So, the conversation about Morrisonās retcon being racist comes up a lot, and some people have difficulty understanding just why the way Morrison wrote Talia was racist in general.
If youāre familiar with the tropes common among writing asian and arab women in media, youāll be familiar with how hypersexualized many of these characters are and how thereās a distinct fetishized manner that theyāre portrayed.
@thearielbee on Twitter describes it best, and she gave me permission to repost her thread here.
So, if you look up Asian Babymama you will find an exact description of the way Talia was presented in Morrison's run, and has been presented ever since.
And I think what makes it especially egregious in Talia's case is that their relationship was originally very much NOT this. Talia was never presented as having a Dragon Lady personality.
Originally she was a rather soft personality - a pacifist, according to her creator Denny O'Neil, who was unable to fully express her pacifism due to her loyalty to Ra's al Ghul. She ultimately just yearned for peace, freedom and love. And Damian's conception, back before he had a name, was originally not a retconned in footnote, it was actually a story where she was the legitimate real time romantic interest of Batman and she made an unselfish choice to give her son up for his sake and for his father's sake, rather than having conceived him in secret because Ra's needed an heir or whatever.
Point being - all of that was retconned into her, which makes it even worse than if she were just created as a stereotype because not only was it a very uncomfortable use of asian tropes, it was using them at the expense of a character who had previously defied those stereotypes.
And notice now her existence is confined very much to that role - she spent 35 years as a present and onscreen love interest, but since that storyline she's been written as a romance from his youth that ended ages ago ("It's been a long time since Beloved," he said to her even though they'd only ended their romance a couple of REAL WORLD years earlier, and that's been the story ever since), and ultimately wasn't that important aside from providing Damian and being the motivation for her turning evil. Also the conception was retconned from being a natural result of their romance to being, as the trope says, a decision she made for a "strange and twisted" reason - she's not even allowed to conceive and birth him naturally now, he had to be gestated in a chamber and altered to become a genetically perfect child that she wanted to continue to al ghul legacy, which... I mean isn't something she ever cared about before but the point is...
Talia was never a dragon lady or an asian babymama trope, and that story retconned her into both, chopped off the parts of her character that didn't conform to those tropes (which was basically ALL of her character aside from her design) and trapped her in that stereotype for, as of now, 15 years and counting.