Tumblr Sexyman Subgenres
I've been wasting time and being a freak on this website for 10+ years. I've witnessed the rise and fall (and crash and burn) of empires. And now, as we crest into the dawn of the Poll Era, I'm doing Very Serious Research into the evolution and expansion of the "Tumblr sexyman" label. Behold, my magnum opus on a shocking case of divergent evolution:
Tumblr Classic (Evil Twinks)
Loki (MCU)
Alastor (Hazbin Hotel)
Bill Cipher (fanon human version courtesy of the incomparable @itsscaredycat) (Gravity Falls)
The Onceler (The Lorax)
The 2013/2014 "my ovaries are exploding" forefathers of the genre. Suits or black tie fashion important but not required. Punchable or ambiguously evil, because teenaged you (and possibly adult you) had some kind of a thing for assholes. More rarely encountered than other Tumblr sexymen these days, but certainly not a dead category (hello Hazbin enjoyers).
Wet and Pathetic (Men Who Whimper)
Ryland Grace (Project Hail Mary)
Howl Pendragon (Howl's Moving Castle)
Jesus Christ (The Bible)
Will Graham (NBC Hannibal)
The most direct line of evolution from the classic Tumblr sexyman, and the most conventionally attractive. Set off from traditional heartthrobs by the fact that they are one metaphorical dropped ice cream cone away from a sobbing meltdown, a villain origin story, or a legendary crashout. This is a punching bag of a man that a fandom grips tightly in its fist and shakes around in a mad fit of cuteness aggression. Put that man in the microwave/torment nexus/soup.
Old Men (or middle-aged, or prematurely aged, or whatever)
Stanley and Stanford Pines (Gravity Falls)
Dr. Doofenshmirtz (Phineas and Ferb)
Gomez Addams (The Addams Family)
Senshi (Delicious in Dungeon)
Symptom of Tumblr's daddy issues and aging user base. These men tend to be somewhat more in line with the unhinged-ness of the Classic sexymen—not necessarily evil, but with a slightly higher tendency to be a weird, off-putting little freak than the Wet and Pathetic type. This is probably the result of a more settled identity, which is very attractive to those of us with back problems and a desire to stop masking all the damn time. You want him to take care of you or you want to take care of him (and sometimes taking care of him still means putting him in a hydraulic press, because you're on Tumblr and you can't act normal about your favorite characters).
That is Not a Human (for Monsterfuckers Et al.)
Mr. Ant Tenna (Deltarune)
Bill Cipher (canon version) (Gravity Falls)
Caine (The Amazing Digital Circus)
Kermit (The Muppet Show)
Does this one need explanation actually. This website is monsterfucker central. Includes object head characters, assorted pixels, monsters, aliens, cryptids, muppets, Transformers, faceless entities (you can argue for Cecil Palmer here), and literally anyone else that doesn't fall under the umbrella of "this person could theoretically pass as a human." Most broad and flexible Tumblr sexyman category.
Much like animal classification and other forms of taxonomy, these categories have wiggle room and crossover. (See Bill Cipher's placement into multiple categories above, for illustrative purposes and because I am a Gravity Falls fan who thinks he's neat.) Fellow Tumblr veterans and scientists: comments are open and debate is encouraged. We gotta peer review ts
(Also hiii @mimosa-sexypeople-contests-2026 if you see this please know that poll participants and your followers are the intended audience of this post and that's why it's in the sexyman poll tags. Ily thank you for hosting and enabling all this nonsense <3)
AND NOW A POLL:
Which Tumblr Sexyman subgenre is your favorite?
Classic Sexyman (Evil Twink)
Wet and Pathetic
Old Men (or Middle-aged, etc.)
That is Not a Human Character






















