The Blue Castle Book Club Chapter 39
I get why LMM uses the 'imp' here, but what is so imp-like about leaving a note? It seems the most sensible act to do in this case? Barney is not there, she cannot talk to him but she needs to give him a reason for why she is leaving him. How else would she communicate that--send smoke signals??? (Btw, were there that many stories featuring runaway wives?)
And so, we finally learn the secret of the Bluebeard chamber.
I suspected Barney was John Foster on my first read, as soon as the 'Bluebeard chamber' was mentioned for the first time. I bet he's John Foster and that room is where he writes his books, that was my thinking. The Redfern connection surprised me, bc I never considered the founder of those products could be a character in this novel. But John Foster I was able to guess. This means that Barney has been in her life before she ever met him or spoke to him. He was the one who showed her the right way.
However, those chemical experiments I forget with each read. Has Barney inherited some liking for chemistry from his father after all? (I presume the 'Dr' in Dr Redfern refers to a PhD in chemistry? Barney prefers writing but one can like, and be good at, more than one thing, sciences and humanities.)
However what I most want to pick on this time (I, too, have an imp at the back of my head) is: how did Valancy know what galley-proofs were and that authors were sent complimentary copies? How could she know about publishing--is this common knowledge and am I just ignorant? I write sometimes but I just post on my writing blog and that's the extent of my 'publishing' experience, lol. Anyway, it's not important. When Valancy felt she was living in a John Foster book, she was literally right (it took strength not to say it when recapping that chapter!). I wanted to say: umm, he is standing next to you.
Valancy was not excited. She had absorbed all the shocks and sensations that she could compass for one day. This affected her neither one way nor the other.
She took up Barneyâs penâand a vile one it wasâpulled a sheet of paper to her and began to write.
How is a pen 'vile'? A pen is a pen. It writes. That's it.
Sigh, LMM and her obsession with the 'trapped/tricked into marriage' phrase, sigh. Yet, I think Valancy should have added a line about the other patient. "My letter was meant for Jane Sterling of Port Lawrence, Dr Trent mixed them up". I want to make it clear: Barney should not need more than 'it was a mistake' to believe her, and overexplaining is symptom of trauma/not being believed (which would track for Valancy), but I feel it would add more veracity, bc Barney could check that there was a Miss Sterling in Port Lawrence who really died of heart disease. Or maybe that's the Agatha Christie fan in me.
I understand Valancy's reasoning about the pearl necklace. I would not see anything wrong with her keeping it--that 15k will not make a hole in a Redfern fortune. And even if it does, I still wouldn't see anything wrong with her keeping it. But I get her. And I like that she is sorry to give it up bc she likes it. Why would she not liked a pretty pearl necklace?
She put on her hat and mechanically fed Good Luck and Banjo.Â
Good Luck and Banjo are the most unconcerned characters in this book. Atoms bombs are dropping? Give us food.
The little house under the pines looked very patheticâa casket rifled of its jewelsâa lamp with its flame blown out.
Mr Bernard Redfern can light his own lamp when he gets back from wherever he is.
âI shall never again hear the wind crying over Mistawis at night,â thought Valancy. This hurt her, too. She could have laughed to think that such a trifle could hurt her at such a time.