Seriously people the lack of fandom interaction these days makes me genuinely depressed, it never used to be like this, makes me wonder what's the point of coming online to do anything anymore.
Reblog a post so other people can see it.
Leave a comment so the author doesn't feel like giving up.
dont be scared to leave a little message in the tags! dont be scared to tell that author what you thought about that one line in their fic!
i used to only like/kudos because i was worried i would upset the op/author but then i posted my first fic and it genuinely made me so happy when i got a comment!
now i think of that feeling whenever i interact with fandom and i imagine op feeling that too
i promise you, the person you are interacting with will treasure your little tag or your little comment for a long time! THATS THE WHOLE POINT! THATS WHY WE POST INSTEAD OF JUST THINKING IN THE SILENCE OF OUR HEADS!
I am whatever the opposite of a speed runner is. I am a game meanderer. I have to look at literally everything. I am overly cautious in every way. I forget to pause and wander away from the game. I take a minimum 7 hours to get through any given level. If you give me a timer I will cry.
Sometimes, I like to try to envision how a plot swap could come about.
Of course, a plot is made of a million little choices, many of which can send the characters off to go become people their canon self would not recognise. But I tend to write fanwork, and genrally speaking the mark of a good fanwork is that other people still reconise the character portrayed within their new circumstances.
Of course there are people who don't mind otherwise, with a compelling enough story to convince them to go with it.
But now I'm dancing around topics. Not an unusual state for me, but posts are meant to get to a point. Eventually.
Picture Alm raised in the church, and Celica as Mycens grandaughter. This is a crack premise of course, but opens intresting questions.
How could that happen? Perhaps, the person who discovers the brand on Alm has to instead be a follower of Desaix or something.
And the logical response to that of course is to send Alm to the last place anyone would look for him. The illogical answer is where they picked.
The nature of the thought exercise is to think think about how their personalities would be shaped and changed by this decision.
Will a Celica who never went to a priory be more inclined to fighting. How would hiding his identidy change Alm's personality? Whst would be the long term butterfly effects of this?
Of course, what I'm actually thinking about is how Ram village would handle it. And the potential funny of Ram village collectively gaslighting anyone who gets nosey that Mycan has always had a granddaughter. Grandson who told you that? And gifting Cecilia all manor of styled gloves.
They talk about by not talking about it. Not after what happened to Alm.
Behold: the list! More than 150 prompts ripe for the taking! Now everyone can pick something cool (even if you didnât submit anything) (no need to claim it anywhere) and start drawing it or writing it or any other creative verb of your liking. Next stop: June 19th, when weâll all post together to celebrate GTâs original anniversary (there will be a reminder with brief posting instructions).
Prompts are numbered for your convenience, in the order they came in. The block divisions are just because tumblr gets twitchy about long numbered lists. Full rules here.
And now, without further ado:
BLOCK A:
pennamepersona - sissel & lynne besties, please no ship
pennamepersona - yomiel being part of the "family" post-game
pennamepersona - some or all memories regained by lynne/kamila post-game
pennamepersona - ace attorney crossover of any kind (but I do think jowd & yomiel & phoenix could be friends; I wrote a couple crossover fics on ao3 that could give insp)
pennamepersona - sissel learning how to read post-game
pennamepersona - the melding of everyone into a found family in the new timeline
pennamepersona - jowd & yomiel friendship in new timeline
pennamepersona - sissel meeting yomiel's fiance
Jowd/Cabanela, who fell first and who fell harder?
What's Lovey's read on Sissel during game events?
Emma's latest masterpiece?
Cast member(s) of your choice as a DnD class, art
Cabanela and Yomiel rivalry mid-game angst, art or fic
Ship of your choice, art or fic, in case someone wants an excuse to indulge
Post-game Cabanela/Yomiel on vacation, ship, art or fic
Kamila playing something on a Nintendo DS (for the sake of remembering the origins of the gameđ„č), art
Pre-game Yomiel trying to figure out how give Sissel the cat a bath, art or fic
Crack ship of your choice! Art or fic
the-grey-hunt: sissel in a service cat vest
the-grey-hunt: yomiel in a wheelchair!
