So many unsavory takes and outrage out there, so here is my take on why I think for the most part, the ending fits and Attack on Titan ended well. It’s not perfect, but it fits. There’s so much to say that I can’t fit in one post, but I want to talk about Eren in SNK. One of the things I love about SNK is that while it takes place in a fictional world, the difficult subjects–prejudice, war, and how cruel the world can be–has always felt realistic. And to the very end, it lives up to this. That the world isn’t black and white, it’s not about the clearly defined “heroes” or “villains”, it’s that everyone is very much truly human. For me, I can’t disagree more that Eren doesn’t feel like “Eren”. Eren, from beginning to end has been through and through who he’s always been. This is the boy from day 1, who isn’t afraid to take away the freedom of those who want to take his. This is the boy who always fought to keep moving forward and he did, until the very end. He’s never been “traditional” heroic and he’s never been afraid to do the unthinkable (it is also one of the reasons I love most about him). And while Eren had been under the guise of this stoic character who kept pushing forward even through the cruelest fates and even committing genocide, I’m thankful we got to see his humanity come out one last time. I’m not an Eren/Mikasa shipper as I have previously stated, but honestly I’m not even bothered by the scene in 139 where Eren declares he doesn’t want her to think about anyone else or to forget him, for ten years at least–I think this scene is very much up to interpretation whether he loves her platonically or romantically and that’s up to however anyone wants to interpret this.
But putting that aside, for me, the importance and interpretation of this scene isn’t his “declaration of love” or how that confession seemed out of place, but that it’s about how we finally truly see Eren again and what he wants. That he wants to live, he wants to be with them, and he doesn’t want to be forgotten. His “declaration” of not wanting her to think of someone else, to me is really just him saying Mikasa’s name in context, but really implying for all of them (the people important to him). That he wants to be with Mikasa, with everyone. And this wishful outburst to not be forgotten, to not be replaced by “Mikasa finding another man” is simply the nineteen-year old Eren’s desperation to live. He’s so very human here and he wants to live. It’s easily one of the most heartbreaking scenes in the manga, seeing the “selfish” side of him finally come out again. Because above all of Eren playing the martyr so that the people most important to him can have a chance to live, above him knowing undeniably that can’t ever be forgiven, he still doesn’t want to die (especially, not alone, forgotten in a few years time). What he’s doing is completely unforgivable, but it’s not forgiveness that matters here, it’s about his sacrifices, about the lengths he’s willing to go, his desperation and how he unconditionally loves his friends/his people more than anything in the world.
Eren’s been alone for so long like Armin said and this whole time, even though he’s talked to all of them in paths, he’s erased their memories temporarily. He is alone, even up to his last moments. Eren is truly the most tragic character, but as SNK always shows, the world is impossibly cruel but there is and always will be, glimpses of beauty (beauty that is their friendship, beauty in them remembering him despite his unforgivable sins, beauty in Eren’s love for the people important to him, beauty for the world’s ability to move on–that life truly goes on).
I also want to say that clearly to me, nowhere in this chapter or the characters (including Eren), was genocide ever justified/glorified, etc. just because Armin thanks Eren for “being a mass murderer”. Armin clearly states that what Eren did was an “error”, but Eren’s made that choice, Armin isn’t thanking him for committing genocide, he’s thanking him for loving them so dearly that he’ll sacrifice himself so that they can have even a shot at peace. Even if it’s not solving everything. And for those who are saying “then what was even the point of the rumbling” – the point is that, Eren ended the cycle of Titans and disarmed the world from retaliating for a long time, which gave Paradis a chance of survival. As long as Titans exist and Eldians can turn into Titans, they will forever be seen as monsters. Now with Titans vanquished from this world, they finally have the chance to be seen as humans. Different/divided humans, still, yes (as humans have always been), but the chance of convincing the world, of establishing peace is that much more likely now that they’re on even grounds and they aren’t Titans, that calling them monsters isn’t an excuse anymore. And I feel like this ending, where they have a world without Titans but that the war never really ends, that the prejudice between nations and fighting between humans will always exist, is painfully realistic. It’s the same way in the real world, where conflict between humans will always exist and that isn’t just going to “go away”, but with Titans gone from this world, their ability to work for peace is actually a possibility. For me, SNK was always a masterpiece before it even reached the last chapter, so nothing that happened would ruin that for me, but endings are important and do leave a lasting impression. So I’m actually so happy that 139 felt right. It felt real, it stayed true to the themes it’s always held and it ended as the kind of story it’s always been–That the world is cruel, that there is no real “enemies” when you can see both sides of the story, but that there is still beauty.
Anyways, sorry this is all over the place, it’s so hard to put to words all the pieces of this story and how much it means. But yes, there were scenes I wanted to see (Eren’s talk with all of the 104ths, Levi’s thoughts, Ymir’s pov, etc.) and other questions answered, but I also feel like it tied up enough to be an end. It’s not perfect, as nothing ever is and no end can ever satisfy everyone, but I’m happy with the way it ended because it felt right. It’s bittersweet, it’s tragic, it’s realistic and I love this story so much. From beginning to end.
Thank you Isayama, for this masterpiece that will stick with me forever, for the story of a lifetime and sharing this world with us. And thank you to everyone who I have ever befriended because of this beautiful world. <3

























