Classic Hollywood influences in Disney's "Beauty and the Beast"
I’ve posted about this before, but I want to post about it again.
Disney's Beauty and the Beast is filled with subtle influences from classic Hollywood movies, especially musicals. More so than any other Disney animated feature that came beforehand.
Some of these you'll see cited in many places on the Internet. Others I noticed all by myself.
*Katharine Hepburn
Screenwriter Linda Woolverton has often cited Katharine Hepburn as an influence on Belle's characterization, with her intelligent, independent, strong-willed screen persona. Belle's general personality as a headstrong, free-spirited bookworm draws inspiration from Hepburn's portrayal of Jo in the 1933 version of Little Women (albeit less tomboyish), while her snappy arguments with the Beast in their early scenes were inspired by Hepburn's similar bickering with Spencer Tracy in their romantic comedies.
*Audrey Hepburn, Natalie Wood, Elizabeth Taylor, Ava Gardner, Vivian Leigh
While Katharine Hepburn influenced Belle's personality, these classic Hollywood brunette beauties influenced her appearance. Ava Gardner was reporttedly the strongest influence on early concept art of Belle, while Audrey Hepburn, Natalie Wood, Elizabeth Taylor, and Vivian Leigh influenced the way her design evolved. Photos of these actresses were allegedly displayed in the studio for the animators to literally draw inspiration from. The design of Belle's golden ballgown was also influenced by the gown Audrey Hepburn wears at the beginning of Roman Holiday, which reads as white in the black-and-white film, but which was, in fact, golden.
*The Wizard of Oz
Besides the above-mentioned movie stars, Belle also looks a bit like a young Judy Garland, with her brown hair and soft rounded face, and her blue and white peasant dress looks similar to Dorothy's iconic blue and white gingham dress in The Wizard of Oz. Appropriately, like Dorothy, Belle is a dreamer who doesn't quite fit into the workaday rural community where she lives, longs to escape to a better place, and then, through unforeseen, uncomfortable circumstances, is whisked away to a magical place where she meets new friends and has remarkable new experiences. Lumiere, Mrs. Potts, and Cogsworth can also be seen as counterparts to the Scarecrow, the Tin Man, and the Cowardly Lion. A trio of loyal friends who provide both comic relief and invaluable help, consisting of an unofficial leader who has most of the bright ideas (the Scarecrow/Lumiere), one who's especially kind and gentle despite being made of a hard, cold substance (the Tin Man/Mrs. Potts), and a comically nervous one who eventually proves to be braver than he seems (the Cowardly Lion/Cogsworth). Last, but not least, we get a Wizard of Oz shout-out when the Beast has his fur styled for his elegant dinner with Belle: his "stupid" hairdo with curls and ribbons looks almost identical to the Cowardly Lion's curled and ribboned mane after his Emerald City makeover.
*The Sound of Music
Belle's stance on a hill with her arms outstretched as she sings "I want adventure in the great, wide somewhere..." is an obvious homage to Julie Andrews as Maria singing the title song of The Sound of Music on a similar green hill. This is fitting, because a close look at the two plots reveal many similarities. In both, the heroine is a passionate, free-spirited young woman who doesn't fit into the conservative community where she lives (as her fellow community members express in song). Then, through unforeseen circumstances, she goes to live in a wealthy new home, where the master is a stern, aloof, and unhappy man. She quickly bonds with the others in the house (the children/the servants), but clashes with the master because she dislikes his attitude and ignores his rules. But just as she's about to leave, a turning point happens (Captain von Trapp hears his children singing and his own love for music reawakens/the Beast rescues Belle from the wolves), and so she stays after all. From then on, she brings new warmth and joy into the household, the master becomes a kinder man thanks to her influence, and they gradually and secretly fall in love with each other. Their growing feelings culminate when they share an intimate, romantic dance. Immediately afterwards, however, the heroine leaves and goes back to her old home (Maria to resist her feelings for the Captain, Belle to rescue her father), seemingly never to return. But her love for the hero ultimately brings her back and they joyfully wed. (Fortunately, in Beauty and the Beast, there are no Nazis to darken Belle and the Prince's newlywed days.)