the-grey-hunt: yomiel and fiansissel's wedding (i wanna see them in fancy pretty clothes)
the-grey-hunt: alma and fiansissel being (or becoming!) friends
the-grey-hunt: the gang goes to an escape room. they either escape in 5 minutes or are too used to real mysteries and fumble it SO bad. would vastly prefer kamila to get some kind of spotlight here!
the-grey-hunt: rindge and memry being friends
the-grey-hunt: lynne on the run with sissel
the-grey-hunt: sissel with some cat friends (either in the previous timeline or post-canon)
bluestbadger - Jowd and Cabanela as Sherlock Holmes & John Watson! Preferably ACD era, but any variation works. Either can be Sherlock or John, romantic or platonic! (art)
bluestbadger - The different weird but useful gifts Cabanela has given Jowd over the years (like the tracking compass)
bluestbadger - Cabanela/Jowd, but Jowd is still with Alma who isn't aware of the infidelity -- how does this work out for them?
bluestbadger - Cabanela angst after Jowd's arrest -- how is he holding up? Romantic, unrequited, or platonic is dealer's choice!
bluestbadger - Cabanela as a mentor figure for Lynne after Jowd's arrest (not romance)
bluestbadger - Lynne's backstory beyond Temsik! Where is her family in all this? Was Jowd more directly a father-figure before his arrest? But go any direction you want!
bluestbadger - Kamila & inventions -- could be what she gets up to in the future or an exploration of her relationship with inventing after Alma's death, go wild!
bluestbadger - Lynne and/or Kamila swapped with Ace Attorney girls !! i.e., Lynne as Ema, Kamila as Iris Wilson, etc etc (art)
Red-headed-target - Lynne and Kamila spending time together, can be during the previous timeline or post-canon, angst or fluffy.
Red-headed-target - Sissel relearns how to use his powers in the new timeline, while Alma and Kamila notice that something is up with their cat.
Red-headed-target - Anything with kid!lynne and kitty!sissel. Bonus points if its a scenario where she adopts him in the new timeline (or if sheâs helping jowd care for him).
Red-headed-target - Sissel and Lynne vs an exorcist/ghost hunters/paranormal investigators from a more typical ghost story,
Red-headed-target - Yomiel in the doomed timeline either messing with Cabanela or grappling with getting screwed over.
siverwrites - Missile DOES swap Jowd orb and a ball
siverwrites - warm, soooft, lovely times for Jowd/Alma &/ Cabanela (please no infidelity)
siverwrites - Sissel (cat!), Missile and Lovey-Dove animal team-up! Ghost Tricks optional for Lovey-Dove
siverwrites - Pigeon Man and Jowd friendship, any timeline
Jowd &/ Cabanela hurt/comfort in either direction or both ways
siverwrites - Cabanela and Pigeon Man weird friendship and working together
siverwrites - Lynne has to team up with someone completely unexpected to solve a case
siverwrites - free square for the FFVI AU - https://archiveofourown.org/series/1196335 https://archiveofourown.org/series/1169099 Info on what we've done in the links, or go wild with your own ideas
alto-tenure: sports au. any sport but track & field is my preference. coaches jowd & cabanelaâŠvery enthusiastic but not as talented lynneâŠ
alto-tenure: inspired by a novel I read recently, AU where Sissel is (a/the) Grim Reaper, tasked with reaping a soul about to die when they shouldn'tâŠ
alto-tenure: putting in a request for Yomiel + Professor Layton and the Unwound Future, bonus especially if you put him with Claire & Dimitri <3
alto-tenure: steampunk grickâŠso many mechanics and gears for sissel to mess around with, if you catch my drift :)
alto-tenure: for the second year in a row I just think it would be really funny if Sissel was on Rokkenjima foiling Beatrice's plans
aviatoons - Any interaction between Jowd and Ray
aviatoons - Something featuring Jeego and Tengoâs rivalry
aviatoons - Art of Lynne and Kamila walking Missile
aviatoons - Anything featuring Metal Yomiel
aviatoons - Post-canon Sissel being a âcompletely normalâ cat (because he definitely still thinks heâs at least a little bit human)
frogpotat - Kitty Sissel having a strange, sibling adjacent relationship with Weirdy (The Hollow (Netflix)), and/or Michael Afton (FNAF). Don't question it.
frogpotat - Amelie when she isn't sick. She already gets up to some crazy shenanigans in the game, imagine how she acts when she isn't too dizzy to walk.
frogpotat - Jeego, Tengo, Dandy, and Beauty hanging out between missions, just having some watercooler talk as if they have normal jobs. Please no shipping of Jeego and Tengo.
frogpotat - Lynne and Kitty Sissel investigating together.
frogpotat - Draw someone else's Fiansissel design in your own style. Remember to tag them!
frogpotat - Missile's heartfelt reunion with the rest of the cast in the new timeline.
frogpotat - [FREE SPACE] Yomiel aura farming.
