Because I'm me I have to break down all of these because I love all of these and having to pick one made me lose my mind a little
BEST OF YOU - love the style of music but I skip this song every time I listen to the soundtrack. It serves its purpose as the "happy ending in a high school musical" song. I just like the other ones more. I jam to it when I actually watch the musical though. I think when I think of NPMD songs this one just isn't the vibe that I'm looking for when I want that? Like going to an ice cream shop and you find out they have chicken wings. Also good, but didn't come here looking for it, ya know?
I WILL say though Pete and Steph flirting through the entire song is so freaking cute and I will never get over the way they pose at the end and Pete is just looking at her with the biggest freaking grin I love them-
JUST FOR ONCE - For the record, I FREAKING LOVE THIS SONG. It's the song that actually made me love Ruth but I think that's part of the problem. When I showed NPMD to a friend for the first time I told her "There's a part of the musical where Ruth is either going to become someone you really love and feel bad for or you'll become indifferent." And I was right she started feeling for the character after seeing Lauren perform but
Also "I used to dance..." is forever gonna tug at my heart strings. That was not just a character Ruth was playing you cannot convince me that wasn't just her
IF I LOVED YOU - The reason I show this musical to people honestly. It is one of my favorite love songs in every musical I have consumed. It's partly cause of style and partly cause of the characters and their chemistry I just love it. It's so much poppier than the rest of the soundtrack but that kinda services it if that makes sense? Also Mariah and Joey just sound so insanely good together and I need more duets between the two of them. Their ranges compliment each other perfectly and their voices blend and harmonize so perfectly GOSH
Also Pete completely freezing when Steph says "sure I'm a sapiosexual, you're intellectual" beautiful. Love them
Only reason I'm not ranking it higher is because it's a simpler song. That doesn't do it a disservice it's still one of my favorites in terms of musical love/breakup songs, but some of the other songs in Act 2 boggled my mind in terms of how they made me feel. I think if you asked me a few months ago it would have been higher but it doesn't have the same vibe when you relisten to so many times compared to the others
THE SUMMONING - A fun song truly. The whispery voices layering, the unhinged behavior of the lords in black contrasted with the dread and reverence with which the teens sing at the beginning of the song it's just so freaking perfect. It feels like it's supposed to with the quick shifts from spooky ethereal piano playing to electric guitar and drums. Plus the build up to this song for long time fans of the Hatchetfield Trilogy is just unreal. I was screaming with the audience when I heard Wiggly speak like DUDE this moment was so greatly anticipated. Jon Matteson's acting here is also just such a joy.
HATCHET TOWN - Again, SUCH A FUN SONG. There's so much happening in both the performance and the cast recording. Little character cameos, and FREAKING BRYCE CHARLES. WOMAN YOU BETTA SANG PLEASEEEEEEEEE.
Y'all don't understand how much it meant to me to see a black woman sing in a way that made me feel seen as a black woman who loves music, oh my gosh. My friend and I both had goosebumps. She was magnificent. The harmonies are so beautiful and the voices are so well layered. If somebody asked me about who Starkid is, this is one of the songs I would show them
DIRTY DUDES MUST DIE - ANGELAAAAAA!!! SING ANOTHER UNHINGED CHARACTER'S SOLO AND MY LIFE IS YOURS!!!! This song gave me literal chills. Jaw dropped the entire time my first watch. Friend was utterly speechless. After sitting in the corner for like half an hour trying to figure out what she watched she declared after hating Grace all of act 1 that she now completely loved her which like...yeah. Only correct response to hearing this song. This one was seriously close to being number one for me. If it was longer it actually might have made it but I kind of like that it's not. I like its length. Feels right
COOL AS I THINK I AM (REPRISE) - It makes my eyes water every time. It's such a perfect blend of the songs I love plus a beautiful display of Steph and Pete's love/devotion for each other. As soon as Joey sings " you could call this luck" I have to hold back tears please-
"What if I should go?" "You get to live on" D:
"You'd have to say-" "I know" DD:
"You're not as cool as you think you are." "But you're as smart as I know you are!" DDD:
"Loved you more than the stars above" so you can just shoot me in the heart now actually thanks
Any song where Joey's register drops I just have to know I'm going to feel some very intense emotions. My friend cried when I showed her this song. It just hurts so good and explains them so well