Another Canon Divergence AU idea for "The Princess Bride" is that Westley ISN'T following Buttercup when she gets kidnapped. If he's not doing that, presumably intending on kidnapping and confronting her himself, then he really has no way of finding out about the kidnapping besides, again, spying on Humperdink and Rugen (which is very difficult to do). And if he's not there to follow the kidnappers almost immediately, then he has no way to intervene in time.
So, Westley has been a LOT of unpleasant shit to get back and has just found out his true love has moved on to become engaged to their local prince. He's confused. He's really pissed off. He misses whatever opportunity allowed him to follow Buttercup on her daily ride (didn't see her ride out, didn't hear about it, whatever), because he's following another opportunity into the castle to investigate Humperdink. Or else he sees Humperdink and Rugen riding off towards the Pit of Despair together and decides to follow them instead. Either way, Westley overhears the two men very casually discussing Humperdink's beautiful but forcibly gained fiancée and the kidnapping plot currently underway, and Westley realizes that Buttercup is about to DIE and he's very likely not going to be able to reach his true love in time. He still runs off, desperate and ready to die trying to save her.
And Westley is really much to late to cross the water and climb the Cliffs of Insanity and all that, because Buttercup and her kidnappers are already at the border with Guilder. It's fine though, because when Fezzik and Inigo are confronted with the murder part of the job, they object, and Fezzik ultimately decides that he's really not cool with it. Fezzik thumps Vizzini over the head while Vizzini is berating Inigo. Fezzik apologizes to Buttercup. Inigo looks at the unconscious (possibly dead, heavily concussed at least) Vizzini, shrugs, and then helps Fezzik untie Buttercup and apologizes as well.
It's more than a little awkward, because none of them really know what to do besides wander vaguely back towards Florin. Buttercup admits that she doesn't really want to marry the prince, and he'll find her if she goes back to the farm, which leads into her telling the story of her dead true love, which Inigo and Fezzik find very romantic. Which leads into Fezzik and Inigo both sharing their own tragic backstories in turn. Buttercup is personally very intrigued by Inigo's mention of being in the revenge business.
And then Buttercup goes, "Wait a moment, I know a nobleman like that. Count Rugen is Prince Humperdink's closest friend and confidant, and he has six fingers on his right hand. I once had to sit next to them at a dinner table while they spent over an hour discussing all the troubles of finding a good glovemaker and skincare for their hands." (Rugen and his wife also once visited Buttercup and Westley's farm when they were younger, but Buttercup would more recently know Rugen from just... around the castle. Rugen is presumably going to be Humperdink's best man.)
So, Westley is like, "Where the HELL is the love of my life???" presumably harrassing Vizzini about it if Vizzini is still alive. And Humperdink has his theatric rescue party together to find Buttercup's body on the border, unknowingly following behind a rushing and frantic Westley, trying to keep his lies straight while he's internally like, "What the HELL happened to my kidnapping and murder plot to invite a war??? Rugen, I thought you hired the best??? It's so hard to find good help these days!"
Meanwhile, Buttercup, Fezzik, and Inigo are on a new friendship quest back to Count Rugen's house. Buttercup is the future princess, and so is presumably already acquainted with Rugen's young and beautiful wife, who has to let her in and be a good hostess. The Countess is like, "Buttercup... Who are these unkempt and intimidating men...?"
And Buttercup says, "Oh, they saved me from being kidnapped and killed! 😄 I'm sure that my fiancé will want to thank and reward them in person! 😄 This was the closest safe place I could think of! Thank you so much for your hospitality. By the way, when do you think your husband might be home? 😄"
Tags from @pleasantartisanhottea
I *know* that in the original, Buttercup and Westley had this grand romance and Inigo took over the Dread Pirate Roberts name and Fezzik...did something. Did he have a plan? Maybe he becomes Inigo's first mate.
But imagine:
Humperdink and various soldiers catch up to Westley and the extremely useless Vizzini. Westley, recognizing the murderous fiance of his beloved, talks a good line and gets himself in Humperdink's...not good graces, the man is too suspicious for that, but at least begrudged tolerance.
Vizzini, of course, is executed before he can spill the beans. Or at least is gagged and taken to Rugen's secret torture dungeon. No big loss.
So that party heads back to the castle with the prince in A Mood (TM), and he's demanding someone bring him Rugen before he's even through the castle gates.
Meanwhile, back at Rugen's ACTUAL home (mini castle), Inigo is giving Buttercup a swordfighting lesson to pass the time and Fezzik is helping out with all those little chores that pile up while the lord is away. Like rearranging the furniture single handedly. The countess is actually quite charmed - he's very careful, and he keeps offering excellent suggestions about where to place different pieces for easiest use, and he doesn't mind moving things over and over when she changes her mind!
Anyway, the Nice Old King dies, poor man, and Humperdink summons all his nobles so he can rush through a coronation. Lady Rugen is all over the place, not knowing what to do, but she escorts Princess Buttercup and her sworn knights (aka they escort Lady Rugen) back to the capitol.
Something something, Inigo and Westley nearly come to blows over "that's my girl!" but then Humperdink opens his big dumb mouth and suddenly it's Westley and Inigo (and Fezzik) vs Humperdink and Rugen, and there's really only one way this can go.
Westley is now the king by right of conquest, assuming he even wants it, and Buttercup is putting her foot down that they are NOT breaking up their fun new gang, and Inigo and Fezzik are like "idc, man, whatever you want."
Anyway, Buttercup decides that SHE will be reigning queen, in her own name, and Prince Westley will be her consort and Inigo, newly ennobled as a count, will be her chief advisor. (And their lover, shhh.) Fezzik leads the Queen's Guard, and between him and Inigo, they whip everyone into actual effectiveness. Former-Countess Rugen becomes a lady-in-waiting to the Queen, which she likes much better than marriage to a man who plans wars and assassinations and new torture methods.
