Dark Souls 3 is kinda perfect.
The game has issues but complaining about them feels frivolous in the face of how definitively well executed everything about it is. In a way it's the perfect sequel to the first game, visually, thematically and gameplay-wise.
If I were around that sphere when DS2 came out I would be really disappointed because the original intention of that game was to reinvent the series with every new entry. New feel, new mechanics, new worlds and stories, an infinite adventure, ten thousand sequels each with their unique feel of combat, genuinely no stone was left unturned in the development of Dark Souls 2. In a world where DS3 never happened, we probably would still have Dark Souls sequels.
But Dark Souls 3 reigns it in. The series is immediately wrangled back to its roots, everything about dark souls 3 is rooted in the first game, and it all serves one singular purpose: to deliver a message to all who fell in love with the first game. The message being: This Series Has To End. Now.
And what would be a more perfect way to deliver such a message than making a story about a dying world that is tired of existing? Make your fans face the corpses of their favourite characters. Put them into the ruins of their favourite areas, covered in ash and dust and poison. Make I all staggeringly beautiful in a macabre kind of way.
Have you ever had a favourite game series that started out brilliantly but then was bought or the devs just completely lost the plot, so after a few new installments it feels less like the game you once knew, and more like it's corpse being paraded around? I've heard fans of the original Fallout games complain in that manner. I'm not one of them but I can see where they're coming from.
Dark Souls 3 seems to be doing something like that on the surface, but instead of a parade, it feels more like a funeral. It's a beautiful funeral, but the reality hits you like a sack or bricks: this world is dying, and then the credits roll, the casket will be closed. Do you still want to go on this journey? Yeah, I do.
Perhaps one day Dark Souls 4 will come out. I have a small sliver of hope that maybe someone at fromsoft figures out what this series might still have left to say. Dark Souls 3 is probably the most ended game to ever end a series. It ended so hard that I feel like if Dark Souls 4 hits our shelves after a decade, everyone will just look past it, thinking they might've seen a ghost.
I do wanna fuck that ghost though. Badly.















