How to know when "take a break" isn't working for your brain
If your dash looks anything like mine, Tumblr is quite fond of telling you to take a break. It says things like "your body needs to rest, it's not shameful" and "don't feel bad about getting nothing done during the pandemic, it's a very stressful time" and "capitalism tries to stop us taking breaks but actually breaks are vital". Unfortunately, it took me a long time to realise that most advice in this vein is absolutely horrible for my brain and it is very damaging for me to be constantly hearing those messages. Here are some signs that you might be a person like me, who needs to either block those posts or mentally reverse the advice.
You do want to do something. Check in with your feelings. If you want to do a million different things but can't decide on one, the solution is to roll a dice. Taking a break and doing none of them will probably just make you sad.
You have been lying in bed for 12 hours. "Take a break, rest is important, don't be ashamed" urges your Tumblr. You have been lying in bed for 24 hours. You need to eat something and don't want to get up and make it. Thinking about getting up and making food is very stressful, so you decide to take another break. You have been lying in bed for 48 hours.
You feel just as tired after lying down as you felt before you lay down, but you feel energised and renewed after achieving something - even something small.
When you are "taking a break", you actually feel compelled or obligated to finish the things that your brain has labelled as "break actions" - eg. you take a break by playing a game of solitaire, and don't feel like you can end your break until after you've beaten the solitaire (even if you kind of actually want to get back to work).
Worse, maybe your break actions feel more urgent and compelling than your work - like if you know that your homework is more important than scrolling Twitter, but emotionally you feel like it is absolutely vital to be up-to-date on all the latest world tragedies via Twitter and have all the correct takes, so when you take a break and scroll Twitter you actually get more stressed out.
You find it very easy and enjoyable to finish a task that you've started, but incredibly daunting to start a new task or to restart a task that you took a break from.
You are trying to "take a break" from basic self-care actions like feeding yourself and using the bathroom. Those actions are actually obligatory and you do not get to take breaks from them, sorry.
You feel afraid of introspecting about your goals, because if you worked hard on the things you're passionate about and really enjoy, then you might have to admit to yourself that it's time to stop doing the daily quests in the phone app you don't even like. You don't want to admit that to yourself. You take a break from thinking about it, and go do your daily quests in the phone app you don't even like.
You are afraid of coming back from breaks because you drag them out so long, you're scared of replying to people's emails and messages - you find yourself constantly writing "sorry it took so long to reply", then taking another break because that was stressful
Taking a break becomes your only mechanism for coping when work becomes stressful. Don't know how to start a task? Take a break! Anxious about getting something perfect? Take a break! Made a mistake and upset about it? Take a break instead of fixing it! Burying all your woes in Solitaire is not a healthy kind of "taking breaks" - it is just encountering a problem and responding by giving up.
You find that your breaks inevitably get longer, and harder to come back from, every time you take one
You find yourself nodding along to a "rest is vital and breaks are important!" post and decide that you're taking a break, despite the fact that you have done zero work in a week and aren't taking a break from anything at this point
You are using "I just need a short break" as an excuse to avoid pressure whenever anyone asks about your work, because you are ashamed and uncomfortable
You find that your idea of what is normal is very malleable; it used to be easy to work 12-hour days when you considered it normal and expected and just did it... but now you expect to need a break after 30 minutes of work, suddenly your brain demands one
It feels like you're giving ammunition to the excuse-monster inside your head, who says things like "just five more minutes" and "but breaks are really important" and "can't we just finish this one video" when you're trying to persuade yourself to get back to work - and feeding the monster doesn't feel good
Rest does not make you feel good
Movement makes you feel good
Interacting with people makes you feel recharged and/or inspired
You are diagnosing yourself with burnout when you haven't worked in a long time and no amount of rest seems to be making the "burnout" better
Diagnosing yourself with burnout doesn't feel like relief, or like an explanation of what's being going on, or like finally having a label for something you couldn't speak of - it just feels like feeding the excuse monster, it feels scary
You find it much easier to do work and feel energised when you get out of the bed or room where you've been stagnating, but taking breaks and resting always seems to involve staying put
The unease in your soul is really with yourself, not with the pressure of the outside world
Doing nothing and resting makes you feel very anxious, and you take a break to recover from the anxiety, which feeds a vicious cycle
Think carefully about whether this is you. Many people find that the Tumblr-advice, on resting more and feeling less guilt about taking breaks, is useful and important to them. This post is not aimed at you if you are one of those people. You are not bad for taking breaks. This is purely aimed at the people who are "resting" in ways that actually don't make them happy or rested.
