Now that The Vampire Lestat had ended, I thought I'd make a tier list of all of the IWTV/TVL episodes! (Though the only one I found didn't have episode titles so I'll write it out below it as well.)
TVL was such a different show from IWTV, so I wanted to run through that comparison of my own enjoyment/investment with the previous seasons, because I still see all the hallmarks of writing style and core themes that make me love the show across all seasons.
(And, disclaimer if you need it, I loved TVL so if that's not your vibe, I ask you to refrain from going crazy about that?)
Here's the tier list! And I did try to order the episodes within the tiers as well, but some are very close!
S++: S2E5 S+: S3E6, S1E1, S3E3, S1E7, S2E7 S: S3E7, S3E4, S2E8, S1E4, S1E5, S3E5 A: S1E2, S2E2, S1E6 B+: S1E3, S2E4, S2E3, S2E6, S3E2, S3E1, S2E1
You may notice that I do not feel neutral about the episodes of my favorite show of all time. That's probably why it's my favorite show of all time. In my opinion, as a big lover of the craft of theater and someone who sees that in the writing crew, I think every one of these episodes is extremely well-crafted.
In terms of overall patterns:
I definitely already knew that I think Season 1 is the best season in terms of a overall story and consistency. Every episode had me on the edge of my seat following its narrative, no "weak links" really. I apparently struggled to put any of S1 in just "Great" tier. I think I was genuinely just extremely invested in the story focus on Louis' mortal life in NOLA and how he painfully transitioned into vampiric life, the building of the Unholy Family, and the collapse of the Unholy Family. I think I loved the setting of NOLA because of what it meant to and brought to Louis' character, and maybe I'm just a sucker for Unholy Family. Because I am. Maybe it's the core of the whole show to me. I want more flashbacks. S4 now.
Season 2 was great, the new story in Paris was great, but for the sort of personal-mind-preference reasons above I guess the NOLA story spoke to me more. But at the same time, S2 has some of the best episodes in the whole series. S2E5 is a masterwork, it's the star of the whole series in my opinion. It is an incredible stageplay on my screen. Like, Mr Robot S4E7 levels of perfect television episode. (Anyone?) The trial episode and finale are also incredible. S2 works so well because IWTV/TVL are structured around resolution of previous plot points and ideas, and asking the audience to be patient for incredible payoffs. S2E5 pays off a season of foreshadowing, and so do S2E7 and S2E8, and they end up being the best of the show because of that.
It's very hard to rank these seasons because of this.
Onto Season 3/The Vampire Lestat. It follows a similar trajectory to S2 in my mind because the later episodes get more and more gratifying as they payoff their setups, some setups going back to even S1E1. (Writers of Paul scene in S3E7 when I catch you....) I find the progression of tone from beginning to end of S3 essential to S3's payoffs. I think S3E6 is one of the greatest in the series, it delivers the Claudia moment, the Louis and Lestat episode, and the Louis fatal flaw exploration that we have been building up to since S1E1. (Confession booth scene hallelujah???) Everything has been leading up to seeing these three characters as they can be portrayed now. I also think the progression of the Gabriella storyline is so incredibly impacting, and that is also brought to a head in S3E6 with probably the best acting moment in the whole series. (This episode is greedy.) S3E3 is an all-timer, I can't even talk about it, it's, yeah, and it's also where the breakdown of the entire format of S3 starts. And from the S2E5 love you can probably tell I'm an Armand lover, and everything this season of the "Armends" is maybe my favorite of what I've seen of his character. Loved it all.
I guess I did this because I see a lot of continuity in the storytelling style of IWTV that I wanted to honor in this love letter. And I want more. That's my big ask. My biggest complaint with TVL is I want the more that they are clearly planning. Haha AMC. Please.
And shoutout to S3E3 and S3E6 for somehow being the only episodes of this show to make me sob like I was dying. Usually I happily revel in fictional despair, but whatever terrible drug they're putting in Lestat's abuse storylines and Sam Reid's facial acting is hitting me somewhere way too deep. I hope they keep destroying me!

















