I will never understand the obsession with trying to make Magneto not Jewish
You know what I do have one explanation. Leftists love his ideology but Magneto would have been a mega Zionist and I think they are uncomfortable with that
He WAS a mega zionist. Is a mega zionist.
Both literally (the period of time beloved of shippers where he was close to Charles was when they were both living in Haifa and Erik/Max was working as a nazi hunter) and metaphorically (he has directly created or participated in the creation of between three and four New Homelands for Mutants to Flee To When Flatscans Inevitably Betray Them).
At least one of those Mutant Homelands he founded had a "Troubling Founding" involving a civil war against the previous oppressive literally-kept-mutants-as-slaves human government and the founding in question concluded with the expulsion of even innocent civilian human residents.
The reason fan-tourists insist he be something other than Jewish is very specifically because they love his ideology and uncompromising absolutist leave-no-quarter attitude but do not wish to confront the fact that the ideology and attitude they are praising is literally the Kahanism that they hate (or, if they insist that he changed and got better, that the "got better" they insist is different for Magneto is literally the Liberal Zionism they IRL insist is no different than Kahanism) and having it be Zionism That Never Involved Jews Or The Levant lets them ignore that cognitive dissonance.
It is a desperate attempt to avoid acknowledging their own Jew-Hate double standard hypocrisy.
They really hate acknowledging that his transformation by Claremont was based on Begin.
He literally met Charles in Israel, where he lived after fleeing a mob in a Soviet country and they think he's not a Zionist.















