Someone asked questions and. I have issues not trying to answer questions. I also currently do not have functional impulse control bc I am tired. Okay, I never have functional impulse control.
So - uh. I am blundering along, mostly trying to organize my own thoughts. If I seem to overexplain stuff, that’s because of that.
There are tropes and depictions that are harmful - say, queer (1) characters dying off in fiction - Bury Your Gays.
As far as I know, most of the harm comes from the repetition of these tropes.
That said: Appropriate consequences for a content creator using one of these tropes would be… well, some mix of “people not consuming their content”, apologizing, promising to do better next time, and actually doing so unless we’re talking about… idk, say stuff that’s explicitely expousing Nazi ideology, in which case telling people they’re a Nazi is appropriate. And I’m not talking about “and if you view it through this one specific lense were Maybe these things are metaphors” or something like that. I’m talking about either “this is explicitely telling this” or “this metaphor couldn’t be more bloody obvious”
Also, a lot of tropes that often get labeled problematic for fanfic seem to be… fulfilling-fantasies-this-person-doesn’t-want-fulfilled-IRL-y? idk, going with something that squicks me out personally, a lot: Student/teacher fic. As far as I can tell, people tend to like the Forbidden Romance! angle and also often seem to put themselves in the student’s position of “ooh, Glamorous Older Hot Authority Figure!” (that said, if someone who enjoys this can correct me on this... correct me on this) I’m studying to be a teacher, put myself in the perspective of the teacher, consider professional ethics, and get ill at the thought of this. That does not make the existence of student/teacher fic wrong.
Part of the reason why the above is - well, something I don’t think of as problematic is because people, in general, whether reading or writing this, are very well aware this is wrong IRL, AFAIK. Stuff like - I’m aro, so I’m going to give aro examples: People very seldomly getting non-romantic happy endings can hurt, because it feels like I’m not capable of gaining one; people diminishing the importance of friendships in comparison to romantic relationships hurts because this happens IRL, too, is not seen as wrong, and dismisses the most important relationships in my life. Once again, these are mostly harmful not because of any single depiction(2), but because they’re normalized.
Fandom content creators are the wrong people to metaphorically-shout at for being insensitive in a lot of ways, but in easy reach, unfortunately. Not Ever Screwing Up when we’re all living in an awful system, inadvertently soaking up stuff that may be harmful if we pass it on bc we don’t know better, and doing all the research on your own on how to avoid that, maybe if you’re lucky with at most a handful of other people to spot for you, all of this in your spare time, unpaid, is really hard.
Fandom content creators also individually, on average, don’t reach as many people as, say, TV Show Writers. Those also get paid.
So - if we were living in a fairer world, the standards would be higher for people who get paid and reach a large audience, professionals, than for individual fandom content creators. Bc professionals get paid. Of course, then there should be a sliding scale there for “author trying not to drop below the poverty line” versus “movie with literal millions as a budget”; one of those has a much bigger potential research budget than the other.
Leaving awful messages in someone’s inbox generally doesn’t help anything at all, and will probably just harm people.
Moving in the direction of banning discussion and depiction of something in general is also wrong and will probably harm people. IIRC, and through second-hand knowledge... well, “ban all discussion of CSA” on livejournal apparently ended up shutting down survivor groups, which is explicitely and directly harming CSA survivors.
How the identity of content creators impacts stuff is Tricky, bc on the one hand it feels - different, to know something about someone like me was written by someone like me; but also forcing people to disclose bits of themselves they aren’t ready to disclose if they want to discuss them through fiction is wrong? And people in power silencing content they don’t like is. Very likely to happen even if you try to make the best possible standards to prevent this…
I probably forgot something. A lot of somethings. I am tired. Please do not act angry towards me.
(1) I’m not going to discuss me using this. I’m using queer. I’m queer.
(2) And I think leaving awful messages/shouting/etc at specific people for including these things in their content is mean and unproductive. They’re not doing it to hurt me and people like me, they probably don’t even know people like me can exist. That said, talking about How This Trope Can Harm is something I will do, and hope some of those who have written this do listen and - write sth that doesn’t do this next time they write something?