If you think you are one of these people, here are some alternative things to try:
Have tasks that feel productive and exciting, but are very easy to get started on - eg. opening up a Duolingo app and starting a lesson
Try to have lots of things around that make it low-cost to start different activities - for example, roommates who will drag you into the kitchen and ask to cook together, lots of accessible screens (phones and tablets and PCs) with your work in Google docs, and an easily accessible todo list
Instead of finishing a task and then taking a break, leave the very last line of your essay unfinished and then take a break. It's much easier and less daunting to come back and write the final sentence of your essay and then start on the next task, rather than having to come back from a break and immediately figure out a new task. The final line of your essay becomes like an easy starter task that you know exactly how to do, to tempt you back from your break.
Instead of doing 'rest' activities, rotate tasks - eg. alternate working on your website's code and working on your artwork so that you get a 'break' from each type of task while remaining in a flow/work state
Surround yourself with people who treat it as extremely normal to work all day and cook yourself a meal; they should be sympathetic if you express that you're struggling but they should not regard it as the default/normal state of affairs. It is not something your excuse-monster gets to demand. Your excuse-monster is the unreasonable one here, you know it, and you want other people to back you up when you're arguing against it.
Recategorise what your brain thinks of as "rest"; when people tell you to take a break, they are not telling you to lie in bed and play solitaire, they are telling you to work on your novel. Lying in bed and playing solitaire is not rest. It is just not an action that people like us should do.
Internalise that you do not want to lie down and watch TV if it makes you feel bad, and that means you shouldn't do it, no matter how many people tell you that rest is important. You should only do things that make you feel good.
Make a list of things that make you feel good - not the things that are 'supposed' to be restful but things that actually make you feel energised and revived. For me this list includes martial arts and writing poetry and does not include naps or TV.
Do not negotiate with the excuse-monster. IFS does not work on the excuse-monster. The only way to get rid of the excuse-monster is to do the incredibly hard work of actually making yourself feel accomplished enough that the excuse-monster isn't panickedly clinging to its Cookie Clicker high score. The only way out is through.
Instead of resting, indulge. No, I will not lay in bed for another five hours. I will make myself an extra special dessert and a cup of nice tea. It will be nice. It will be worth getting out of bed for. I will treat myself by drinking the tea while I work on my novel (or learn Spanish or write my essay or whatever other task makes me feel good). It is important that the reward for being productive is "I get to eat these delicious biscuits while I work on my essay" or "I get to enjoy this beautiful view at the park while I read my textbook" and not "I did tasks for a bit so now I get to stop doing tasks". Not-doing-tasks is not inherently a reward and mentally categorising it that way will fuck you up.
If you notice a bad routine forming, like scrolling Tumblr for two hours on your phone in bed every day after waking up, do anything to break it before it becomes habit. Uninstall the app. Sleep on the couch. Invite a friend over for an 8am run together. Do not let it become normal, because once it's normal you'll feel like you're being put-upon if you decide to do something good instead, and that's when the monster thrives.
Again, these are ideas for if the standard advice does not work for you. I am not trying to imply that everyone is lazily making excuses to get out of work. I am saying that I have an excuse-monster and these are things I do to try and keep it managed.
I will add more if I think of more later. I mostly just wrote this off the cuff while waiting for my tea to boil. I'm going to get a nice cup of tea to help me through handling my emails!