Can you hear me out on a theory I have , like it’s definitely not an original theory probably but like
So we know scar is stuck in the sunflower field , or at least it seems that way. Now instead of the whole lizzies falling theory (as much as I like Lizzie I don’t like the theory all that much) and instead i believe that he’s stuck there due to grian. Grian who had said that 3rd life was their double win, and the watchers couldn’t really punish grian since well he knows how to escape them , but they could punish scar instead if the man won again. By trapping him in the season that he was at his loneliness, leaving him with the flowers who only look towards the sun , like scar looking towards grian in the desert. But I like to think that as more time passes, scar becomes tired and allows himself to sit amongst the flowers, who as they turn to watch the sun, begin to trap him with their roots slowly over time. Until one day scar is moving with them to see the sun, but he see’s grian, though he is unaware it’s him since grian is in his third life shrike era , and to scar that is unrecognisable not only due to him being alone for so long but because I feel like his memory woukd be going. And it’s like how people say theyre stuck in the desert, but scar is tuck in the sunflower field, surrounded by a grian who isnt really there, one who he doesn’t truly know Is there instead and is just a figment of his memories trying to come back to him. Bjt he is kept out if reach and scar eventually succumbs to the sunflowers and dies and is then in wild life, where by accident he recreates 3rd life but with the wrong avian, believing that Jimmy was who he had seen, whilst grian is with Mumbo and skizz. And once scar dies he is then taken back to the sunflowers and fields where he lays until the next life, past life, where he goes with etho and budbs who had been part of maybe an alliance in last life but they didn’t really care for it , which is why the family falls apart, and also due to all the fires. The fires which are only there due to it being hot enough (like the desert).
Sorrry this is really far fetched but I was so bored and needed to tell someone
OOOH, I LIKE
Grian is stuck in the desert, Scar is stuck in the sunflower field gazing upon a blurry reflection of the desert
YESS ITS EXACTLY THAT , LIKE DONT GET ME WRONG THE LIZZIE THWORY IS AMAZING BUT I FEEL LIKE IT BASICALLY CANCLES OUT SCAR’S WIN LIKE PEOPLE DO TO CLEO’S
YES
AND CLEO'S WIN IS SO VALID AND SO IGNORED OH MY VOID DO NOT GET ME STARTED
I DONT GET HOW PEOPLE DONT COUNT IT, LIKE ARGUABLY THEIR LIFE SRRIES WAS THE HARDEST EVEN IF IT WAS ONLY ONE EPISODE
EXACTLY
LIKE JOEL, A WINNER HIMSELF, WAS THROWING UP THE WHOLE DAMN TIME!
YES, IVE TIRED TO TELLT HAT TO PEOPLE AND THEY JUST COME BACK WITH “OH IT WAS ONE EPISODE” LIKE HAVE YOU EVER PLAYED VR MATE? ITS FUCKING DISORIENTING AND MAKES YIU FEEL ILL , SPECIALLY WHEN YOU HAVE TO MOST LIKELY RELEARN HOW TO PLAY AND STUFF ITS EVN WORSE
