Ntm how many anti endo arguments will end up just absolutely blatantly racist/ anti Indigenous. I cannot tell you how many times we've seen 'spiritual systems aren't valid' as if discounting spiritual knowledge tied to one's culture and Indigeneity isn't extremely fucking inappropriate.
And if they aren't straight up calling people abelist slurs for having a system tied to spiritual beliefs/practices then it'll be something along the lines of 'that's a closed practice! You can't participate in that! You aren't valid for that!' As if members of closed practices don't actively/actually exist in modern spaces.
It becomes exceedingly clear that systems who use 'closed practices' as a gotcha don't actually give a flying fuck about the actual practice/culture/people because the ONLY time you ever see them even semi recognize the existence of Indigenous knowledge/practices is to try to invalidate someone they don't like/agree with because 'a member of that group couldn't possibly exist in online spaces'.
They act like they give a flying fuck about 'preserving the sanctity of closed practices' or Indigenous specific origins yet very clearly don't think we actually exist.
As an Indigenous person who's cultural knowledge and practices absolutely tie into how my system operates its fucking exhausting to see people CONSTANTLY use the concept of us as a way to attack people they don't like and only ever be mentioned as a gotcha 'you couldn't possibly be valid because you couldn't possibly be a member of xyz group/culture/practice!'
Like just fucking say you don't believe modern day Indigenous people exist and move on with your life. Stop using this 'Indigenous people and their practices are mystical and mysterious and couldn't possibly be in a space I could interact with' as a away to attack people YOU KNOW NOTHING ABOUT.
It's inherently fucking racist.
It makes it blatantly obvious you don't give a flying fuck about the real actual people and real actual cultures you're using as a way to attack and invalidate people online.
It makes it extremely fucking clear that your idea of Indigenous people is locked in some fucked up time warp where Indigenous people of any kind couldn't possibly 1. Stand up for themselves in these spaces 2. Even fucking exist in a modern day space like the internet to begin with.
We are not your ace in the hole to invalidate systems you don't like.
We and our practices are not stuck in some mythical land that time forgot.
We are real, actual, living in the age of the internet, fucking people and we see you.
We see you using your idea of us to attack other people.
We see you weaponizing our existence against people you don't like.
We see you acting like we only exist in theory.
We see you attacking real life members of these cultural groups with your attempts to 'gatekeep' a cultural and practices that do not belong to you.
We see you treating us like ghosts of our ancestors.
And we're fucking screaming for you to stop.
Your validity should not be built atop a digital grave of our culture.
Your validity should not come at the expense of the people you claim to care about when invoking the phrase 'closed practices'.
Just a stereotype to be dug out the closet and thrust into the faces of whomever you don't like as an excuse to invalidate their existence.
Completely disregarding the real life human beings you're caricaturizing in order to do so.
__________________________________________
To all the Indigenous systems out there from around the world:
Your frustrations with being used are founded.
Your cultural knowledge and practices have far more value than a gotcha in an internet argument.
From a Turtle Island Native to all Indigenous peoples: