Patrol had been rather uneventful for the past few nights, and the lack if action was starting to get to everyone. Leonardo seemed worried and frustrated. Raphael was becoming restless and was going to explode any minute. Michelangelo was irritating everybody, which was not helping the situation at all, and Donatello was just bored. He was tired of going out night after night and not having anything to do. He would much rather be home, in his lab, working on his projects than out here wasting time.
He sighed heavily as Leonardo ordered them to stop. Raphael twirled his sai as he paced, grunting and muttering under his breath. Michelangelo started humming and tapping his nun-chaku against a nearby metal pole. Leonardo whipped his head around and shushed them, giving them each a glare before turning back to look over the city. Donatello sighed once more and turned to walk to the edge of the rooftop, distancing himself from the tense atmosphere that his brothers were creating. He stood in the edge and looked out over the city. He listened to all the sounds and took a deep breath. Leonardo signaled for them to start moving again and Donatello reluctantly moved from the edge of the rooftop. He was about to follow his brothers when he heard music and singing. He stopped dead in this tracks, turned and tried to focus on the sound.
... Promise me that all you say is true. That's all I ask of you...
“Donnie.” Leonardo broke him out of his trance.
Donatello stumbled and just about stopped his glasses from falling off of his face. “What?” He turned to face Leonardo.
“We're heading back.” He stated simply.
“Oh, yeah, sure. I'll, um... I'll catch up.” Donatello said as he turned back to face the direction of the distant music.
Leonardo scoffed and turned around. “Be back before sunrise.” He grumbled and leapt off of the rooftop, disappearing into the shadows.
Donnie waited for all of them to leave before he headed in the direction that the music was coming from.
... All I want is freedom, a world with no more night and you, always beside me, to hold me and to hide me...
Donatello leapt from rooftop to rooftop, following the beautiful sound and allowing curiosity to take over. He stopped after the third or fourth rooftop, as he realized that the song was much clearer now, he must have been a rooftop away from the source of the music. He moved towards the sound, keeping in the shadows and out of sight. Eventually he saw a small CD player sitting on a side table next to a plastic garden chair, and in that garden chair sat a girl.
Her eyes were closed and she had a small smile on her face while some stray strands of her (H/C) hair blew freely in the slight breeze. She looked so peaceful and beautiful at that moment. He was so focused on her overall appearance that he almost did not see that her lips were moving. For a second, he thought that she was talking to someone. He suddenly became extremely aware of his surroundings and looked around to see if he could see anybody besides the girl and himself on that rooftop, but he soon realised that they were alone. He focused on listening to what she was saying and that she was actually singing.
... Say you'll share with me, one love, one lifetime, say the word and I will follow you...
Donatello was in awe at how beautiful her voice was.
... Share each day with me, each night, each morning.... Say you love me.... Love me, that's all I ask of you...
“Hey! Quit it, girly!” A voice from below startled Donatello. “Some of us are trying to sleep here!”
The girl’s eyes shot open, revealing beautiful (E/C) eyes. “You have work in an hour, Mister Maloney! You should be up already and this is the only time I can practice!” She frowned and pushed herself out of her chair. “I was done anyway.” She grumbled.
Donatello watched as she packed up her things and carefully made her way down the fire escape, climbing through her open window and disappearing behind the drapes. The sound of an alarm beeping brought him back to earth. The sun was going to rise soon and he needed to be underground before that happened. He took a mental note of her address and the time before racing down to the nearest man hole and slipping back into the sewers.
He thought about her as he walked back to the lair. Her (H/C) hair and (E/C) eyes were so beautiful. Her voice... it was so amazing, she didn't really need to practice.
“Wait.” He suddenly stopped walking. “Why does she need to practice?” He mumbled.
He tried to remember the lyrics to figure out what the song was.
“Promise me that you are true?....” He scratched his head. “No, no. That doesn't sound right.”
He continued walking, so deep in thought that he walked right into the lair, passed his brothers and headed straight for his lab, mumbling incoherently and not giving them a second glance.
“What's up with Donnie?” Michelangelo asked his larger, red masked brother. “He looks super spaced out, bro....”
Raphael scoffed. “Don's always like that, Mikey.” He said as he chewed on the toothpick in his mouth.