*The King and I
Whether consciously or not on the writers’ parts, the Beauty and the Beast plot structure mirrors The King and I too. (Of course, some people might argue that in The Sound of Music, Rodgers and Hammerstein rehashed a fair amount of The King and I, just in a different setting and with a different ending.) A strong-willed, intelligent young woman comes to live in the palace of a royal man who is spoiled and short-tempered, yet secretly insecure. At first, they clash, because he tries to command her, but she won’t allow it. But after almost leaving, she gives him a second chance, and before long they gain mutual understanding and respect, and become good friends. Then comes a ballroom scene, in which the heroine exchanges her usual modest clothes for a gorgeous, bare-shouldered hoopskirt gown, and she shares an intimate dance with the hero, making it clear that their unspoken feelings have grown beyond friendship. But directly after the dance, a crisis occurs (Tuptim’s capture/Maurice lost in the snow), which drives the heroine away from the hero, seemingly forever. The hero falls into despair and loses the will to live. But then the realization that the hero is near death (the King of his illness/the Beast threatened by Gaston) brings the heroine back to him, and he dies in peace with her by his side. (Though unlike the King, the Beast doesn’t stay dead.) Both iconic dance scenes also emphasize the moment when the hero places his hand on the heroine's waist. But Disney offers a slight gender flip: in The King and I, the King takes the initiative and puts his hand on the waist of the momentarily shy, uncertain Anna, while in Beauty and the Beast, the Beast is the shy, uncertain one, but Belle takes his paw and places it on her own waist. Still, I suspect that this moment in Beauty and the Beast was meant as a subtle homage.
*Gigi (1958)
Yet another classic Hollywood brunette whom Belle looks a bit like is Leslie Caron, and both Gigi and Beauty and the Beast take place in France and feature a handsome, arrogant playboy named Gaston (the Louis Jourdan character in Gigi), who takes an interest in the heroine. But Gigi refuses to be her Gaston's mistress, while Belle refuses to be her Gaston's wife. Of course, the similarities end there, as the one Gaston ultimately redeems himself and marries Gigi, while the other Gaston becomes a murderous villain and dies. Lumiere’s voice and mannerisms are also clearly based on Maurice Chevalier, who plays the supporting role of Gaston’s uncle in Gigi.
*Frankenstein (1931)
The mob led by Gaston that storms the castle to kill the Beast at the climax recalls the mob that pursues the Monster at the climax of Universal’s classic Frankenstein. Particularly because both the Monster and the Beast are sympathetic, misunderstood creatures, and no mob ever tries to kill the Beast in the original fairy tale.
*West Side Story (1961)
As the Beast lies dying in Belle's arms, the camera angles are almost identical to those of Tony's death in Maria's arms in the original film version of West Side Story. The fact that Belle's appearance was partly based on Natalie Wood must have brought this scene to mind for the animators.
*Camille (1936)
The Beast's death scene also seems to draw inspiration from the famous death of Greta Garbo's Marguerite in the arms of Robert Taylor's Armand at the end of Camille. Even though the characters' genders are reversed, the emotional beats are similar: both Marguerite and the Beast are resigned to their fate because death will free them from their life as a social outcast, while both Armand and Belle insist that everything will be fine. The Beast's "Maybe it's better this way" mirrors Marguerite's "Perhaps it's better if I live in your heart, where the world can't see me," while Belle's "Don't talk like that" mirrors Armand's "Don't think such things." Then the moment of death is conveyed by Marguerite and the Beast's eyes, as they roll upward and then close. Then both Armand and Belle plead "No, no!" and "Don't leave me!" and both bury their faces in their beloved's chest in anguish. The 2017 remake adds yet another shout-out by having Belle plead "Come back!" just as Armand does.
All these homages and influences show that with Beauty and the Beast, the filmmakers weren't just trying to create another fairy tale movie for children, but a romantic musical in the spirit of the Golden Age of Hollywood, which adults could enjoy too. This classic Hollywood spirit was probably a key reason why the film became the first animated feature ever nominated at the Oscars for Best Picture.
@ariel-seagull-wings, @themousefromfantasyland, @thealmightyemprex














