I’m really sad and disappointed to see the maths and sciences being absolute bullshit in a series I genuinely enjoyed.
Normally I would not be judging the maths and science in fiction so harshly, especially in films and tv shows….but this just SCREAMS that it was ai generated.
This is the equation Hodge asked his students to solve when Sherlock and James first met.
AND THE SOLUTIONS ARE LITERALLY WRITTEN ON THE RIGHT SIDE OF THE BOARD
(See red circles on the screen cap below)
The purple circles are the mistakes that are unlikely to be made by humans (such as odd placing of the square root, losing columns and zeros), even less likely if we assume the person writing is familiar with imaginary numbers, a concept that most find difficult to grasp.
Another thing to note is that the steps for solving this equation are not written in order on the board, rather they’re randomly sectioned and spread out across the board.
I would ignore this if it were a throwaway cool math trick for Sherlock and Moriarty’s first meeting……..but as it becomes a major plot point with James stealing the formula…….
These are screen caps of James holding the “formula” in his hands. And it’s just…..the last few lines of the equation written on Hodge’s board. You can easily see the identical lines by comparing these with the pictures above.
It even says quadratic formula….the thing all of us learned in middle school. Also there’s just long division on there for double checking I guess?
And the equation is incomplete (see red circle, it’s missing a zero), rendering the solution completely meaningless.
As for saying that “since there’s a positive and negative root for each equation, we’ll be able to find a way to reverse the effects of the poisonous gas,” that has so little to do with the mathematic principle that I genuinely don’t know where it came from. No one who knows imaginary numbers would write this…..so I can only assume that it’s ai generated, too.
I want to make it clear that I’m not writing this to mock anyone or show off my math skills (I’m a high school student who’s terrible at it.)
But I can’t help but feel anger and frustration that they would use ai so carelessly for such an important part of a series. It’s the equation that has supposedly killed villages of people and is threatening world peace! It’s the equation that drive Sherlock and his father, Holmes and Moriarty apart for Christ’s sake! You couldn’t have consulted a professional or even just put in a little effort?????
If you stuck to the end, I really appreciate it. Fuck ai.