BLOCK B:
Kayoticinconvenience - post canon Cabanela being an uncle figure to Kamila and Lynne
Kayoticinconvenience - Sissel and Missile hanging out being creatures, and maybe Lovey Dove too
Kayoticinconvenience - Bailey and friend playing cards with each other
Kayoticinconvenience - Lynne in investigation mode, and Sissel within an item Lynne is holding
Kayoticinconvenience - Yomiel and cat Sissel, during the ten years
Kayoticinconvenience - Yomiel in the prison cell, painting something
Kayoticinconvenience - Jowd and Lynne doing detective work together
Kayoticinconvenience - Cat Sissel and Kamila playing
memry, lynne, and rindge on an outing of any kind (can be either romantic or platonic!)
RandomK- I'm curious about the first timeline. Tell the journy of how Missile got to the Yonoa after failing to save his girls.
RandomK:- In the first timeline Sissel leaves Missile In the junkyard. What did our favorite ghost cat get up to on his own that timeline?
RandomK:- Ray knows a lot about Sissels Ghost Trick abilities. What would a teamup between Sissel and Missel in the first timeline be over and how long would it last?
RandomK:- In the first timeline, what if Missile sucessfully saved Cabenela. What would their partnership look like?
RandomK:- what if after time traveling Missile got the attention of Yomiel and Sissel that fateful day in the park? What would their friendship look like?
RandomK:- Cabenela died to Yomiel, who was carrying a Temsik. Could he have been able to use Ghost Tricks? What would his be?
RandomK:- Say the Curry Man and the Punk Rocker had escaped from prison? What comes next for them?
RandomK:- AU where the plot kicks off because Kamilia saw her friend get taken by strangers. When she calls Lynne about it, the newely minted detective decides that her dinner can wait. She needs to investigate! -Or, where a simingly simple kidnapping investigation, is the thread that unraveles the foreigners plot.
diathadevil - Post-canon Sissel (ghost or human form), being upset over finding Lynne dead once again, which leads to them arguing and realizing how much the past affected them and Lynne's deaths affected Sissel. Reconciliation may or may not happen at your choice, we're here for the angst and drama.
diathadevil - Art of FianSissel wearing your favorite outfit! Could be from your own closet, or an outfit you've saved that's your fav. (Bonus if Yomiel is there reacting at her fit)
diathadevil - Memry drinking with Lynne as they're commiserating, and mayhaps even flirting together and smooching too I mean what who said that.
intervalart - Jowd being a good dad, interacting with his family, being happy/supportive. If you do angst, plz let it have a happy ending.
intervalart - Post canon Yomiel and Jowd hangin' out. Bein' cane/disability pals and sharing an emotional support cat.
intervalart - Jowd with an emotional support Shiny Spheal (pokemon). I kinda headcanon that would be like a therapy animal for him in jail if pokemon were a thing in that universe, cuz it would be round and pinkish like Kamila's hair, and when it evolves into Walrein, it's pink and has the same hair shape that he does, and is pink like his painter's smock. In fact Jowd with any stage of the Shiny Spheal line would be cool. Pokemon trainer Jowd? I'm not picky lol.
intervalart - Jowd and Cabs butting heads as they're working on the job. Can be pre or post canon; funny, angst, or both.
intervalart - Alma catching on that things are amiss post-canon. Maybe cheeky one-sided conversation with her and Sissel, and Sissel is thinking about what she's saying the whole time. Can be played for laughs, angst, or both.
intervalart - Cabanela/Junkyard Super. Maybe a late night at the office; reminiscing about Jowd, discussing findings about the Manipulator, Soops talks about radiation and sciencey stuff that Cabs doesn't get. Cabs does some of his flowery bs, Soops just cuts right through it; disarmingly so. Good old fashioned old man yaoi like the gods intended (obviously keep it sfw)
any of the cast with their mii / tomodachi life counterparts
man in red tricking objects but its that one levitating pizza with your mind meme
sissel accidentally calling yomiel dad + their reactions
sissel trying to read gullible on the celling (he cant pfft)
sissel keep bothering fiansissel or alma cooking, knowing damn well he can't eat anymore
yomiel painting his fiancee when he's in jail (maybe sissel is also in the painting)
raisa-drawz - [Detective in Black]/sissel human image and lynne trying to solve a case
Reefflux - Yomiel being a cat dad, either pre-game or post-game! Can be happy or sad.