I'm not sure how Miracle Max fits in, but he definitely gets invited back to the castle. Maybe he revives the previous king ("he was only MOSTLY dead!" - Humperdink is terrible at poisoning), who then supports Buttercup's claim to the throne. He likes her, she's clever AND kind. The kingdom could use more of that.
Vizzini never recovers from his concussion and is eventually buried with the disgraced prince and count in an unmarked grave. Fezzik makes sure that lots and lots of buttercups are planted there every spring as a final "fuck you."
I actually kinda want to apprentice Vizzini to Miracle Max.
This might be because I'm addicted to redemption arcs, ones where terrible people really come to be aware of how they fucked up and who they hurt. This might be because I like the "proud man forced to learn" situation. But also I can see how it would work?
As soon as Queen Buttercup learns about the Pit of Despair, she gets busy. The place wasn't just a torture hole - it was a bespoke D&D dungeon designed by a real-world equivalent of a vindictive DM. There are snakes down there. There are other prisoners. I think there was a gorilla. It becomes a pet project, rehoming and rehabilitating all the critters that can be. Prisoners return to their families. The life-sucking machine gets disassembled. A giant octopus swims back into the ocean and everyone sheds a tear.
And then there's Vizzini. Vizzini was imprisoned for failure and meant to serve as a lesson to Rugen/Humperdinck's other catspaws. Vizzini has had a terrible time. Vizzini had an untreated concussion that he had to situate on his own. Vizzini's roommate was one of the top 10 deadliest spiders in the world, a fact he is very aware of. Vizzini's pride is shaken. Vizzini, whose entire self is built upon being the cleverest man in the room, got tortured by Count Rugen, who is also a very clever man - who's just like him if he didn't have to scrape and scheme and scramble for everything he had. Who's just like him if he was noble, attractive, and rich. Who held the knife and the hot iron. Who Vizzini hated, and who Vizzini desperately wanted to be.
He's not in a good mental space when he's let out. He kinda half-heartedly mooches off of Inigo and Fezzik, and they kinda let him because jesus, look at the guy. They set him up in an apartment, at least. They know just enough about him to pity him, which he hates all the more. He's supposed to be up to some Medici shit. His family is Sicilian, but he was expected to scheme like a Venetian. And he keeps at it, low little plots mostly to pass the time - vendettas against the baker's boy, vengeance against the landlord's dog, because he's supposed to be smart enough to make up for all the rest of his flaws and he just can't do it. He'll never be able to do it. Count Rugen made it very clear just how deficient he was.
Then Miracle Max, who's still embedded with the royal family because he's the closest thing Florin has to healthcare, has a heart scare. He medicated it, but he had a heart scare last year, too. He's old, he's not going to last forever, everyone thinks he has some super immortality pill but nobody gets that privilege, and what happens when he goes? Who takes care of his witch? (she never needed taking care of, but she's never going to tell him that.) All that learning, all his miracles, does that all just go away? Vanish into a rooty grave? That's that?
He begins applying for apprentices. Buttercup gives him a list of court kids, Inigo and Westley of former pirate kids, Fezzik of circus friends he thought were nice. Vizzini gets thrown into the mix as an afterthought. Miracle Max takes one look at the guy and feels... something. Pity, probably. Because the thing is that he is clever, he's clever and he was born with nothing and whatever the fuck was happening in city-state not-Italy at the time has trained him not to see people as people, and if he's not given something to do he's eventually going to find something to do, and what else do you do with that? Let him rot? Hope he dies? He needs something to do with his hands. He needs to recite integers of pi while grinding morning glory seeds.
So, yeah, Miracle Max's apprentice is now a balding fortysomething Sicilian, and both of them low-key hate it, but not as much as both of them are mentally stimulated by the whole affair. Max and Vizzini openly scheme assassination attempts at each other while emulsifying the chocolate ("I'm going to get you locked up for treason, old man." "You think I don't know lawyers? My cousin oversaw Rugen's will. I'm going to poison your coffee." "Just like mama used to do. I dab a bit on my wrist every morning. It's nostalgic. I'm going to get you run over by a bull."). Max's wife openly pities and infantilizes him, calls him Vivi and bakes him those pastries he likes, and Vizzini hates this but also never refuses it because there's something, there's still something, that never stopped wanting what he was told he never deserved.
Nothing happens immediately. Everything happens over years. Vizzini bitches about the lack of hot peppers and now he's in charge of the garden. Vizzini is a much better accountant than Max and gets the hut remodeled, which spurs just months of Max bitching, up until the hot tub gets installed. Vizzini is given something to do with his mind and hands. He learns that the dose makes the poison. He has to mix the medicine when Max has more of those heart scares. He becomes, day by day, week by week, year by year, different than the person he was. Still the same sarcastic, superior little nugget, that can't change, but now it's tuned towards making people take their full course of antibiotics out of spite. Now he schemes to make people see him for that thing with their elbow, jesus how do you go to work every day with that?
One day he's out peeling willow bark and he comes across Rugen's grave. They still had to give him a nice one, in the royal cemetery with all the good willow trees nobody checks, but still. Vizzini wonders. A lot of people are willing to believe that bad people are just bad people, that there's nothing that can be done about it. You kill bad people, right? Or you crown them and hope they're awful in your favor. The last thing he remembers of this one was the knife and the hot iron, and now this. It could have very easily been his own grave - smaller, of fucking course they'd make it smaller - right next door.
He gets the willow. And some wild blackberries, fucking Max only takes his medicine if it's immured in a sugar pill big enough to taste. He gets to live. He gets to walk home.
It could've been so very different.


