Donatello took no notice of them and entered his lab, closing the door behind him.
Donatello sat at his computer and tried to remember as much as he could, typing all of it into the Google search bar. He pressed enter and stared at the results.
“The phantom of the opera?” He said as he sat back in his chair. “I don't think I've watched that.”
Donatello read about the movie once or twice but never really gave it a second thought. He decided to read about it again and discovered that there were two, the original and a remake. He couldn't decide which one to watch so he ended up watching both. He found the constant singing a bit unnecessary but considering that it was a musical, he just accepted it. He actually found himself enjoying the movies, the original more than the remake but the story line was quite captivating.
In the days that followed, Donatello went back to that rooftop to hear her sing. Some mornings she would stay up there longer than usual but she was always there practicing her little song. He even caught himself humming the tune every so often. He couldn’t stop thinking about her and, much to his surprise; it was actually making him happy. His change in mood was noticeable and Leonardo was starting to get slightly suspicious. He wanted to question Donatello about his late nights but didn’t want to ruin his mood, at least one of them was happy.
One night, after patrol, Donatello got to the rooftop and the girl wasn't there. He was a bit puzzled at first but decided to wait. It was still quite early. After waiting for a while, Donatello became worried. He thought that she wasn't going to show but just as his concern grew even more, she made an appearance. She set out her things as usual and started practicing.
He immediately calmed down and exhaled with relief. He found an old air-con vent and decided to sit down but it unexpectedly gave in to his weight and collapsed with a very loud, metallic clang. The girl gasped and shot up out of her seat, startled. Donatello went into ninja mode and quickly hid in the shadows.
“Who's there?” The girl called into the darkness.
Donatello panicked. A million thoughts were running through his head at that moment. Should he run? Should he stay? He thought about staying quiet but he was worried that she would be too scared to ever come back out on to the rooftop. He’d never see her again.
“I know you're there! Come out!” Her voice broke through his thoughts.
“No.” He cringed at his own bluntness.
There was a slight pause. “No? What do you mean ‘no’?” she said, obviously confused.
Donatello was starting to get nervous. “I-I can't.” He choked out.
“Why not?” The girl asked as she took a tentative step closer.
“I don't want you to see me.” Donatello moved through the shadows, making his voice seem like it was coming from different directions each time he spoke.
“You won't like what you see.” Donatello said softly, just loud enough so that she could hear but not letting her hear the hurt in his voice.
The was another pause. He looked at her face from the shadows, she looked confused. Sad almost. “What do you mean?” She said with a worried frown on her face.
Donatello thought for a moment. He thought about the song that she had been singing and the movie it came from and he suddenly got an idea.
“I-I'm horribly deformed.” He lied.
“Oh...” She frowned again. “I'm sure you don't look that bad.” Even though she tried to hide it, Donatello could hear her voice was laced with worry.
Donatello stopped moving around and chuckled at her attempt at being nice. “I'm hardly human.” He said, not exactly lying.
“Don't say that. I'm sure you're more human than most.” Her (E/C) eyes continued to search the shadows for signs of movement. “It's not all about what you're like on the outside.” Her voice picking up a bit.
"I guess, but I still think you'll find me gross." Donatello sighed.
"Well how about we just chat then?" The girl suggested. "Let's get to know each other and maybe you'll feel more comfortable about showing yourself."
Donatello thought for a moment. "Y-yeah, okay. That sounds good." He said with a nervous laugh.
"Cool." She smiled. "Let's start with your name."
"Donatello." He said shyly, "But everyone calls me Donnie."
"That's a really cool name." She beamed. "My name is (Y/N). Pleased to meet you, Donnie."
Donatello met (Y/N) on that rooftop every chance he got. These little secret meetings went on for weeks, Donatello waiting for her on the rooftops and chatting to her from the shadows. Most mornings he would listen to her sing for a while before making her aware of his presence. There were a few times when (Y/N) would ask Donatello to show himself but each time she asked he would say no and apologise. It hurt him to see the look of disappointment on her face but he knew that it was for the best. Yet, each time he saw that look, it slowly broke his resolve.
