My opinions on Spider-Man Brand New Day that no one asked for! SPOILERS!!!!!!!
Sorry for the long read.
In no particular order:
I did not know that Big Brother Frank Castle- Little Brother Peter Parker was a dynamic I needed to see, but I need to see more. And just to get this out of the way, the heartbreak on Frank's face when he shot Peter! I wanted to hug Frank. Like no, buddy, don't worry, he'll be ok, probably (more on this later).
Thank you Marvel for not throwing MJ and Peter back together first chance they got. The memory wipe spell was heartreaking and character defining and I was so afraid they were going to undo it for the main characters for convenience.
Also thank you for having both Peter and MJ conflicted about even trying to start a relationship. Of course Peter wouldn't want to put MJ in danger (and reminded me of Tobey not getting together with Mary Jane for his first two movies). And of course MJ wouldn't want to get into a relationship with someone she really doesn't actually know. But when she said she could see why a version of her would love him, my heart actually broke a little.
Although I would have also liked to see a little more of MJ's relationship with her current boyfriend. I know it doesn't play a role in the movie, but it would have been even more heartbreaking if Peter was in a situation where he couldn't even be upset with the guy she ended up with cause he can tell that this guy really does care for MJ. Even better would have been if during the party scene the boyfriend is the first to notice Peter and is friendly/nice to Peter before MJ and Ned are. All that's really said about him is that he knows MJ is withholding, which I also didn't care for. How much more angst could there have been if she (after learning to let her guard down with Peter and Ned) truly did have a strong connection with the boyfriend.
While I loved seeing characters like Hulk/Bruce and Yelena, I didn't think they were really needed for this movie. Hear me out! I love a good fight, but it kinda felt like you could have replaced him with any other strong character and still get a decent fight. Plus this makes it the third time this character has been mind controlled by a slightly mentally unstable younger sibling (see Loki in Avengers and Wanda in Age of Ultron) so it feels a little redundant. It also feels like that Marvel has no idea what to do with Hulk at this point. In Endgame he and Bruce were in harmony, in She-Hulk he was just suppressing to heal and was even in Smart Hulk form at the end, and now he's afraid of Hulk again? Although, I do like that he does play a role in the inhibitor tech.
Yelena does help connect Peter to the MCU/New Avengers, which means I am hoping to see him in Doomsday (I doubt we've actually gotten the full cast list yet). But she could have also been replaced with almost anyone else who can give Spider-Man information. Frankly, if they insisted on it being a New Avenger, Bucky may have been a better choice. He was a Senator (I think) so of course he'd have access to highly confidential information/other connections/ better reason/resources to investigate Damage Control. And he was familiar with Spider-Man thanks to the Airport Fight and final fight with Thanos. So he'd respect him at the very least.
I was terrified that Jean Grey would be in a similar situation in which she could have been replaced with anyone, but no I loved her as this role. And as an introduction to mutants in the MCU (does Ms. Marvel count?) she actually is a strong and familiar character to have put on screen. Her motivations were completely understandable. They showed she was powerful but not OP like other media tends to try to make her. I also love that they showed her abilities are still growing and that mutant abilities aren't always stagnant/predictable. Honestly, I can see this version of Jean developing the Phoenix naturally like in that cartoon Wolverine and the X-Men, where it had always been a part of her, but grew into something powerful. And all due respect to the original X-Men movies, but Sadie Sink's version had more character and development in this one film than Famke Janssen's version had in all three movies. There I said it.
And the reveal of V-MAX!!!!!! When I first heard it I thought it had to have been some connection with the X-Men. She had misread something about it on some file, she knew it was some place for mutants but didn't know specifics, that she was actually sent by the X-Men. More likely that it was some vauge comic reference I didn't understand. Then when Sarah's abduction (whose name I don't recognize) was revealed, I thought Sarah was trying to send Jean to the X-Men (again a mistranslatioin of some kind). But no, it was the last thing Sarah SAW! Jean's crash out was fully valid.
Even beyond the grave, May Parker was playing MVP- Most Valuable Parker. She was the mother figure that Jean needed, and Peter was more than willing to share May's wisdom/love with May. I love that it was something so simple that got Jean to stop. It shows how little things can be so impactful especially to young, grieving teenagers. It also sets up the importance of Xavier's school and the impact he'll have on his students (Marvel I need to know whose going to be the new Xavier and Magneto). I only hope that when X-Men are introduced that they don't throw away Jean and Peter's relationship, I would love to see more (as friends).
Finally Peter! My sad little spider. I love how they showed that even though he's doing all these wonderful things as Spider-Man, even getting the key to the city, none of that matters to him without his friends/loved ones. That montage also showed how loved he is by New York so that when he is in the hospital it fits that the city would be there for him. Although I would have also liked to see J.Jonah Jameson/Daily Bugle around as an almost reflection of all these negative thoughts Peter has about himself that he uses as reasons to not get personal with anyone.
Unfortunately, Peter getting shot was spoiled for me (the cons of working at a movie theater). But when I saw how big that blood puddle was under Peter I still got scared. Like no, did I mishear them, am I about to lose one of my 4 favorite Spider-Men?! But no, Peter lives to swing another day! And Frank being a giant kid in the spider mask, distracting everyone *French kiss*. I also like that in addition to New York gathering around/rooting for Spider-Man, the police force is also supporting him for once. Kinda- They didn't turn on him the second he did something bad, so progress. It also got Yelena- any (New) Avenger- to care about the 'small' things in a meaningful way. I would love if this opens the door for Peter to working with other heroes more often.
Yes, I would have changed some things, but I love the rest so much more. I don't pay attention to any casting/contract rumors, especially since so many of them end up coming back after they say their done anyways. This movie was character driven rather than action driven. So I would love to see more of Tom Holland as Spider-Man, see where he goes from here. Maybe we can even get to the point of seeing an Adult Peter Parker being a mentor to the younger generations of heroes.
Alas time will tell. So I give this movie a 9 out of 10. Have a happy Spider.


















