I have a note for a possible murder in 15x24, but I don't know what I was referring to (why was there a question mark?) And I'm not going to rewatch the episode right now to figure it out.
I can't find the original murder count, so here's the one I made meticulously during my last rewatch:
Organized by number of murders followed by which episodes they were from. Any special cases are separated, and I love Margaret for the arson, so it gets special mention.
Julia
3 - 2x02, 9x18, 13x09
Halloween Count:
3 - 12x06 (for a brief moment), 17x05 (twice! Damn Julia! And you murdered Effie too!!)
Murdoch
3 - 5x08, 13x11, 17x02
Brax
1 - 2x12
Specific mentions of killing a man while in the army:
2 - 12x07, 13x09
Violet
1 - 13x18
George
Halloween Count:
1 - 12x06
Henry
1 - 10x08
Margaret (special arson column)
1 (definitely burned down that gazeboš„°)













