Why are my players like this!
Me, first time DM, with vague outline for a campaign, and a fairly solid outline for the first session.
Players, my family, all new to DnD.
Me: *playing one of my favorite NPCs, whose a little weird, and really likes the party.*
Player 1: this guy is immediately suspicious because he’s being really nice.
Me: *slightly stunned because while I do have nefarious plans for the man he hasn’t done anything yet, but he’s also just kinda like that.*
Me: *enjoying being a dramatic little shit as the NPC.*
Player 2: “where did these strange objects come from.”
Me: “oh! How bizarre, I have no idea.”
Player 2: I don’t trust that.
Me: ok, can’t you roll a-
Player 2: Nat 20. “Tell me the truth, where did these come from!”
Me: *slightly stunned* riiight… ok
Me: *working out how to not fuck up my plans to much*
Me: so he leans over, “well you see dear. I left them.”
Player 2: “ok!” Moving on!
Me: *…internally confused that didn’t go further.*
Me: *still recovering from the last incident.*
Player 3: oh, wait wait, what if the weird friendly NPC is actually the crazy powerful magical creature that created the town!
(For the record I talked about said creature ONCE, via the most jittery little priestess you ever did meet.)
Me: *internally screaming because that’s EXACTLY WHATS HAPPENING!!*
Me: what? *just act confused this is FINE*
Player 3: yeah can you imagine? Anyway!
Me: *inhuman brain screeching*
And all this in session one! It was stressful! Leave me and my weird little man who might become an antagonist alone you heathens. I need you to like him first before I can rip your hearts out!!