Thinking about an AU where Shane and Ilya never get back together after the tuna melt day, and Shane still dates Rose for a bit, but when she tries to have the “You’re gay” conversation he flat-out refuses and keeps denying it. Eventually he finds another girl to date who cares way more about Being Superstar Shane Hollander’s Girlfriend than she cares about Shane himself, which is perfectly fine by him. Shane doesn’t need anyone else looking at his life too closely.
So Shane keeps playing hockey, and he keeps dating this girl. Eventually they get married, and everyone’s so happy for them. Shane’s mostly just relieved. He did it. He’s got the Wife and the Career and he’s normal, he’s finally normal, and all that stuff from his early twenties was just a momentary aberration. (And if there’s a hollowness in him, an ache that can’t be filled unless secretly opening himself up on his fingers or ordering enough room service to make himself sick, that’s no one’s business but his own).
Then Shane retires, and the first real cracks start to appear. He’d been traveling constantly for most of their relationship, and now that he’s home all the time he and his wife find they don’t have much to say to each other. When she does speak to him, it’s mostly to make pointed comments about his body.
But Shane can’t really blame her. He knows his weight problem is spiraling out of control. It started his last few seasons on the ice, when his runaway appetite had made him gain a handful of pounds above the solid 200 he’d maintained throughout his career. He was so close to retirement that the trainers just laughed it off, said Hollander deserved some newlywed bulk. But after he’d stopped playing, he still couldn’t stop eating, and his weight had snowballed rapidly. The pounds packed on and on, his widening belly carrying most of the fat but still leaving a hefty amount split between his ass and thighs.
His wife was understandably incensed. She’d married Shane Hollander, Hockey Star, not Shane Hollander, Chubby Retiree, and doesn’t he know how embarrassing it is that she can’t post beach vacay-thirst traps of them together anymore?
And Shane knows she’s right, that he does need to get a handle on it, that his plump tummy and thick love handles probably should be embarrassing, but also he can’t really bring himself to do anything about it. Nothing has felt particularly real to him since hockey ended, least of all his body.
One day he’s at a gallery opening his wife had dragged him to in Montreal, wandering around with a plate of hors d'oeuvres while his wife holds court among a group of influencers in the back corner. He’s chewing a cube of gouda while staring absently at an abstract sculpture when he hears the voice.
A little more gravelly from years of smoke, a little bit less of an accent from years in the States. But still the same voice Shane’s had memorized since that cold December day in Saskatchewan, 2008.
“Nice show, I think. Though I am not sure what this one is supposed to be...”
Ilya Rozanov’s standing by his side, gesturing at the sculpture with a tip of his graying curls. He’s wearing a collared shirt buttoned low enough to expose the sexy scruff of his chest hair, sleeves pushed up to show off his muscular forearms.
For the first time since retiring, Shane feels very, very awake.
He opens his mouth, intending to make some polite comment and bid his farewell, but what comes out, in a playful, slightly snotty tone he hasn’t heard himself use in years, is “I think it’s pretty obviously you crying on the ground after we knocked you out of the playoffs in ‘25.”
Rozanov’s silent for a moment, and then his joyful burst of laughter is loud enough to make the nearby visitors shoot them curious looks. “Ha! So Hollander still chirps, eh? You know, this is funny, because I was actually thinking that statue looks very much like you on your knees, Vegas ‘14, coming untouched...”
A little jolt goes through him to hear their sexual past referenced so baldly like that, and he waits for the attendant rush of shame, the turtle-like instinct to retreat into his shell. But it never comes. Somehow, from Rozanov’s lips it all feels completely… normal.
“Fuck you,” Shane says, but he’s laughing too. “Don’t say ‘untouched,’ you make it sound like I just came in my pants or something. You were definitely doing some touching.”
“Okay, okay. Hands free, we will say.”
“Better.” Shane elbows Rozanov in the ribs, and Rozanov elbows him back, laughing again.
“Fuck, Hollander. I missed you.”
“I missed you too,” Shane admits plainly, then hastens to add, “I mean, those last few years weren’t the same without you on the ice.”
“Mmm.” Rozanov shrugs. “Well, you had other things to keep you busy.”
“Right.” Rozanov had retired around the same time Shane got married.
For a moment they’re both quiet, staring at the sculpture. Shane fidgets with his cocktail napkin and chances a glance to his right. Rozanov is already staring at him, eyes dark and calculating. He doesn’t look away when he notices Shane watching him.
“You look good, Hollander,” Rozanov says lowly. His eyes trace a deliberate path up and down Shane’s body. “Very good.”
Shane instinctively looks down at himself, and for the first time he remembers how much bigger his current body is than that of the Hollander Rozanov used to know. Blood rushes to his cheeks as he stares at the chubby spill of his belly over his belt, his thick thighs straining the seams of his pants. “Oh,” he says awkwardly. “I know I need to—“
But before he can get into a lie about how he’s working on losing weight, his wife is there, pulling him by the elbow off into the crowd.
Ilya watches Shane’s retreating form lumber through the crowd, the petite blonde woman he recognizes from his years of internet stalking attaching herself to Shane’s side like an angry barnacle. She hisses something in Shane’s ear, and then his belly retracts slightly in a clear attempt to suck in. But Shane’s too fat for it to make much of a difference. His wife is clearly aware of this, because her face hardens and she takes the plate of hors d’oeuvres from Shane’s hand and dumps it in the trash.
Ilya can only stand there stupidly paralyzed, all the confidence and bravado that had driven him here having melted away almost instantly after coming face to face with Shane again for the first time in years. Fuck. It was his only chance, and he fucking blew it, struck dumb by the utter miracle of him, the irresistible loveliness of Shane’s soft bulk. Ilya hadn’t been able to do much more than choke out an awkward compliment that made Shane regard him warily like he thought Ilya was making fun of him, and then Ilya just let Shane walk away before he could say everything he’d been keeping in his heart.
Just like last time, Ilya thinks bitterly. The broad curves of Shane’s shoulders fall into a slump as he shuffles forward. There will never be anything as painful as watching Shane walk away.
(But what had he even been thinking, Ilya berates himself. Did he seriously expect that Hollander would, what, leave his wife for him? Get a grip, Rozanov.)
But then— at the mouth of the gallery, Shane turns around. His eyes lock on Ilya’s for a single electric moment, and then he’s pushing back through the crowd, his wife’s lips forming a cherry-red ‘O’ of outrage behind him.
Shane’s a big man, and the crowd parts easily in his wake. In no time at all he’s back in front of Ilya, slightly out of breath, a deep flush reddening his round cheeks.
“Rozanov,” Shane pants. “I wanted to ask… would you, would you want to maybe get coffee sometime? Catch up?”
Inside of Ilya, a long-dormant spark begins to glow so brightly that he knows it’s surely spilling out from every gap of his toothy grin. “I would like that, Hollander. I would like that very much.”