Reefflux - Hugs! Cabanela/Jowd/Yomiel/Lynne/Sissel, anybody really!! These people just need some hugs. Happy hugs, sad hugs, all the hugs.
Jobswaps! Programmer Amelie? Rockstar Pigeon Man? Novelist Jowd? All of the above, none of the above, you get the gist.
(art) Steampunk it up. AU? Just a hobby? Whatever works!
Danganronpa AU, ages and species adjusted if necessary. Who's the Ultimate at what? Can Sissel change the fate of every victim in a killing game?
The gang has a night at the casino. Chaos ensues, of course.
Missile getting as loved on as he deserves.
Jowd & Yomiel, platonic, talking through their issues or finding solace in each other's presence, or just hanging out together, whatever floats your boat.
Yomiel and Sissel (cat). Any timeline or genre goes.
Yomiel & Fiansissel. Ideally something sweet and fluffy.
Any combination of Jowd, Alma, Cabanela, polyamory is welcome. No infidelity, please.
Bailey and co-worker shenanigans. Can be romantic or platonic.
sunnyaliceart - Cabanela wearing a pink coat like a flamingo or any other color of the rainbow
sunnyaliceart - Yomiel babysitting Cat Sissel and Missile. Bonus points if Yomiel is using mobility aids like a wheelchair or cane
sunnyaliceart - Jowd, Alma, and Cabanela taking Lynne and Kamila to a fair, maybe riding a ferris wheel together
sunnyaliceart - Kamila playing with Missile, Cat Sissel and Lovey Dove. She's the animal whisperer
sunnyaliceart - Jowd asking Cat Sissel to look after Kamila on her first day of high school. Hijinks ensue. Up to you if Kamila knows about Sissel's ghost powers or not
sunnyaliceart - Lynne and Kamila clothes shopping with Missile and Cat Sissel
sunnyaliceart - Jowd being great at ice skating, but Cabanela surprisingly is terrible at it
sunnyaliceart - Pigeon Man and Kamila bonding over engineering. Lovey Dove and Cat Sissel hanging out while they infodump
azurefishnets - Worldbuilding fic! There are so many things about this world they live in that are so interesting! There are robots! There are ghosts! Thereâs some kind of cold war??? There are tiny submarines that can be run by only ten crewmen! My suggestion: pick a location and a couple of characters and put them in a Situation there. See what worldbuilding develops from there!
azurefishnets - Emma & Memry. When the odd girl who always gets what she wants comes up against the Justice Minister's wife in pursuit of opposing ends (you decide what those ends are), how will they form some sort of unholy alliance?
azurefishnets - Amelie & Lynne (& MIssile?). Surely they have run into each other previously while living in the same apartment complex. What do they think of each other? What happens if Lynne happens to catch Amelie in the middle of throwing one of her legendary tantrums? Or engineer a missing moment during the in-game timeline!
azurefishnets - Emma & Kamila. Not certain they know the deeper meanings of who one is to the other, but I'm so curious how Emma's curiosity/principles would handle a small, sad little girl living next to her precious angel. Or engineer a missing moment during that night where they do actually meet!
azurefishnets - Alma & Emma: Almaâs job has been the source of much speculation and I like to think sheâs a secret cat burglar who is hired to test security at various important places, so hereâs the prompt: Alma is hired to test security at the Justice Ministerâs compound as a fake cat burglar, and runs afoul of Emma in some way. They probably know each other, distantly, so how will Alma manage to finish the job with reputation intact? Will Emma pass the security test? Will the Justice Minister ever recover?
azurefishnets - pet swap! Put a pet with a person and let some magic happen. What would have happened if Emma had a Lovey-Dove to help her write? What if Missile was hanging out with Rindge that fateful night? What if Sith had a pet rat instead of his adjutant? Just some of the many possibilities!
