"What's going on?" "You know what's going on" I looked from him to her. Her to him. I had given him a get out clause and had just thrown it back in my face. My nightmare was real. It was over. I was 17. He was 22. She was in the year below me at school. I couldn't move. I tried to talk, I couldn't. My friend led me out of his hostel. I was heartbroken. I was reminded of that fateful day yesterday when the hackers of controversial site AshleyMadison.com released the identities, email addresses and sexual preference details of some 37 million people, mainly men, who have signed up to the site which encourages married users to have an affair. I thought of the millions of women forced to confront the truth that their partner was not the man they thought he was. Forced to feel that punch in the pit of the stomach. That shock. That humiliation. As solicitors across the country get ready for the influx of divorce petitions, I wonder, does an affair, or a desire to indulge in one, have to spell the end of a relationship? Why do so many men cheat? And what is the answer then, to maintaining a long lasting healthy relationship? To most of us, a relationship is a voluntary agreement between two people to love, be intimate with and respect one another. A marriage is of course when this agreement is legalised, but either way, couples choose this relationship model and my gut feeling is that if you chose it, stick to it. Or if not, leave. It's simple. I fully understand that the honeymoon period wains, the sex may decrease. I fully understand that people find other people attractive and that's totally natural. I get that over time crushes on others may develop and I understand that flirting occurs - it's a nice ego boost to know someone else fancies you! It's all harmless. Or should be. This is where the line should be drawn. If you go beyond this, you're putting your selfish desire before someone you 'love' and that means you have to be prepared for that relationship, that 'love', to end. If you chose to cheat, you are effectively gambling something precious away. The gamble can be fatal for the relationship or it can pay off. Let's face it, there's a chance the woman won't ever know and even if she does, if it's a one one off discretion, there's a chance it may be forgiven - most outed cheaters cling onto this scenario. But I can understand a woman's choice here. Sometimes a longterm, invested relationship means more than their partners impulsive one night stand. There is no right and wrong. So I can understand the need to cheat, I can understand I woman's choice to stay and work it through. What I cannot understand so well is someone who goes online, creates a profile, pays money on a credit card and actively seeks out to not only cheat, but engage in a prolonged and premeditated 'affair'. This seems so much worse. Maybe I feel this strongly about affairs because I have never had an affair or cheated - not through lack of opportunity may I add - but because I just have never wanted do that to someone I love. So that's why it hurt so much when I was 17 and realised my first love was a selfish cheating liar. I couldn't get out of bed and I cried for months. I couldn't understand how someone I was so close to could be so unbelievably horrible to me. I did of course get over it and learn from it. I hardened at first, I even went out with a guy with a girlfriend to prove I didn't care about love, to prove that whole thing was bullshit to me. But eventually I met someone and fell in love again. I think even now, in my current relationship, as much as I love my partner, I will never fully trust another human being like I used to. I wonder, are men are naturally predisposed to cheating and is that just the way it is? Do I have to reluctantly conclude that my loving boyfriend will one day join the ranks of those before him and hurt me and deceive me? Only now I'm not 17. I'm at an age when I'm making big life decisions about children, marriage, mortgages. Will it inevitably all end in disaster because men will have to eventually cheat? In the article 'Top 3 Reasons Why Men Cheat' from practicalhappiness.com, suggests so, saying that 'Most men are driven by a powerful natural force to seek novelty and variety when it comes to sexual partners... The desire to be liked and attract women is one of the most significant ways through which men are able to validate their masculinity'. Erm, is that not just an excuse to normalise sexist 'boys will be boys' behaviour? Saying that naturally men 'need variety' is the interest of one gender at the detriment to the other. So men must find a variety of women to be fulfilled whilst women must happily sit at home raising children waiting for their hubby to return? This view discounts responsibility and the ability to care for another human being's feelings. Qualities that all men are actually capable of (and would exhibit a lot more if we stopped this 'boys will be boys' culture). No, I believe women get the same desires that men also get, but the only difference is men are encouraged by society to celebrate their sexuality, to 'conquer' multiple women and so they act on these desires at lot more. So what's the solution? Forcing people to stay in unfulfilled sexually frustrated relationships? No. Perhaps it's monogamy that needs to end? Maybe it's time we normalised open relationships, where both the man and woman openly have sex with others when they have the desire to do so? Dr Anderson, sociologist at The University of Winchester and author of The Monogamy Gap: Men, Love, and the Reality of Cheating (Oxford University Press) claims monogamy isn't the only "proper" way to be in a relationship, and it's time that society finds "multiple forms of acceptable sexual relationship types including sexually open relationships.. that coexist without hierarchy or hegemony." Sounds like the answer to the inequality that exists in many relationships, but the question is, can this actually work? Wouldn't jealously naturally play a part? In a recent Cosmopolitan article 'What it's Really Like to be in an Open Relationship', journalist Emma Barker interviewed 2 women in open relationships who were both very positive about their lifestyle choice, citing honesty as one of pros of such a relationship. Woman A says the success is being 'Open and forthcoming about everything you are thinking and feeling'. She says 'Jealousy often comes when you suspect something is going on in your loved one's head that they're not telling you'. Makes sense. Isn't it the lies and deceitful behaviour in cheating that hurts the most? Woman B commented that 'I feel very free to be who I am, and after feeling so stifled in my marriage it's refreshing to feel like I can explore and enjoy life again'. It certainly sounds liberating. But for me I personally, I love that bond that you grow with that one person in a relationship - it is so special and intimate. I'm not sure multiple relationships or lovers would allow that bond to exist in the same way. Maybe it's just the way we think about monogamous relationships that need to change, not the actual idea of two people being faithful. Maybe we need to all stop trying to chase the honeymoon period buzz that will inevitably end. Dr Anderson says: 'We falsely believe that when the sex dies, the relationship has also died. The reality is the opposite; when the sex dies the relationship has just begun'. I get that. You get to know that person like no one else does, you get to love that person on a much deeper level. But unlike Dr Anderson, I don't agree that the sex should have to die. It should become more intimate, more meaningful, more connected. Better. And if not, work on making it so, like you would any other important thing you want in life. So I have no sympathy for those men whose names pop up on the hacked AshleyMadison.com email list. They chose the easy route, didn't want to work on what they had and now they have to face the consequences. Some women will leave them; just as some will choose stay and work through it. But I feel for each and every one who find their partner's email address on there, or is approached by their hubby for an awkward conversation. Because as all women who have ever been on the receiving end of infidelity know, it's not the desire to want someone else sexually that's hurtful, that's natural, it's the choice to act on it and deceive. I'm no expert, but I'm going to be hopeful - the secret to a long healthy relationship is far from simple but let's start here: communication - work on things by listening to what another needs; intimacy - sexual intimacy and emotional intimacy on both sides and most of all, honesty - whether that's in the form of monogamy, or not.