Premise 1: if you tell the truth, then people will be offended. Premise 2: I offended people. Conclusion: I told the truth. Does the above argument commit a fallacy, assuming the premises are true? If so, which one? Answer below. . . . . . . . . . . . Of course, the first premise is not true for all cases, nor for all people. But again, we were to assume the premise was true for all cases and people. In such a case, this argument commits the formal fallacy known as affirming the consequent. Denying the antecedent and affirming the consequent are two types of formal fallacies. Formal fallacies have nothing to do with "propriety," as with "formal events." Formal, in this case, means form, or structure; meaning the structure of the argument does not support the conclusion. Of course, this doesn't mean the conclusion is wrong. It just means the argument is invalid, ie, the argument does not support the conclusion. However, the conclusion may be accidentally correct, but it wouldn't be true *because* of the reasoning. Take the example from the chart. If you heard Joe is dead (and no other information was given) he might have been decapitated. But simply assuming he was decapitated because decapitation causes death relies on fallacious reasoning. These two fallacies apply to conditional statements. A conditional statement is "if x then y." You can only infer x or y under certain conditions. This is not to be confused with biconditional statements, "if and only if x then y." In a biconditional statement, if you know either x or y, you can validly infer the other. An example is "in modern times, it is Halloween and only if it is October 31st." If you know if the date either is Oct 31, you can deduce it is Halloween. If you know the date is Halloween, you can deduce it is Oct 31. Carpe Datum and Semper Sci! [Sgt Scholar Actual] Let's Promote #skepticism (not contrarian doubt) #criticalthinking #logic #evidence #science #STEM #scicomm #education #metacognition #selfawareness #dialogue #philosophy #reason #wisdom Let's Attenuate #pseudoscience #snakeoil unfounded #conspiracytheories #bullshit #fallacies #cognitivebiases #misinformation #disinformation https://www.instagram.com/p/CVQygDThv51/?utm_medium=tumblr