I gotta say. As someone who has met a puppygirl. What A Fucking Essay
Ok no I have further thoughts here are my further thoughts.
1. The puppygirl was able to make herself a sandwich and buy herself little treats and play games. Therefore the puppygirl is physically and mentally capable of performing small menial tasks. The puppygirl can clean, to some extent. The puppygirl has mental energy she could theoretically put towards helping the household, to some extent. The puppygirl is absolutely choosing not to do that work. I am not saying the puppygirl can do all the things perhaps expected of the average person but she can definitely do some things that she is choosing not to. And I'm sorry I'm sorry but feeling anxious is not a good reason not to clean up after yourself. Feeling unloved isn't either. At some point in life you have to do things that are inconvenient or uncomfortable or boring or scary and people having expectations of that is not unreasonable or hurtful
2. If you have a breakdown when something comes up that is incredibly distressing to you that's just life. If you have a breakdown EVERY TIME IT IS MENTIONED, to the extent that your partners can't even ask you to stack the fucking dishwasher, you are being completely unreasonable and it is a very valid reaction for them to stop accepting your meltdowns as currency. Part of the lot of living with anxiety is learning ways to engage with things that don't set you off. Maybe the puppygirl could message. Maybe she could write letters. She needed to actually try. A meltdown does not excuse you from life.
3. This is a controversial take but I'm gonna say it anyway. Actually preface first: the puppygirl is NOT a uniquely trans phenomenon. She is the sister of "girl math" and "damn bitch you live like this?". This is where I disagree with tara because I do not think the puppygirl is toxic masculinity I think she's toxic femininity. I think she's a girl that's asked herself what the girliest girl possible looks like and come up with the answer of "helpless". She's just a girl. Just a stupid girl. The puppygirl is acting out the worst version of womanhood and calling it her identity. The puppygirl is a fucking tradwife, minus the housework.
4. There are plenty of disabled people who contribute to their households. The level to which they can contribute varies. This essay is not ABOUT that. Being disabled has nothing to do with the puppygirl. An able bodied woman can be a puppygirl. Being the puppygirl is about refusing to take responsibility for yourself and the things you can do. It's about being the main character and the weakest and the softest and making that everyone else's problem
Yeah I can distill this down into like one para actually, here we go:
There is a subset of women who use the narrative that women are soft and weak and helpless to excuse themselves from any and all responsibility and accountability in life. Disability or disadvantage may play into how this starts, but the characteristic trait is always the insistence by these women themselves that they "need to be protected" - from work, from responsibility, and from life. The puppygirl is one archetype of this sort of woman, who couches her denial of accountability in leftist rhetoric. This, dare I fucking say it, is bad























