Talk to me about the way Remus views his transformations at different points during his life
This is a broad question, but Iâll do my best. I think Iâll break it down into the major segments for ease.
Early ChildhoodThis portion of his life should really be broken down into two, but the thing that itâs all much of the same: after the initial terror of those very first transformations, the main theme of this portion would be adjustment. Or, more aptly, acceptance.
I donât think it was proper acceptance, though. I think Hope and Lyall went through the stages of grief, and did eventually settle on acceptance after a long time. But the thing about this sort of thing is that you canât face it and say, âI canât change this, so Iâm going to have to deal with it,â because the upheaval makes it hard for people to come to terms with it It takes a long time. I think that they would have just gotten used to it rather than face it head on, even if I believe they did try to deal with it at face value.
I donât think Remus, though, went through the same process. He likely experienced the five stages of grief as well, but for someone so young it would have been much harder to process what was happening to him. Especially since his parents were learning about lycanthropy with him, there was more than likely this period of time where none of them knew how to comfort the others when they needed it most. The problem, of course, is that Remus is experiencing lycanthropy firsthand. But his parents are experiencing it second hand (and Hope and Lyall are further apart even still, with different backgrounds informing their worldviews on the disease). And for a child who had previously known only happiness, that (completely understandable) period in the family could easily have been as traumatic as the first couple of transformations.Â
During this point in his life, I think Remus was confused, and I think he was angry. He has no context for what is happening to him and his life, he has no idea why his parents arenât able to help him in the ways he needs (which isnât to say that they werenât able to help him and that they didnât love him (that means Lyall too)), and I think if ever there were a time for Remus to actually act out and cause trouble that this was more than an appropriate time. He viewed his transformations with terror and anger, I think, something which lessened as he grew older but would not ever go away. (The anger I think he was more able to deal with as he got older, and it changed from âwhy is this happening to me, please make it stop, why canât I stop it, why canât my parents stop itâ to more, âI hate that I have no control over this and that it impacts my life in ways that I could never have predicted or wished on my enemies, and I resent the fact that I will never be able to do anything about it.â)
As the family (and Remus) learned how to deal with their new reality, how to care for Remus and what that meant, they must also have experienced rather quickly that lycanthropy was, sadly, not just about Remus. While Remus was learning about what it meant to be a werewolf, he and his family were learning about what it meant in the eyes of others. The discrimination and hate that they encountered would suddenly be applied to them. Due to the Baader-Meinhof effect, they would suddenly be noticing a lot more to do with werewolves in their daily lives, and the subconscious collective hate the wizarding (and frankly, Muggle) world have for werewolves would be overwhelmingly apparent. Remus, who never had to think of werewolves much before except in stories, is suddenly very aware of how monstrous they are in all the tales. Hope goes back through her memories of legends of the slain werewolves in folklore, and how they would pull whole children from their bellies. Lyall realizes how many mechanisms of hate there are, and the entire family is suddenly aware of how many people think of werewolves as a creature deserving of destruction when their little boy is proof to the contraryâtheir little boy, who now hears stories of how people think people like him should be put to death, or worse.
Suffice it to say, these years are not easy for the Lupins.
Which means by the time Dumbledore comes around, they are naturally defensive and suspicious. But Remus and Dumbledore himself are able to win over the day, entering into phase 2:
This period sees a strange, positive turn around for Remus and how he views his transformations. He enters Hogwarts with the fearful mindset of his parents, purposefully clinging to what is safe and knowing he could be expelled but fearing worse in the form of retaliation from his peers or from society. Skipping over the shock and the slow acceptance of his friendsâ knowledge of his lycanthropy, the mere fact that they didnât abandon him is what I think pushes Remus just a little bit to let them in. They, in turn, continue to be a support that Remus never knew he needed. His parents love and support him unconditionally, but⊠theyâre his parents. But his friends? Theyâre real people who think Remus is really cool, and they make him laugh andâand they want to help. They give Remus the confidence and a new kind of safety net that he needed to explore being Remus the kid, versus just Remus the werewolf. His trust in them leads him to even explore that, tooâto allow his friends to help, to become animagi and to eventually enter a locked room with a fully realized werewolf. The levels of love and trust must have been so deep, so unbreakable, for someone who lived his entire life knowing he would find only rejection to allow these people to literally be in the room with him, one wrong move away from his worst nightmare of killing everyone.
Itâs this confidence Professor Lupin shudders to think about, because it meant that he trusted three teenage boys with his safety and the safety of the entire school while they tromped illegally around the grounds with a bloodthirsty werewolf. We see Remus darken at Siriusâ âI wish it were full moonâ with that salty, âYou might,â comment, but Remus would not have allowed them to be with him or do take him from the Shack if he werenât okay with it on some level because of that trust. (Of course, I think that exchange from them also happens post SWM, so thatâs something to keep in mind as well.) But what I think is most important to remember about this period is that eventually Remus grew from that fearful young child to a young adult who could openly joke about his condition in public (albeit privately). âHeâs sitting in my chair, his nameâs Remus LupinâŠâ.
