I'm curious about how Alastor's deal with Rosie works, for numerous reasons, with one of the biggest being in regards to his fight with Vox in the finale of season 2.
Was Charlie saying Vox was the strongest sinner in Hell all it took to make it so? Was it the fact that the majority of sinners (100% of them, if Vox's display is to be trusted) agreed with her or believe it was true, that Vox was empowered by it enough to actually become the strongest sinner?
And if he did in fact become the strongest, and Alastor's deal with Rosie was voided, then how come Alastor still retained his powers after the deal was broken? I know he's still an Overlord in his own right, but I feel like it was implied that his power was largely due to Rosie's deal to make him powerful in Hell.
Rosie gave him powers, and promised to keep him the strongest sinner in hell, and restrained his powers. Vox gained more and more power due to his ratings. His ratings reaching 100% made him more powerful than (constrained) Al. Al wasn't the strongest anymore, so Rosie lost her grip, and with it Alastor's constraints, so he became the strongest again, without the constraints, and without owing anything to Rosie.
But wasn’t Al’s “constraint” due to his staff being damaged? I’m not sure I saw anything that implied Rosie was doing anything to constrain his power, aside from neglecting to fix his staff.
The deal between him and Rosie was clearly broken in that scene, given that cut to her eye’s flashing and the collar vanishing from Alastor’s neck. I’m just wondering why he still possessed the power she gave him after their deal was broken, unless it had something to do with the fact that it was technically Rosie who failed to hold up her end of the bargain?





















