synopsis: you pack up your things and take an impromptu trip to new york to clear your mind of your ex. when shopping and bodega doesn’t help, you’re left to grapple with your feelings and decide what to do when you get back to tulsa.
warnings: this is lowkey the great gatsby, great gatsby references, depression, u thinking like a soc, underage drinking, mentions of death not proofread
that was the day you had ran away(for the second time). that was the day you had booked a last-minute flight to new york and rushed to the airport, all to clear your mind of johnny.
you had packed all your cute clothing and shoes in your suitcase, phone balanced between your shoulder and ear, nearly tripping over the wire as you packed your bags hastily.
“yes, that sounds great. okay, thanks so much.” you said cheerfully as you hung up, selecting the numbers on the rotary phone carefully to tell your few friends goodbye before your sudden departure.
you lugged your fancy suitcase into the backseat of your car, struggling. if darry was here, this would’ve been a piece of cake for him, you thought as you pushed the door shut.
you sighed, mentally chastising yourself as you pulled out of your driveway. don’t think about darry. don’t think about any of the gang, especially johnny. don’t think about his big, dark brown eyes and his caramel skin. don’t think of how soft his hair was when it wasn’t greased and how he’d let you run your hands through it at night.
don’t think about how you’d just saw him less than two hours ago and now you were bolting out of tulsa for how long? a week? two? you didn’t know, but being reminded of johnny was messing you up. focus, you told yourself.
you slammed on your breaks, letting out a yelp as your car jerked still, inches from rear-ending the red t-bird in front of you. you flinched when the car honked, gripping the steering wheel tighter with sweaty palms.
good thing there were taxis in new york, you thought as you stepped on the gas pedal, leisurely driving through tulsa, making sure not to go around where you’d seen johnny. you turned up the radio, the sweet tune of some beach boys song filling your ears as you drowned out your thoughts, humming along to brian wilson’s voice.
maybe, just maybe you’d be okay.
you woke up to the sound of a flight attendant booming over the speaker of the plane, announcing that you had finally arrived in new york. getting up with the rest of the passengers, you exited the first class section as you grabbed your luggage from the overhead compartment and left the plane, inhaling deeply as you stepped off the ramp of the plane.
you took in the beauty of the city. new york was so different than tulsa. tulsa was dirty and loud and country. everyone knew eachother’s business. But here? in this urban megacity? You could do unspeakable things and just be another insignificant person in the city. Hello freedom!
you couldn’t help but think of dallas as you stumbled around the city, attempting to adapt from the new environment. all of dally’s scary, ‘tuff’ stories? they happened here. you shuddered, trying not to remember the details. you hoped he wasn’t still in contact with his buddies in gangs here—or else you’d be in big trouble.
dallas had completely pushed you away after what went down with johnny. you. His ride-or-die. His best friend. the girl who’d dress him up nice and gasp when he fake-proposed to her in public—all for some free dessert. the girl who always paid his bail and never mentioned it. you two were inseparable.
when push came to shove, you knew he’d choose johnny over you. you just never thought it’d actually come to that.
you didn’t blame him—or any of the gang—for how they acted after the breakup. It was your fault. but god, it hurt.
you remembered the first time you had encountered the gang. you had been 8-walking home from school when you came across a group of soc boys fighting with a blonde-haired boy of around your age who was clearly losing. it was 4-1! unfair!
you stepped in. slinging off your backpack and running into the fight. you managed to get between the boys, pushing the soc boys off of the kid and crossing your arms.
“if you’re gonna hit him you’re gonna have to hit me first. and everyone knows boys cant hit girls.”
you said, frowning as you stared down the soc boys.
“cmon, you ain’t defending this little greaser, ain’t ya? how would your momma feel if she knew you liked little runts?” one of the boys piped up, snickering and stepping up.
“scram!” you said, firmly holding your ground until the boys gave up, riding away on their bikes.
you turned to the blonde haired boy, studying him. he was skinny and pale, in dirtied jeans and a jean jacket with a silver necklace on.
“i would’ve won that fight, yknow.” the boy mumbled in a thick accent, bashfully looking away.
“you talk funny. are you a yankee? what’s this?” you curiously inquired as you reached to grab his st. christopher’s pendant before he grabbed ur hand, pushing it away.
