I know it's cringe as an american to play devil's advocate for other american's behaviors abroad, but I was reading this reddit thread about annoying american abroad habits, and most were fair, like yeah we dumb & rude I get ittttt blah blah blah. but then there were people complaining that american's will answer "where are you from?" with their town & state and the prevailing attitude was like "isn't that just like an american to think we know all their one horse towns" and idk I think we're just friendly lmao. like I would also take that question as a conversation starter. if I met an austrailian and asked where they were from and they said "australia" i'd be like no shit sherlock lol. I don't know beepboopville queensland, but I can't ask about it if you don't tell me. as if any of us yanks know the majority of the municipalities in the united states. if someone told me they were from googoogaga iowa I'd be like wow, never heard of it. tell me more. so that's the one thing I think ppl are misjudging americans on.
I live in Ireland now and every time I say I’m from the States they ask me which one. I think you’re right that it’s a friendly conversation starter to give a specific answer.
100% I think people complaining about this are complaining about the wrong cultural difference. It's not "Americans think we all know their geography," it's "Americans love to chit-chat with strangers and assume everybody else wants to, too."
It's literally the answer to the question that was asked, some people just enjoy being mad for no reason.
Alright internationals! Let's start answering "where are you from" with your municipality and not country! XD
when you, as an American are asked, where you are from, especially in countries where the native language is not English, the chances are high that they do indeed not know which country you are from because people oftentimes can't tell your accents apart. It's easy to say "USA" and maybe people will then ask "oh where exactly" because they know it's a huge ass country, there you go, you can start to go in-depth without being culturally condescending
If someone tells me they're from the USA or Australia or whatever I'm not gonna think to myself "no shit sherlock". I can't tell people apart by accent, I am barely able to place the most common german dialects. Sometimes this website is so utterly anglo-centric, for lack of a better term.
So I feel like there's two things going on here:
1. I do notice that people from my country who have never been to america or don't actually know any americans will harbor a ridiculous amount of hate and superiority towards americans just because of what they see in the media. It's objectively stupid and deserves to be called out. Japan is praised for it's politeness culture and the USA is seen as ingenuine stupid idiots for the same thing. People love to hate on the US for anything and everything.
2. You are misunderstanding why people dislike when americans mention their town instead of their country. The issue is not "oh that's tmi i don't need to know the exact spot", the issue is that they are not actually answering the question in a way the other person can understand. Saying "I'm from the US, specifically beepboopville" is fine and nice conversation, saying "I'm from beepboopville" with no reference to any place I would actually know leaves me feeling stupid and needing to ask again where the hell you're from.
It's like asking someone where they got a shirt and you answer "aisle 3", like wtf? At what store?? Am i supposed to tell by your style where you shop at? If you're IN the store it's a fine response but saying that anywhere else is INSANE.
At the same time it's really not hard to ask "at what store/in what country" and people love to blow this out of proportion because USamerica=bad.
Ok hope this helps bye