Early one morning, Donatello sat in his usual spot and waited. The darkness in the night sky was just beginning to fade and the stars weren't shining as brightly anymore. The sun would start to rise soon and (Y/N) was usually out by now. Not a moment later, he heard the familiar sound of the rooftop maintenance door opening, indicating the arrival of the young song bird. Donatello settled down, expecting (Y/N)'s beautiful voice to ring through the air. He waited. But nothing happened. He frowned, wondering why she wasn't singing. He stole a glace to check if it was not maybe someone else that came up instead. But all he saw was (Y/N), gazing up at the fading stars. He wondered why she wasn't singing. He wondered if he should say something. He heard her sigh and could feel the sadness in it. It almost broke his heart.
"(Y/N)?" Donatello called out tentatively.
"Donnie." She gave a soft smile. "I'm sorry if I was a little late."
"I overslept." She stated simply.
"No, I meant why aren't you singing?"
"Oh," she paused and took a breath. "I don't need to practice anymore." She said softly.
"I didn't get the part, Donnie."
Donatello felt her sadness again. "Oh..." Was all he managed to say.
"Well, I got the part but I've been replaced." She added, disdain creeping into her voice.
"Replaced?" Donatello crept a bit closer.
"Yes." She sighed. "The male lead managed to convince the director that his girlfriend should play Christine because she looks more like her from the movie. They're such hypocrites!" She crossed her arms over her chest, and frowned. "When I auditioned for the part they said that everyone is welcome because they wanted to have a diverse cast and they wanted to be different. But then they pull something like this?!" She raised her voice at the last sentence. "Unbelievable." She mumbled. Donatello didn't know what to say. He didn't know if he even should say anything. She sighed again and shook her head. "I'm sorry, Donnie. I'm just venting."
He smiled. "It's okay. We all need to vent sometimes."
He heard her chuckle. "Since we're sharing, what do you need to vent about?"
"My brothers." Donatello said without thinking.
"Donnie?" (Y/N) called out. "You still there?"
"You weren't supposed to know that..." He said sheepishly.
Donatello didn't know how to answer that. The silence dragged on for a few moments until (Y/N) spoke up, encouragingly.
"No, this is good." She sounded eager. "Please continue. I'd love to hear more about your brothers." She tried to spur him on. "What are their names? What are they like?"
Donatello fought many internal battles, trying to decide if he should reveal any more about himself or his life, not wanting to endanger the rest of his family. But he didn't have to tell her too much. Where they lived didn't need to come up yet. Yeah... And if all else fails, he could just run...
"Well, there's Leo, Raph, Mikey and I..."
Donatello spoke and (Y/N) listened. He told her as much as he could without revealing too much and answering the few questions that she had whenever he could.
"It sounds amazing, Donnie." She said a while after they fell into a comfortable silence. "You're lucky to have brothers like that. To have people you can count on."
Donnatello was quiet and thought about her words. "Yeah," he said softly. "I guess I am."
"I'd love to meet your brothers."
Donatello didn't know what to say. He knew what that implied and it terrified him.
"I don't know if that's a good idea." He said warily.
Donatello heard (Y/N) sigh. "I feel like I haven't met you properly and I don't like it. It feels so... I dunno," He heard her sigh again. "I don't think that 'fake' is the right word but it doesn't feel real, you know?"
"Yeah," Donatello's voice was barely a whisper. "I get it."
After a long pause, (Y/N) spoke up. "Don't you trust me?"
Donatello's heart clenched. He could hear the sadness in her voice and it sounded as if she was holding back tears. "No, (Y/N), it's not that." He found it difficult to tell her that it's not safe without telling her everything.
"Then what is it, Donnie?"
He stayed silent, not knowing what to say or do.
"I feel like I've finally made a proper friend, but at the same time... I feel like I'm talking to a stranger." She spoke so softly, her voice breaking slightly at the end. "I have so many questions but I'm scared that if I ask, I might scare you away."
"What questions?" Donatello heard himself say.
"Like, why are you out at this time of the night? And are your brothers like you?" She paused waiting for some kind of answer. "Why do you speak of your brothers so fondly but sound so lonely?" She added softly.
"We're all just a little stressed right now." He said after a while.
She at quietly waiting for him to continue, but he didn't, so she spurred him on slightly. "But...?"
Donatello sighed. "But I feel like they don't get me sometimes."
"Is that why you're up here all the time, talking to me?"