So as far as what he thinks of his transformations? I think Remus continued to fear them and loathe them, but the cushion provided by his friends meant that he was able to relax. His friends would have challenged the notion in Remusâ head that he was worth nothing because of what he was, and Remus would have been able to look beyond the month to month cycle of living and begin to think beyond Hogwarts. Not only would he have had less terror in dealing with his transformations, but about the prolonged impact they would have on his life as well. He did not like it, of course, but he knew he had his friends to help support him if he got into dire straights and his own efforts didnât succeed, something which he had never had under his parentsâ watchful gaze because they couldnât guarantee it like his friends could.
This certainty was stripped away during the war, though. Certainly when James and Lily went into hiding, but even before that point his friends had become less reliable for transformations through no fault of their own. Everyone understood that the fight came first, and for the first time Remus was dealing with transformations sometimes entirely on his own whereas before he had his parents, Madam Pomfrey, and his friends.
I think this was a time when Remus reassessed his future daily. The stress and the fact that he was once again alone while Moony meant that transformations were much harder, and he probably began to imagine himself as an older man struggling with his joints and the pains his illness left over for far longer than they used to even a year before. Remus fears whatâs to come from him as his human body eventually begins to reflect the damage both time and constant restructuring does to a person.
This is when his friends die. Separately from the grief of their loss, I think this would also have been a blow for Remusâ stability that he was very aware of as well, and I think this is a point in his life where he sees no future for himself. Without the buffer of his friendsâ love and support, I think the insecurities he carried from childhood were allowed to regrow and morph into the very adult fears we see him bear until his death. His friends provided doubtâdoubt that maybe he would be okay and maybe he wasnât a monster. And without them, the reality of it made Remus feel foolish: of course he was a monster, of course he was never going to be okay. More than the transformations, this also meant that Remus faced BEING a werewolf alone. The prejudices he encountered were bearable with a support network, but without one, they were nothing but water to drown him.
This time would have been one of true self loathing, in addition to the fear and the anger.
This part, of course, we can keep short because we know so much. Remus hates his transformations and his greatest fear is still killing someone when out of his right mind. But the wolfsbane potion is a curious invention that he can finally experience for himself, and he wonât deny that heâs curious.
Personally, I donât think he cared for it because of the dysphoria and so on. But I think he loved it, and that was grateful: Remus describes being able to curl up in his office and go to sleep. This automatically tells us that he felt comfortable enough not to go to the Shack (though he probably did for the first while), and we can guess that it was far less stressful on him physically to both sleep through the night and to be whole in the morning. It still took him a whole day or more to recover, which given that these are the mildest transformations from him means that without the potion he would be so much worse off. But I think this must have been a huge burden off of his shoulders, and that there was a time, for a short while, when Remus was okay with what was happening.
This portion of time would again bring up the self-loathing Remus keeps close, but without the wolfsbane potion Remus would have had a hard readjustment period where he remembered very quickly what it was like without. Transforming with the werewolf colonies was probably something Remus loathed and felt disgusted by, and he needed that sense of duty to keep him on the path because the werewolves in the colonies were probably exactly what people had always described werewolves to be. Not that they all were, of course, but according to Remus himself many of the werewolves serve Voldemort because they believe wizardkind will never accept them and that better conditions will never be possible. Violence and theft and all sorts of gruesome things are the reality in these camps because they are inhabited by people who have been given up on, and thus given up themselves. To transform with them and to try and be one of them must have been difficult for Remus, and I think he loathed full moons especially now because it wasnât just a private affair anymore.
Itâs worth mentioning that Sirius is back for a brief time here as well, and while I donât think they went back to their old shenanigans, I think Sirius did accompany Remus on several full moons when they were able to do so and that it helped them both.
Tonks deserves mentioning as her own segment of time, as well, because she brings back the support network that Sirius and the others did long before. She doesnât change what happens to him and so his opinion doesnât change, but I feel like thereâs some new shame that appears when Remus is actually in love with the person who wants to help. Heâs afraid to ask Tonks what she thinks because as an Order member she knows about him. Heâs ashamed to bring it up, and suddenly he doesnât want anyone perceiving that heâs weak when heâs feeling the effects of the moon. I think there was a level of embarrassment here, possibly, that he didnât feel before because it didnât matter the same way with other people. That further drives the spike of shame and self-loathing deeper into his heart, naturally.
But again, this doesnât change how Remus perceives his transformations. Overall, this period during the second war was much like the first, but Remus was better able to be prepared for his transformations on the run because he had had the experience.
So obviously this is just a rough collection of thoughts, and I encourage anyone who wishes to add on their thoughts to do so!