
Now the problem was, neither brother knew that the other likes Y/N. And when the two brothers told their respective sister about it, the sisters vowed to set them up on a date with Y/N. Here's how those interactions went.
"So you're telling me that you..... Like, Y/N?" Viva raised a brow as she repeated Clay's words back to him. She wanted to be completely, 100% sure about what she heard.
Clay just nodded, his face turning a deep shade of red (or teal if you want to imagine them as actual trolls!) Viva stared at him for a couple seconds; silent, blinking. Then her smile grew wide.
"That's amazing, Clay!!! You two would be like, such a perfect match!" Viva spoke way to cheerfully, "Me and Poppy will come up with the perfect date for you two!!"
And before Clay could object, Viva ran off to find Poppy.
Branch started at Poppy while she took in what he had said, that he liked Y/N. Poppy was to silent for Branch's liking, and he opened his mouth to speak but Poppy cut him off.
"That's amazing, Branch!! I'm so happy for you, can I set up a date for you and him? Please, please pleaseeee!!"
Branch blinked before sighing softly and nodding. Poppy jumped up and down with joy before running off to go find Viva.
When Poppy and Viva found each other, the two of them tried to speak at the same time.
"Branch likes Y/N and I need help setting up a date!"
"Clay likes Y/N and I need help setting up a date!"
Then there was silence between them. Poppy and Viva stared at each other for a good couple seconds before Viva spoke up first.
"Well, Clay is closer in age to Y/N, albeit a couple years older... But Branch is a little young for Y/N.."
"But Y/N and Branch spend a lot of quality time together, and Clay only meets with him when he's not busy, Branch drops everything he's doing for Y/N."
Poppy and Viva went back and forth arguing about who would be better for Y/N, and the two of them were getting fed up that the other always had something to say after they finished their argument.
"Ugghhh! I'm so done going back and forth with you, I love you Poppy, I really do. But I think we should just go to Clay and Branch and figure this out."
"I agree, even though Branch is the better candidate..."
Poppy and Viva went and found Branch and Clay sitting down and chatting, Poppy slammed her hands down on the table with anguish.
"You two have to solve your own problems, you both like Y/N and we need to figure out who's going on a date with him because Viva and I are done arguing about it."
Clay and Branch sat in shock, blinking. Branch's mouth gaped open as he stared at Poppy. Clay looked over at Viva, who had a look of disapproval and disappointment on her face as she looked at Poppy. Viva's gaze turned to Clay, and her gaze softened.
"Wait, Branch... You like Y/N and you didn't tell me..?"
"I mean, I told Floyd that if you asked he could tell you.. I didn't.."
Clay looked dejected, and for a while, Branch just sat and stared at him. "How come you didn't tell me that you like Y/N?
"Well I just, I mean, I was busy and we don't really hang out. And when we do hang out the topic never really comes up and I-
"Enough!!" Viva shouted, moving Poppy aside so she can stand beside Clay and Branch. "You two seriously need to figure this out because I'm not setting up a date between both of you and Y/N. What happens if the first date goes really well and he doesn't want to go on the second one with the other brother? I'm not making either of you upset."
Branch and Clay sat still, then they started to make a plan to go up to Y/N when he woke up later that day from his midday nap.
Y/N woke up later that day and stretched, got off from his bed and made himself some coffee. Then he walked outside with his book and sat down in his rocking chair. Then there was four pairs of footsteps.
"Y/N! How was your nap? Lovely I bet!" Y/N glanced over and saw Poppy waving at him. She was the one talking. He also saw Viva, Clay, and Branch walking behind her.
"Oh uh, my nap was good? Do you need something?" Y/N raised an eyebrow and Poppy nodded.
"These two have something they want to tell you!" Poppy spoke with a wide smile as she pointed at Clay and Branch; who both turned a bright shade of red.
"Oh! Uhm, ok! What's up guys?"
Clay immediately got nervous and looked everywhere but Y/N. "Uhm, so basically both me and Branch like you and we both wanted to take you out on a date but we weren't sure if you want to go on a date with both of us so we wanted to give you a decision!" Clay spoke rapidly, and then he looked at Y/N for a couple seconds before he turned away again.
"I- Oh!" Y/N's eyes widened in surprise, and he set his coffee and his book down. He wasn't sure what to say, so he asked if he could have some time to think about it. Clay and Branch left Y/N to think about it, but Poppy and Viva stayed there.
"If you choose one of them, please try not to break the other's heart o bad.." Viva spoke softly, looking over her shoulder at the brothers who were walking away.
"Oh yeah, I would never dream of doing that, they're two of my best friends.." Y/N spoke as he grabbed his coffee cup and book.
"So since you had time to think about it, who did you choose?" Poppy asked, jumping up and down.
"Poppy!" Viva shouted, and she lightly punched her sister in the shoulder.
"It's alright, and I didn't need time to think about it, I just didn't want to make the decision right then and there.. I choose..."
And the story ends!!! I'll have upcoming stories about who you choose later on 😊