azurefishnets - Alma/Cabanela/Jowd (or any /& subset therof) - Always and forever the OT3 of my heart, and I will happily devour anything that develops any facet of their happy poly triangle relationship (but please no infidelity). I love these three together, or doing things with just one of the others, but always with the knowledge that they are a threesome at heart, you know?
azurefishnets - forever free square for the FFVI/GT AU! For information on the premise and previous works see: https://archiveofourown.org/series/1196335 https://archiveofourown.org/series/1169099
BLOCK C
Lemchi - Alma being Jowdâs muse for his latest masterpiece
Lemchi - Alma and Jowd taking care of newborn Kamila
Lemchi - Alma, Jowd, and Cabanela all dressed up for a fancy night out together (have fun, make them look stunning)
Lemchi - College aged Alma, Jowd, and Cabanela having fun and messing with each other while at a beach/on the lake (one of them forgets to put on sunscreen, one of them wakes up to being buried in the sand, who knows what happens, itâs up to you to decide!)
Lemchi - Just Alma and Jowd, recently married, happily in love, enjoying each others company, what a peaceful time for them
Lemchi - Alma has gotten into knitting, and now sheâs made a fun sweater for the character(s) of your choosing
Lemchi - Take an album cover of your choosing, and ghost trick-ify it (replace people on the cover with the characters, change some objects on the cover with the ones from the game, etc.)
cappyjara - fic or art, what if Detective Rindge was "awake" after dying and developed a core?
cappyjara - fic or art, it's the 13th overall Ghost Swap, we already got a black cat -- give any character some bad luck baybee
cappyjara - fic or art, Missile and Sissel bonding post-game
cappyjara - fic or art, Lynne and Kamila having alone in the submarine, the more angst the better >:)
jorb-ponderer - Alma-Jowd outfit and/or role-swap⊠i just think it'd be delightful to see her in the big coat or rocking the jorb look :)
jorb-ponderer - yomiel/jowd! post/pre/during canon, sad or sweet, all flavours are good
Sissel and Missile having fun together!
Yomiel angst! As light or heavy as you desire.
Memry x Lynne having a meal together!
Amelie and Kamila hanging out as besties!
A manga-style panel of Yomiel striking a super cool pose with Sissel nearby!
Yomiel's time in prison!
Role swap AU designs!
Missile and Sissel as humans, and human characters (as many or few as you want) as animals! Feel free to get creative with the species!
allpatchedart- Sissel/Yomiel working at a cat cafe
allpatchedart- Ghost Trick x Death Mark/Spirit Hunter crossover
allpatchedart- What would it be like if Ghost Trick had a rep in a crossover fighting game?
allpatchedart- Ghost Trick has become a turn-based RPG! What's the party composition and what are their classes?
allpatchedart- Ghost Trick x Paranormasight crossover or AU
allpatchedart- Ghost Trick x Persona crossover or AU
laughingmango - ghost household shenanigans. Anything that might happen in the new timeline, with Jowd, Alma and maybe Kamila (and Cabanela. and Lynne?) all aware of their wonderful ghost kitty
laughingmango - Cabanela/Jowd heart to heart somehow, somewhen
laughingmango - a friendship that's still new-ish for Cabanela but that Jowd remembers for a decade and moreâŠ
laughingmango - show me your grown-up Kamila and Amelie!
laughingmango - average Jowd&Sissel interaction
laughingmango - Alma&Kamila! What's their bond like, especially in the new timeline? (generally I like it when Alma comes to learn about the old timeline but this specific prompt can do with or without it. âŠunless it's about Kamila finding out too, when she's not a child anymore?)
laughingmango - Cabanela/Jowd, game timeline missing moment, giving an outlet to Cabs' yearning. When? How? You tell me!
laughingmango - Jowd does something nice for Cabanela. Imagine that
I should lock the fuck in *half an hour passes* I should lock the fuck in *half an hour passes* I should lock the fuck in *half an hour passes* I should-
I am once again begging people to realize that AI checker doesnât work. itâs never worked. itâs notoriously known to have flagged human-made works as AI and AI-generated works as human-made. and by feeding it peopleâs works, you are feeding more works to AI, because apparently the machine itself is AI.
the only thing AI checker does is harm genuine artists and people in general too.
