Okay but going by that logic, wouldn't it also make Gally a potential candidate for the cure? Since he was stung and underwent the Changing too đ i like this theory, however, within canon, it doesn't hold. Starting with the fact that Thomas was already immune before entering the Mazeâthatâs the entire premise of WICKEDâs experiment. In the books, the Flare is already airborne, meaning everyone is effectively exposed from the start. Thomas would therefore be both infected and immune simultaneously, which is exactly the kind of paradox WICKED is exploiting. Except for a few designated âcontrolâ subjects (for example Newt, or if weâre talking movies, Winston as well i suppose) everyone in the Maze is Immune.
More importantly, the Griever sting and the Flare are fundamentally different in both origin and purpose. The Flare is a man-made viral pandemic that progressively destroys higher brain function. The Grievers, by contrast, are biomechanical constructs engineered by WICKED to physically test subjects and extract neurological data from Immunes. Nowhere in canon are they described as carrying a virus or simulating infection. Their sting is explicitly a pain and neuro-disruption mechanism that, in combination with the Grief Serum, triggers the âChangingââa forced neurological response that unlocks or restores memoriesânot a biological infection. If it were truly viral, it would have spread through the Glade rapidly, which it never does.
The idea that the sting is a âsimulationâ of the Flare also doesnât really align with how WICKEDâs experiments are structured. WICKED already has direct access to both Flare-infected individuals and controlled Crank Zones. Their tests in the Maze and Scorch Trials are focused on stress responses in Immunes under extreme psychological and environmental pressure, not on mechanically recreating disease progression.
The visual similarity between people undergoing the Changing and actual Cranks is likely just thatâvisual. It functions more as an external stress factor, another one of WICKEDâS precious variables, for the other Gladers witnessing it than as evidence that the same pathology is being replicated in the stung individual. (This is also just my interpretation, it's never stated in canon!)
As far as we know, every Glader who received the serum also survived the Changing. There is a fan theory that those who died or failed to recover were actually non-immune, but Ben complicates that interpretation due to inconsistencies between the books and movies. In the latter, Thomas (and everyone else) discovers Ben has been stung only after arriving, and Ben is Banished even before receiving the serum (i think? since the serum only enters the Glade with Teresa so in movie canon Alby actually is the first to receive it)ânot because heâs turning, but because he threatens Thomas and breaks Glade law. In the books, however, Ben is already mid-Changing (they already have access to the serum here) when Thomas arrives, and his hostility is tied to fragmented memories from that process. He recognises Thomas (this is true to both movies and books) and reacts out of fear and confusion rather than full-blown madness. In either version, itâs reasonable to assume he might have recovered if given proper time or treatment.
That said, if you start pushing these questions too far (which, to be fair, the series practically invites), the entire internal logic starts to unravel. Why release a catastrophic virus without a deployed cure? (rookie blunder) Why invest in elaborate Maze systems and waste resources on that instead of more direct simulations? (like those we see with Minho in TDC, way more efficient if you ask me, but no one ever asks meâŚ) Why risk killing Immunes when they might be humanityâs only viable hope? If Immunes exist, shouldnât antibodies exist tooâmaking a vaccine the obvious focus instead of a cure??????
At some point, the science just stops holding together⌠but honestly, thatâs part of the charm. Itâs easy to poke holes in it, and still somehow enjoy it anyway, right?