“don’t touch it! and i ain’t no yankee. im dallas”
“yes you are! yankee-doodle dallas”
you called as you giggled, grabbing his hand and dragging the scraggly boy along the street, handing him your backpack.
“carry that. i helped you so you have to.” you commanded.
“hey, man! where are you dragging me?”
“home! it’s cold and i have hot chocolate and like so many blankets. cmon!” you said excitedly.
and from that day on, you were cool with dallas winston.
you remembered when the gang had returned the favor.
you were 14, walking home from school again when a pair of soc boys walked out of a convenience store, tackling you from behind. you screamed.
“aww look, the little soc girl can’t fight?”
“well too bad. you want to hang around greasers, you get treated like one. traitor.” the boys taunted before landing blows on you, kicking and punching.
you curled up in a ball as u cried, keeling over at an especially hard kick to the ribs. you lay there, bleeding and hugging ur knees as the socs continued their brutal assault on you.
until you heard a bunch of boys shouting, familiar voices yelling as you heard someone get tackled, the sound of fighting filling your ears. you were just glad it wasn’t you.
you slowly looked up, eyes still watery as you watched dallas, steve, and two bit swing at the boys who had been assaulting you. you attemped to stand up, swearing under your breath when your knee ached, blood trickling down your let from a nasty cut. you whimpered, sliding back onto the concrete as the socs ran away, substantially more beat up then you were.
you watched steve, dally, and two bit approach, dallas seething. you tried to stand again, failing.
“crap.” you muttered, watching the blood from your cut drench your white socks and shoes.
“need a ride?” two bit asked as he gestured for you to get onto his back.
god, you always smiled with them. even when you were having a horrible day, two-bit would crack a joke or ponyboy would make a snide remark that’d make you giggle. if you were sick or—god forbid—didn’t come to the curtis house one day, the gang would be busting down your door, demanding an explanation.
they were all you had loved. he was all you had loved. now you had nothing.
you sat at the table of the bar, an empty glass of what used to be some expensive tropical drink empty, condensating onto your hands.
you sighed woefully, biting your lip. you had gotten all dressed up—did your hair, makeup, short dress, louboutin pumps—the whole shebang, hoping to flirt with some guy whose name you definitely wouldn’t remember in the morning and forget about your life back in tulsa.
so far, you had done everything since.
you were broken out of your trance when someone tapped on your shoulder, looking up and meeting the gaze of a 6’2 hunk of man.
“sorry—you were kind of spaced out there. mind if i buy you a drink?” he inquired honestly, flashing you a model-like grin.
you quickly inspected him—he was tall, dark, and handsome—not to mention his rolex and expensive cologne that made you sure he had just walked straight out of the financial district. not to be materialistic, of course, but it was nice to find a man who could pay for himself…right?
“sure.” you responded, flashing him a small smile as he sat down next to you, giving his(your) order to the bartender.
“so, what brings you to new york?” he inquired casually, studying you in the same manner you had done to him earlier.
“is it that obvious i’m not from here?” you replied bashfully, letting out a chuckle. was it? you certainly were dressed nice enough to not look like a beverly hillbilly and you didn’t think your accent was that strong.
“no, it’s just that i’m sure if i had seen someone who looked like you somewhere, i would definitely remember your face.” he said slyly, taking his drink from the bartender and taking a sip, handing you yours.
you talked to him. sure, he was nice and handsome and reeked of daddy’s money, but he wasn’t johnny. your johnny.
and when he offered to walk you back to your place, even handing you your coat and purse? you had to refuse. you couldn’t keep on leading the guy on. it wasn’t fair.
you had never been to new york before, but even you knew it’d be a bad idea to walk home alone, especially drunk, in such a big city. you waved for a taxi, nearly getting ran over in the process before you finally got one, slumping into the back of the car, tipping the driver generously and stumbling up the steps of your apartment, flopping onto your bed without care for your makeup or hair.
you rolled over, glancing longingly at the phone sat on the nightstand in your room..you couldn’t, could you?
you leisurely reached over to your nightstand, kicking your heels off as you stared at the phone. you knew two numbers by heart: johnny’s home number and the curtis house. you knew better than to call johnny’s house. one of his parents would answer, screaming over the receiver so loud it hurt your ears even a thousand miles away—literally.
that left the curtises. but what time was it? judging by the black night sky lit up by the city lights and the twinkling of the stars, it had to be at least 12am, probably later. you knew darry usually stayed up late, but this late? it’d be rude to call. besides, you were sure it’d take 20 minutes to connect and darry would not be able to pay the long distance call fee. it would be selfish to even consider calling them.
you had made your bed, and now had to lie in it. literally.
and so, you did, hugging ur pillow and smearing the white sheets with makeup and glitter as u slept—night after night, the same routine.
