Now that I released the anger at vegans, I only got questions:
Like, is it vegan to have pets? If the point is not using animals isnāt using animals for comfort not vegan? Are service animals vegans?Ā
depends on whether theyāre being exploited. it seems unethical to ābreedā anyone for the sake of companionship or service, or force them to be exactly who you want them to be. that doesnāt mean its wrong to live with someone or care for them.
the power dynamics can be concerning, but iād argue that we need safeguards and a different approach towards our relationships with non-human animals. for example, i live with two lovebirds; iāve seen people suggesting having a single lovebird to make them more dependent on you, and more social with you. that kind of deliberate alienation from their own species seems to be inherently unethical imo.
in my own experiences with interspecies relationships, i also recognise that i (usually) have the power, and i enable them to exercise autonomy as much as possible. i think respect for autonomy is essential to any relationship.
Also what is the future of domestic animals? I know the idea is that as the world goes vegan production of domestic animals would go down until thereās no domestication anymore; but does that mean that domestic animals go extinct or that they evolve into a form that can survive in the wild?
honestly, a lot of these species are unable to reproduce naturally (such as certain chickens), and others couldnāt live happy or healthy in the wild. people might take measures to preserve those species, but i donāt think i could give a perfect answer to this in the present context. certainly, existing individuals should be supported to live happy and healthy lives.
either way, this question is not relevant to whether or not we continue to exploit other species: keeping a species alive doesnāt justify exploitation, harm or murder.
And what kind of world is it in which humans use no animal products? Okay so we get all plant based fabrics, and construction materials; I think the world population would have to go down (world population should probably go down anyway) so production of plant based food and other materials is small enough to be sustainable. Capitalism has to go obviously, thereās no way for humanity to exist with Capitalism anyway, so vegan world has to do away with that. Where are all the animals living? Is this a solarpunk world? I guess it should be, and thereās lots of wildlands, is human production hydroponic? I mean, we need to use as little space as possible (even without veganism production has to occupy little space). What about people who canāt go vegan for medical reasons? Whatās gonna happen to them? What about medicines?
firstly: we are not overpopulated. that is a myth, we have enough to feed everyone but itās capitalism that causes shortages. flesh, eggs and milk are essentially second hand grain - we shouldnāt need more space inherently without that industry.
if we considered non-human species and their rights to land, food, freedom etc. then that would impact planning and how we approach natural spaces and the planet as a whole. i think a start would be making cities/towns not immediately hostile to other species; further than that, making the place actively hospitable to them.
a lot of barriers to plant based diets and lifestyles are not someoneās medical condition itself - often people with the financial resources can be plant based regardless of medical issues. if we agree the abolition of capitalism is necessary for a vegan society, then we have to consider the other effects of it: equal access to resources. further, development of more robust and moral options for such dietary requirements could be expanded without financial limitations. consider lab grown flesh, or fungus replicated dairy (i know that was an idea thrown around a few years back).Ā
Actually, what about medicines? Medicines and other healthcare procedures that no longer use animals, but were created with animal experimentation vegan? Anything created from animal products are vegan, even if they donāt use animals anymore? Petroleum comes from dead animals, are petroleum-derived products vegan? If taking advantage of an animal corpse that died without human intervention can we use the leather of a cow that dies of natural causes?
iām disabled and trans, so thereās a bunch of medication i require daily. within capitalism, my stance is to avoid what i can, and take what i canāt.
i saw your other post about testing also. there are a lot of alternatives to animal testing now, and more still in development. the accuracy of testing on other species is also questionable as is, hence the continuing need for human trials. realistically, without the profit motive driving pharmaceutical companies, iād expect great leaps and bounds in medicine that arenāt due to animal testing - just due to the sharing of information, for one.
What about carnivorous and omnivorous animals? They can eat other animals? If so, why humans canāt? Are our oversized brains too big to kill other animals anymore? Oh, right the modern human brain is the result of early humans discovering cooked meat; is it wrong that we inherited traits caused by meat-eating in vegan thinking? What about sheep? They canāt molt naturally anymore, should we shave them as a service and throw away the wool for natural compost?
we have the capacity to extend moral consideration to others, and so we should. we do not exist within ecosystems, but we instead build on top of them and wear away at them. there is a balance struck in the world between different species, but we arenāt a part of it.
i have no interest in why our brains developed as they did, since that doesnāt affect our morals now. once we were more similar to single celled organisms too - should we take our morals from that?
Am I overthinking this? Heck yeah. Are these questions wrong? No, not really; I donāt think most people realize how alien a true vegan world would be. And I really want answers on medication derived from animal experimentation that doesnāt require animals anymore
yeah, a vegan world would be pretty alien: the marginalisation of all other species is very much entrenched in most of human society, to the point that very little is not informed by it. iād certainly like to see the world without that.
in addition, iād say that most of your questions are more about hammering out the details of moving forward without exploitation. very few of these questions suggest that exploitation is okay, actually.
i did go back and have a look at your post angry at vegans, and iād also add:
there is no ethical consumption under capitalism: we stand on stolen ground, and use roads that cut through the homes of non-human animals; we poison those who attempt to share our foods; we hunt to extinction any that threaten us. that said, i will not normalise the consumption or use of things that inherently require harm, death or exploitation to acquire. in a post-capitalist society, these things would still be harmful. veganism is less about what you do, than your approach to non-human animals as moral subjects. i approach veganism as anti-exploitation across species, and as such, inherently anti-capitalist.
with regards to eggs: birds arenāt supposed to lay ~365 eggs a year, and itās hugely taxing on the body; nor are we entitled to be the beneficiaries of that labour. for their health, itās more appropriate that they eat their own eggs to regain the lost nutrients, and reproduce often enough to have periods without egg laying.
as iāve said above: we arenāt functionally āpart ofā ecosystems. if you would argue that what goes for other species should therefore be acceptable for us, then is cannibalism and murder acceptable? if not, then you agree that human morals are important in guiding our behaviour - why wouldnāt that extend to everyone.