Attended a rattlesnake conference yesterday and one of the presenters was talking about public attitudes towards snakes, specifically how showing them in a non-aggressive context helps to create more positive attitudes, and. Y'all. I NEED to show you the image he used as an example
Look at him. Look at this smiley newborn sidewinder sitting in a bottle cap. He is so small and so happy he is EXACTLY the right size to sit comfortably in a bottle cap
There are only 2 rules when it comes to writing fanfics:
Write whatever you want.
Have fun doing it.
Thatâs literally it. There is no âshow and donât tellâ. There is no âmake it realisticâ. There is no âfit in with the trendsâ. And of course, there is no âwrite as fast as possible to keep up engagement and please othersâ.
No.
Most fanfiction writers are not professional writers. This isnât a job, weâre literally writing for shits and giggles. We donât have a team of editors behind us to make our story perfect. Fanfiction isnât about creating the most perfect plot with the most perfect prose and the most perfect pacing.
Fanfiction writing is for you first. To make your heart happy. Other people just get the benefit to also enjoy it if they wish.
Thatâs it.
Write whatever makes you happy, with whatever writing style you want, whenever you want.
sometimes i wonder if we have forgotten that sharing creative work is, fundamentally, a bid for human connection. like I'm not posting art or fic for 'engagement' i'm posting it looking for other sickos to play with! i'd be making it anyway for my own gratification because there's something wrong with me, i'm sharing it hoping we can have something wrong with us together <3
So, you know how certain Christian missionaries are trained to act in a very obnoxious way, so that most people they preach to will reject them outright, so they feel like the world hates them for being Christian and they can only be friends with fellow Christians? You know that thing?
I think as activists, we sometimes need to stop and ask ourselves whether we're acting like those missionaries. I think this type of behavior is a little more ingrained into our society than some of us realize, and some of us have internalized it without realizing what it's actually meant to do.
OP I know that this is probably a different direction than you were going, but genuinely this advice would do so so much to help people not fall into secular political cults.
A lot of high control groups use this tactic to isolate their members. Itâs absolutely not just evangelizing Christians. New age wellness cults often encourage their members to make outlandish and offensive accusations regarding the mental and physical health of other people or their children, because they know that the backlash their members receive will reinforce the idea that the âmainstreamâ simply has no room for people who like crystals and essential oils. White supremacist cults will seed the vocabulary of new recruits with Nazi dog whistles that fly over those recruits heads, specifically so that they will get clocked as possible neo-Nazis and shunned by anyone who might offer them another perspective and help them to get out before itâs too late. And a lot of left-leaning political cults strongly encourage members to share their views in the most inflammatory ways possible, and then say âyou see? everyone outside of this small circle is evil and cannot be relied onâ when, inevitably, that produces bad results.
Sometimes I think that activists fall into these patterns completely accidentally, either because they were raised in culturally Christian evangelical environments and never unpacked it, or else because they just arenât any good at approaching things in a non-inflammatory way and no oneâs shown them how.
âŠBut sometimes, these structures emerge in activist circles because those circles are legitimately becoming high control groups.
I think some things to watch out for especially in this regard are:
Are you being directed to behave in an extremely hostile and alienating way? (even if itâs by someone who you trust!)
Does the group you are in immediately shut down any conversation about the effectiveness of an antagonistic strategy? In particular, do they shut that conversation down using in-group stock phrases?
Is experiencing harsh rejection seen as something of a rite of passage?
Do you receive more validation from the group you are in after you have been rejected by someone outside the group than at any other time?
Have you ever been concerned that the antagonistic strategy you are using hurt someone you cared about, only to be quickly advised by members of the group that that person was toxic and that you should actually completely cut them out of your life?
These to me are all pretty significant red flags about the group in question, whatever the specific thing that brings people together there is. If you start noticing them in a group that you are a part of, be that an in-person activist circle or a Discord server or anything in between, take a step back and seriously consider the possibility that the good thing that you joined is turning into something different, and possibly dangerous.
In the words of Jonestown survivor Deborah Layton, âNobody joins a cult. You join a self-help group, a religious movement, a political organization. They change so gradually, by the time you realize youâre entrapped â and almost everybody does â you canât figure a safe way back out.â
this is a pdf detailing the BITE model of authoritarian control, a method for determining whether or not you're in a cult.
even if you feel confident you are not and have never been in a cult, it's a good idea to familiarize yourself with the signs, just in case one begins to sneak up on you in the future.