Donatello thought about her question. He thought about everything... And then he decided to to stop overthinking.
"I'm a six foot eight mutant turtle." He blurted out.
There was silence and Donatello panicked for a second.
"Are you serious?" (Y/N) asked. "I don't think this is funny, Donnie."
He heard her get up from her little lawn chair and panicked even more. "No! I'm completely serious!" He wracked his brain, trying to figure out a way to get her to stay. "I'll show you!"
He heard her stop and sigh. "If this some stupid joke-"
Donatello stepped out of the shadows and stepped up behind her, unintentionally startling her. She gasped and jumped a little before focusing on him. Her eyes landed on his chest first and shot up to his face. She gasped again and stumbled backwards, tripping over an exposed pipe that neither of them noticed and toppled over the edge of the building. Donatello lurched forward as her scream pierced the air and, with inhuman speed, dove over the edge after her. He reached out and grabbed her, before firing his grappling rope and pulling them back up to the roof top.
"Are you okay?" Donatello asked as soon as they landed safely. "I'm so sorry for scaring you." He felt her shaking in his arms and felt extremely guilty. "I didn't mean-"
"It's okay. I'm sorry too, I didn't mean to... you know. I-I didn't mean to react that way. I just wasn't expecting..."
Still clinging to him with her forehead against his plastron, Donatello felt her nod in reply. He moved to let go of her but she held him tighter and buried her face in the crook of his arm.
"No," she said when he tried to let go of her. "I mean, can we just stay like this for a little while? Please?"
Donatello was somewhat confused but figured that she needed time to process everything, so he held on to her. After a few moments, he felt her give him a little squeeze and felt her hold loosen. Taking that as a sign that she was ready, he loosened his hold as well, and dropped his arms to hang at his sides. She took a small step back and tilted her head slowly. Donatello couldn't help but smile when her eyes meet his and she let out a quiet 'wow'. Her hand came up to his plastron, as if she wanted to touch it, but she retracted it at the last second. Instead, her hands went up to the sides of her face and she let out a breathy laugh in awe of what she was seeing.
"It's a long story." Donatello gave her a nervous smile.
"I've got time." She smiled up at him but her smile faded when she glanced behind him. "But you don't." She frowned as she looked at the first light of the rising sun.
Donatello turned and followed her gaze. He hadn't even noticed the stars fade or the sky getting lighter. He grumbled to himself and turned back to her, taking her hands in his. "I'll be back tonight and I'll explain everything." He gave her hands a little squeeze before letting go and stepping back.
"Same time?" She asked, worried.
He noticed her worry and thought for a moment. "How about after midnight?" He was almost at the edge of the building.
"After midnight's great."
"Great." He said as her turned and sent a little wave over his shoulder. Leo would be so mad at him for staying out so late... early? Someone could have seen him. He stepped up to the ledge at the very edge of the rooftop and got ready to descend to the dark alley below.
"Great." He heard (Y/N) giggle nervously. "It's a date."
He froze. "A date?" He whispered.
But by the time he turned around, the maintenance door was already swinging closed and (Y/N) was gone.
"Why is there no frosting on this poptart?"
(Y/N) asked as they stood in the kitchen, with one hand on her hip and the other hand holding the treat up in front of him. She knew full well that it was him that had licked it off yet she still asked the question, hoping to at least make him feel guilty enough to not do it again. He smiled sheepishly and shrugged before he resumed his task of making Hot Chocolate for them. She rolled her eyes and couldn't stop the smile that crept up onto her face.
"What am I going to do with you?" She asked as she walked back towards the fridge.
"Love me..." Donnie started singing in an off key falsetto. "That's all I ask of you."
(Y/N) rolled her eyes again and started laughing as Donatello 'sang' the instrumental part of the song.
Raphael's booming voice rang through the air from where he sat watching TV and (Y/N) rushed to him to clamp both hands over Donatello's mouth to try and stop the noise he was making.
"Stop, Donnie." She giggled.
"He's just jealous." Donatello whispered before leaning down and giving her a light peck on the lips.
They both blushed and (Y/N) fixed his glasses before pressing her lips to his snout.
"Gross guys, we make food in here," Raphael pulled a face as he walked past them to retrieve another bag of cookies. "And I'm not jealous," he grumbled as he left the kitchen.