1. go out—whether it be to a bar you were definitely not old enough to be at, a mall, or a fancy restaurant
2. meet a cute guy—rich, good smelling, usually not too creepy. make conversation, flirt lightly.
3. ruin it. push them away, deny them a kiss, politely decline to “head back to their place”—leaving you all alone to deal with your misery, like always.
you didn’t cry. maybe it was because the hangovers were so horrible you couldn’t even muster out any extra fluid. but god, you were miserable.
you thought things would change. tulsa was the issue. it was small, violent, poor. no one wanted to live in a place like that. of course, you were depressed.
but even in this big, beautiful metropolis, amongst times square and in the noise of the city, you felt the same. the huge population of people only made you aware of how utterly alone you were. no one knew how you truly felt, ever.
sure, you were friends with some of the soc girls—cherry and marcia and them—but the weren’t your best friends. socs had an unspoken rule. don’t show weakness. don’t show sympathy, don’t cry, don’t ever talk about your emotions or your interests—only material, mundane things.
your heart ached almost as much as your head did as you lay on the tiled bathroom floor of your hotel suite, dry heaving. the alcohol made you sick, and your sobbing didn’t help it either.
you were insignificant in this city—just one person amongst the millions. some of these people would be stars, actors, finance bros—whatever. but you? you’d never make it anywhere when you were stuck in this loop of self-loathing and depression.
what were you even doing anything for? drinking yourself sick and flirting with guys you didn’t even like for what—to prove that you could have fun alone, without the gang, without johnny?
you were gatsby. johnny was daisy. no matter how many parties you threw from across the lake to impress him, he would never care. no one ever would.
you didn’t sleep a wink on the plane ride back to tulsa, staring out the window as you mulled over your feelings.
was it too late to apologize? it felt like it. you didn’t even want johnny to get back with you—okay, yes you did. but you didn’t expect that. you didn’t deserve it. but what johnny deserved was closure. it wasn’t right—for you to up and leave him without a good explanation.
you pulled an empty piece of paper out of your diary, uncapping your fancy ink pen and drafting a letter—to johnny. an apology, an explanation. your near cursive flooded the page before you finally chose to sign off, folding the paper in two, sighing.
once you had arrived back in tulsa and unpacked your bags at home, you had one thing left to do.
your feet carried you with purpose as you walked to johnny’s house, crossing through the lot, making sure to stay on the soc side, just incase johnny was there.
you tip toed over to his house, being met with the sound of screaming and glass shattering—per usual. you crept over to his bedroom window in a manner you had done so many times before, slowly sliding it open—the lock was broken—praying he wasn’t there.
you let out a breath of relief when you saw his empty room, quickly taking your letter out of your pocket and tossing it onto a pile of blankets and a pillow on the floor—his bed. you slid the window closed, heading back to your place.
you were gatsby and johnny was daisy. and just like gatsby, you’d die alone. johnny would have moved on and gotten married and had kids. ponyboy would be out of tulsa, a published author. darry would finish school and actually make it somewhere now that he wasn’t taling care of his kid brothers. but you?
you’d be sitting in the vacant lot, right where you had left him.
unless, of course, he read your letter.
you stirred your tea, watching your sugar cubes dissolve in the warm mixture when suddenly, a soft knock came from your door. once—then twice. almost impatient
“coming!” you called as you walked to open the door, slightly aggravated at the idea of someone at your home, let alone knocking at this time of night, twisting the knob and swinging it open;the cool night air making you shiver.
you dropped your cup of tea.
a/n: my tumblr was glitchy as HELLLL when i wrote this omg. cred 2 dollywons for these dividers