Ok, I actually want to talk about this for a moment.
Jonestown, one of the most infamous cults in history, with a mass suicide / mass murder that left more than 900 people dead of cyanide poisoning, hundreds of whom were children⊠was a leftist political cult. That fact is an unambiguous and completely undebatable matter of historical record.
This isnât a footnote in the story of Jonestown, and it isnât a weird anti-leftist gotcha either. Jonestown attracted people to their cause with anti-segregation and anti-poverty activist work, and they did actual, meaningful good for those causes. The Peopleâs Temple was a leftist org, unambiguously. They created mutual aid networks for food aid, and rent assistance, and job placement services, and clothing donations, and winter heating. They leaned heavily on the Indianapolis Human Rights Commission in order to push desegregation, and led sit-ins and boycotts and protests. They participated in significant voter registration efforts. They led the fight against the eviction of tenants from San Francisco's International Hotel.
People joined The Peopleâs Temple because it was a good thing when they joined it. They didnât start out as brainwashed cultists, and they didnât gravitate towards the leadership of Jim Jones out of masochism, or inherent submissiveness, or a perverse love of creeping authoritarianism. They fell in line under Jim Jones because heâd built a community that was genuinely helping people, and was advancing a political cause that seemed worth fighting. They followed Jim Jones because he earned their trust.
Jim Jones then used the trust and the social capital that he had gained from all of the above in order to elevate himself to the status of a messianic figure, and abuse and profit off of his followers. Slowly but surely, he boiled the frog. It was all good â and then it was mostly good â and then, well there was some abuse, but it wasnât that bad, and it wasnât really his fault â and then there was a lot of abuse, but the outside world would destroy them if given the chance, so wasnât it the lesser of the two evils? And then, eventually, it got so bad that hundreds of people poisoned themselves and their children at his command, and murdered everyone in the compound who refused and resisted.
Your cause of choice is not immune from abusers taking advantage of it!
It doesnât matter if youâre right. It doesnât matter if your cause is just. It does not matter if your good thing really is a good thing, because there is always the possibility that it will one day be co-opted by a monster. And if the fact that it started good is enough for you to ignore that gradual, subtle change, you could end up in a truly horrible situation.
One of my best friends in undergrad got sucked into a cult. Years later, we talked about it, and he told me something that Iâll never forget which is, itâs only when you look all the way back at things that they seem crazy. You start off with things that are totally normal and innocuous: âweâre stronger togetherâ; âoppression is badâ; âyou can accomplish more if you believe in yourselfâ; âempathy is important and we should all try to bring more of it into our livesâ; etc. Then, you move to something thatâs just a little step away from that. And then again. And then again. And then again. But it never feels like a big jump, because itâs not! A -> Z is crazy, but A -> B wasnât, and B -> C wasnât, and C -> D wasnât, andâŠ
This friend was smart, and rational, and independent, and normal, and by the time he and his wife left, theyâd gone from just thinking that we should all practice more emotional mindfulness, to being terrified that leaving the cult and the cult leader would literally kill them, via the cult leader having magical powers.
If your only analysis is âWhere I started was good, and no single step since then has been crazyâ that is utterly insufficient to keep you safe.
âThis canât possibly be a cult, because when I joined it was a leftist political org and thereâs never been a single instance where it suddenly changedâ is literally the exact logic that kept people in Jonestown until it was too late.
Wait Iâm sorry parent/child incest fic?????? Why does that exist? Why do you KNOW that exists?????? What the fuck đ€ą
I feel like you can sort of tell how long (or not) someone has existed in fannish spaces by how outraged they get about things like this. Like rings in a tree trunk lol. I've been in so many fandoms. At least one, but often multiple at the same time, since I was a teenager. I've seen just. Everything.
Sex pollen. Mpreg. Incest. Monster fucking. Tentacles. Pairings like Snape/Hermione that would be crazy abusive and illegal if they were real. Wild kinks. The babygirlification of all kinds of villains. So much RPF (the 'I sincerely believe they are secretly a couple' kind and the 'this is fictional but it's fun to imagine they're in love' kind.)
