Okay so as someone who is greyromantic and has experienced a bit of both, the feelings are remarkably similar, but still different in a way that’s really tough for me to describe.
So I have my boyfriend, and the crushy feeling I had with him was very different from anything else I’d experienced. And if it hadn’t been reciprocated I could’ve dealt with being friends, I guess, but there probably would’ve been some jealousy because I knew what I wanted even if it took me a little bit to decode the feelings.
But I also really didn’t like having a crush.
It’s nothing against him! At all! It’s just that relationships are hard and our circumstances were messy and I was scared and the feelings were strong and I just didn’t like it. But I’m glad things worked out and we’ve been together for as long as we have.
On the other hand, I have a friend crush in the way the original post describes on this person I met at my school.
The day I first talked to this dude (via email first for a student org related thing), I thought he was cool as fuck, but I expected that vibe to chill once I actually got on campus and all. The day I actually met him irl, I knew I wanted to be really good friends with him. There were a handful of people I met around the same time and felt like “I need these people as besties, and I need it soon,” but the vibe was always strongest with him.
We talked at this student org’s meetings almost weekly but it was a group thing and he’s cool with everyone so I was just kinda there. Very sure I wouldn’t get far with this idea.
Over winter break, I’d sent a message or two, not really expecting a reply; I try not to assume that I mean anything to anyone.
Imagine my surprise when a few days before the semester starts, he tells me he had a really rough break, which is why he hadn’t replied, and he actually wanted to know if we could hang out outside of meetings at least once (which happened! It was really cool actually!)
He graduated at the end of that semester, but we’ve kept in touch as much as we could, and I actually saw him irl last week.
(Sorry for the infodump, he’s just also kind of a hyperfixation rn which is awkward and sucky imo)
Anyway long story short (and using this example instead of an example with a friend I talk to daily ONLY BECAUSE my friend crush on him was about a decade ago and the one I talked about above is recent), the biggest difference for me is what label I wanted out of the connections.
See, I love strongly either way. I want my life to be intertwined with my boyfriend’s life, with my best friend’s life, with this friend crush’s life, all of it.
I just really love my boyfriend as my romantic partner, and if we changed our minds and decided to “just” be besties, that’s fine; I’ve always preferred having more than one bestie anyway. But want I want wouldn’t change, it’s more the label itself that varies.
With my best friend, whether we’d swap to a romantic relationship is questionable. I don’t know how I’d feel about that. But I like where we’re at right now.
With my friend crush, I want to know him the way I know my close friends. And I’m okay with him knowing me the way my close friends would.
Deep down I want what I used to read about: the relationships where there are adventures and late-night deep conversations and silly immature things.
I may also want to buy out an apartment complex and have all my loved ones all live near me but like that’s an entirely different fantasy.