You learn to just scroll past shit you don't like or unfollow people or filter tags. The tldr of fandom is that humans are weird as fuck. And creative, and unhinged, and traumatized, and talented. And amazing. And every single thing that you clutch your pearls about 'well surely someone doesn't want to read/write THAT!' - someone does. Probably lots of people do. And those people are perfectly normal. In their offline lives, they're parents and siblings and they have jobs and friends and they go about their lives and they don't cause any harm. And that's the sticking point. There's this really concerning, frankly highly Evangelical idea that if someone enjoys the wrong kind of fiction, they are obviously a Bad Person. But nothing is that simple, and thought crimes aren't real, and you definitely have some thoughts or ideas that someone else would find fucked up. You don't have to like every kind of fic that exists. I certainly don't. But shaming people for their harmless fantasies about fictional characters is so boring. I saw Goody Proctor enjoying a Toxic Ship! Good for you, I'll alert the pope.
Almost all of these are about variety. Humans need stimulation! We need enrichment! We literally cannot do the same thing every day!
The other day I was feeling miserable, so I hopped on a bus and rode it all the way back to where Iâd started, and my brain, which had finally had some proper stimulation via new environments, was suddenly ready to go again!
This is why taking walks/drives and trying new hobbies are good for you! Donât turn yourself into a sad zoo animal! You need some pumpkins to roll around in your enclosure!
at some point it's just like. do they even fucking like the thing they're asking AI to make? "oh we'll just use AI for all the scripts" "we'll just use AI for art" "no worries AI can write this book" "oh, AI could easily design this"
like... it's so clear they've never stood in the middle of an art museum and felt like crying, looking at a piece that somehow cuts into your marrow even though the artist and you are separated by space and time. they've never looked at a poem - once, twice, three times - just because the words feel like a fired gun, something too-close, clanging behind your eyes. they've never gotten to the end of the movie and had to arrive, blinking, back into their body, laughing a little because they were holding their breath without realizing.
"oh AI can mimic style" "AI can mimic emotion" "AI can mimic you and your job is almost gone, kid."
... how do i explain to you - you can make AI that does a perfect job of imitating me. you could disseminate it through the entire world and make so much money, using my works and my ideas and my everything.
and i'd still keep writing.
i don't know there's a word for it. in high school, we become aware that the way we feel about our artform is a cliche - it's like breathing. over and over, artists all feel the same thing. "i write because i need to" and "my music is how i speak" and "i make art because it's either that or i stop existing." it is such a common experience, the violence and immediacy we mean behind it is like breathing to me - comes out like a useless understatement. it's a cliche because we all feel it, not because the experience isn't actually persistent. so many of us have this ... fluttering urgency behind our ribs.
i'm not doing it for the money. for a star on the ground in some city i've never visited. i am doing it because when i was seven i started taking notebooks with me on walks. i am doing it because in second grade i wrote a poem and stood up in front of my whole class to read it out while i shook with nerves. i am doing it because i spent high school scribbling all my feelings down. i am doing it for the 16 year old me and the 18 year old me and the today-me, how we can never put the pen down. you can take me down to a subatomic layer, eviscerate me - and never find the source of it; it is of me. when i was 19 i named this blog inkskinned because i was dramatic and lonely and it felt like the only thing that was actually permanently-true about me was that this is what is inside of me, that the words come up over everything, coat everything, bloom their little twilight arias into every nook and corner and alley
"we're gonna replace you". that is okay. you think that i am writing to fill a space. that someone said JOB OPENING: Writer Needed, and i wrote to answer. you think one raindrop replaces another, and i think they're both just falling. you think art has a place, that is simply arrives on walls when it is needed, that is only ever on demand, perfect, easily requested. you see "audience spending" and "marketability" and "multi-line merch opportunity"
and i see a kid drowning. i am writing to make her a boat. i am writing because what used to be a river raft has long become a fully-rigged ship. i am writing because you can fucking rip this out of my cold dead clammy hands and i will still come back as a ghost and i will still be penning poems about it.
it isn't even love. the word we use the most i think is "passion". devotion, obsession, necessity. my favorite little fact about the magic of artists - "abracadabra" means i create as i speak. we make because it sluices out of us. because we look down and our hands are somehow already busy. because it was the first thing we knew and it is our backbone and heartbreak and everything. because we have given up well-paying jobs and a "real life" and the approval of our parents. we create because - the cliche again. it's like breathing. we create because we must.